Item 2. Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Item 2.
Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
The
following discussion and analysis should be read in conjunction with our financial statements, included herewith. This discussion should
not be construed to imply that the results discussed herein will necessarily continue into the future, or that any conclusion reached
herein will necessarily be indicative of actual operating results in the future. Such discussion represents only the best present assessment
of our management. This information should also be read in conjunction with our audited historical financial statements which are included
in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2023, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on February
29, 2024.
Overview
Lightwave
Logic, Inc. (the “ Company ”) is a technology company focused on the development of next generation electro-optic photonic
devices made on its P 2 IC™ technology platform which we have detailed as: 1) Polymer Stack™, 2) Polymer Plus™,
and 3) Polymer Slot™. Our unique polymer technology platform uses in-house proprietary high-activity and high-stability organic
polymers. Electro-optical devices called modulators convert data from electric signals into optical signals for multiple applications.
Our differentiation
at the modulator device level is in higher speed, lower power consumption, simplicity of manufacturing, small footprint (size), and reliability.
We have demonstrated higher speed and lower power consumption in packaged devices, and during 2023, we continued to make advances in techniques
to translate our world class material properties to efficient, reliable modulator devices with commercial foundries. We are currently
focused on testing and demonstrating the simplicity of manufacturability and reliability of our devices, including in conjunction with
the silicon photonics manufacturing ecosystem. In 2023 we worked with silicon-based foundry partners to help scale in volume our polymer
modulator devices and we received working modulator chips from these foundries. We have advanced and matured our interactions with our
foundry partners and we continue to receive working modulator chips for prototyping. Silicon-based foundries are large semiconductor fabrication
plants developed for the electronics IC business, that are now engaging with silicon photonics to increase their wafer throughput. Partnering
with silicon-based foundries not only demonstrates that our polymer technology can be transferred into standard production lines using
standard equipment, it also allows us to efficiently utilize our capital. The foundry partnerships will allow us to scale our high-performance
polymer optical engines quickly and efficiently. We have now received silicon wafers that range up to 200mm in diameter, which aligns
well with foundry manufacturing. Using 200mm silicon wafers, we showed packaged polymer modulators operating with open (clean) eye diagrams
at 100GBaud PAM4 (or 200Gbps PAM4) at voltage drive levels at 1V at the 2024 Optical Fiber Conference in San Diego, California in
March 2024 (“ OFC 2024 "). OFC is a leading international conference bringing together the complete value chain of fiber
communications, datacentric, and telecommunications industrial players. We also showed polymer modulators with voltage drive levels that
were below 1V. Driving voltage levels of around 1V is important as it allows our polymer modulators to be driven directly from CMOS ICs
(as opposed to dedicated driver integrated circuit chips). This performance is ideal to enable 4 lanes at 200Gbps per lane pluggable transceivers
that can operate at an aggregate data rate of 800Gbps. Since the invited talk at OFC 2024, a number of Tier 1 pluggable transceiver companies
have both reviewed our technical results and viewed operating packaged polymer slot modulators at 200Gbps PAM4 with drive voltages at
1V.
Our extremely
strong and broad patent portfolio allows us to optimize our business model in three areas: 1) Traditional focus on product development,
2) Patent licensing and 3) Technology transfer to foundries. We are continually looking to strengthen our patent portfolio both by internal
inventions and acquisition of intellectual property.
We are
initially targeting applications in fiber optic data communications and telecommunications markets and are exploring other applications
that include automotive/LIDAR, sensing, displays etc., for our polymer technology platform. Our goal is to have our unique polymer technology
platform become ubiquitous across many market verticals over and above the optical fiber optic communications markets.
Generative
Artificial Intelligence (G-AI) has been integrating deeper within our daily activities with applications to make us more efficient and
possibly smarter. The impact on the internet is huge, and the internet is based on an optical network that utilizes data centers to route
and switch traffic or information to and from destinations. Data centers are being upgraded today in a fashion that the industry has not
seen before with significant investments of capital. The expected demands of increased traffic, information, and data driven by G-AI is
changing the way the internet is being operated. G-AI is now creating new and interesting market opportunities to upgrade the internet.
Three of these opportunities are important today: density, speed, and low power and these are very well aligned with our high performance
electro-optic polymers modulator platform. We are designing high performance polymer modulator optical engines to support the rise and
growth of G-AI as it generates more information that will travel through the internet and optical network. While we are not directly a
G-AI company designing electronic processors, we do see immediate benefits of enabling higher levels of information to cross the internet
using our optical polymer modulator platform.
20
Commencement of Commercial Operations
We commenced
commercial operations in May 2023. Presently, our commercial operations consist of a material
supply license agreement to provide Perkinamine ® chromophore materials for polymer based photonic devices and photonic
integrated circuits (PICs). The license agreement represents tangible commercial progress for electro-optic polymers as part of our Company's
business plan. Our Company is also in various stages of photonic device and materials development and evaluation with potential
customers and strategic partners. We expect to continue to obtain a revenue stream from technology licensing agreements, and to obtain
additional revenue streams from technology transfer agreements and direct sale of our electro-optic device components. We have seen increased
interest in our materials during 2023, which has continued into 2024 and we are in discussions on future license agreements.
Materials Development
Our
Company designs and synthesizes organic chromophores for use in its own proprietary electro-optic polymer systems and
photonic device designs. A polymer system is not solely a material, but also encompasses various technical enhancements necessary for
its implementation. These include host polymers, poling methodologies, and molecular spacer systems that are customized to achieve specific
optical properties. Our organic electro-optic polymer systems compounds are mixed into solution form that allows for thin film application.
Our proprietary electro-optic polymers are designed at the molecular level for potentially superior performance, stability, and cost-efficiency.
We believe our proprietary and unique polymers have the potential to replace more expensive, higher power consuming, slower-performance
materials such as semiconductor-based modulator devices that are used in fiber-optic communication networks today.
Our patented
and patent pending molecular architectures are based on a well-understood chemical and quantum mechanical occurrence known as aromaticity .
Aromaticity provides a high degree of molecular stability that enables our core molecular structures to maintain stability under a broad
range of operating conditions.
We expect
our patented and patent-pending optical materials along with trade secrets and licensed materials, to be the core of and the enabling
technology for future generations of optical devices, modules, sub-systems, and systems that we will develop or enable our partners to
fully commercialize. Examples of our partners include: electro-optic device manufacturers, contract manufacturers, original equipment
manufacturers, foundries, packaging and assembly manufacturers etc. Our Company contemplates future applications in market verticals that
may address the needs of semiconductor companies, optical network companies, Web 2.0/3.0 media companies, high performance computing companies,
telecommunications companies, aerospace companies, automotive companies, as well as for example, government agencies and defense entities.
Device Design and Development
Electro-optic Modulators
Our
Company designs its own proprietary electro-optical modulation devices. Electro-optical modulators convert data from electric signals
into optical signals that can then be transmitted over high-speed fiber-optic cables. Our modulators are electro-optic, meaning they work
because the optical properties of the polymers are affected by electric fields applied by means of electrodes. Modulators are key components
that are used in fiber optic telecommunications, data communications, and data centers networks etc., to convey the high data flows that
have been driven by applications such as pictures, video streaming, movies etc., that are being transmitted through the Internet. Electro-optical
modulators are expected to continue to be an essential element as the appetite and hunger for data increases every year as well as the
drive towards lower power consumption, and smaller footprint (size).
Polymer Photonic Integrated
Circuits
Our Company
also designs its own proprietary Photonic Integrated Circuits (otherwise termed a polymer PIC). A polymer PIC is a photonic device that
integrates several photonic functions on a single chip. We believe that our technology can enable an ultra-miniaturization footprint that
is needed to increase the number of photonic functions residing on a semiconductor chip. We see this creating a progression like what
was seen in the computer integrated circuits, commonly referred to as Moore’s Law. One type of integration is to combine several
instances of the same photonic functions such as a plurality of modulators to create a multi-lane polymer PIC. The number of lanes can
be varied depending on application. For example, the number of photonic components could increase by a factor of 4, 8, or 16. Another
type of integration is to combine different types of devices including from different technology bases such as the combination of a semiconductor
laser with a polymer modulator. Our P 2 IC™ platform encompasses both these types of architecture.
21
Current
semiconductor photonic technology today is both struggling to reach faster device speeds as well as seamless integration with commercial
silicon foundries. Our modulator devices, enabled by our electro-optic polymer material systems, work at extremely high frequencies (wide
bandwidths) and possess inherent advantages over current crystalline electro-optic material contained in most modulator devices such as
bulk lithium niobate (LiNbO3), indium phosphide (InP), silicon (Si), and gallium arsenide (GaAs). Our advanced electro-optic polymer platform
is creating a new class of modulators such as the Polymer Stack™, Polymer Plus™, Polymer Slot™, and associated PIC platforms
that can address higher data rates in a lower cost, lower power consuming manner, smaller footprint (size) with much simpler data encoding
techniques. Our electro-optic polymer material will boost the performance of standard PIC platforms such as silicon photonics and indium
phosphide. Further, with our recent demonstration of packaged polymer slot modulator devices fabricated onto commercial silicon 200mm
wafers using a commercial silicon foundry, our electro-optic polymer material is much easier to integrate with silicon foundries compared
to competitive crystalline electro-optic materials.
Our electro-optic
polymers can be integrated with other materials platforms because they can be applied as a thin film coating in a fabrication clean room
such as may be found in semiconductor foundries using standard clean room tooling. These approaches enable our Polymer Plus™ and
Polymer Slot™ device platforms to not only be competitive but fully integrated with foundries. Our polymers are unique in that they
are stable enough to seamlessly integrate into existing CMOS, Indium Phosphide (InP), Gallium Arsenide (GaAs), and other semiconductor
manufacturing lines. Of relevance are the integrated silicon photonics platforms that combine optical and electronic functions. These
include a miniaturized modulator for ultra-small footprint applications in which we term the Polymer Slot™. This design is based
on a slot modulator fabricated into semiconductor wafers that can include either silicon or indium phosphide.
Our Company has a fabrication
facility in Colorado to apply standard fabrication processes to our electro-optic polymers which create modulator devices. While our internal
fabrication facility is capable of manufacturing modulator devices, we have partnered with commercial silicon-based fabrication companies
that are called foundries who can scale our technology with volume quickly and efficiently. The process recipe for fabrication plants
or foundries is called a ‘process development kit’ or PDK. We are currently working with commercial foundries to implement
our electro-optic polymers into accepted PDKs by the foundries. One of the metrics for successful implementation of PDK is to receive
working modulator chips. Our work with the foundries is being focused with the Polymer Plus™ and the Polymer Slot™ polymer
modulators. We are currently receiving 200mm silicon wafers with our Polymer Slot™ modulator designs from AMF, a silicon photonics
foundry based in Singapore.
Business Strategy
Our first
revenue stream was obtained from our entry into a material supply license agreement to provide Perkinamine ® chromophore
materials for polymer based photonic devices and photonic integrated circuits (PICs). Our Company is also in various stages of photonic
device and materials development and evaluation with potential customers and strategic partners that include Tier 1 players in the fiber
optic communications industry. We expect to continue to obtain a revenue stream from technology licensing agreements, and to obtain additional
revenue streams from technology transfer agreements and direct sale of our electro-optic device components.
Specifically,
our business strategy provides that our revenue stream will be derived from one or some combination of the following: (i) technology licensing
for specific product application; (ii) joint venture relationships with significant industry leaders; and (iii) the production and direct
sale of our own electro-optic device components. Our objective is to be a leading provider of proprietary technology and know-how in the
electro-optic device market. In order to meet this objective, we intend to continue to:
•
Further the development of proprietary organic electro-optic polymer material systems
•
Develop photonic devices based on our P 2 IC™technology
•
Develop proprietary intellectual property
•
Grow our commercial device development capabilities
•
Partner with silicon-based foundries who can scale volume quickly
•
Grow our product reliability and quality assurance capabilities
•
Grow our optoelectronic packaging and testing capabilities
•
Grow our commercial material manufacturing capabilities
•
Maintain/develop strategic relationships with major telecommunications and data communications companies to further the awareness and commercialization of our technology platform
•
Add high-level personnel with industrial and manufacturing experience in key areas of our materials and device development programs.
22
Create Organic Polymer-Enabled
Electro-Optic Modulators
We
intend to utilize our proprietary optical polymer technology to create an initial portfolio of commercial electro-optic polymer product
devices with applications for various markets, including telecommunications, data communications and data centers. These product devices
will be part of our proprietary photonics integrated circuit (PIC) technology platform .
We expect
our initial modulator products will operate at symbol rates at least 112 Gigabaud which is roughly 200Gbps when utilized with PAM4 encoding
schemes that aligns with our recent package polymer slot modulator results presented at OFC 2024. Our devices are highly linear, and can
also enable the performance required to take advantage of more advance complex encoding schemes if required.
Our Proprietary Products in Development
As
part of a tactical marketing strategy, our Company is developing several optical devices using our proprietary electro-optical polymer
material, which are in various stages of development. These include:
Ridge Waveguide Modulator,
Polymer Stack ™
Our ridge electro-optic waveguide
modulator was designed and fabricated in our in-house laboratory. The fabrication of our first in-house device is significant to our entire
device program and is an important starting point for modulators that are being developed for target markets. We have multiple generations
of new materials that we will soon be optimizing for this specific design. In September 2017 we announced that our initial alpha prototype
ridge waveguide modulator, enabled by our P 2 IC™ polymer system, demonstrated
bandwidth performance levels that will enable 112 Gbaud modulation in fiber-optic communications. This device demonstrated true amplitude
(intensity) modulation in a Mach-Zehnder modulator structure incorporating our polymer waveguides. This important achievement will allow
users to utilize arrays of 4 x 112 Gbaud symbol rate (4x 200 Gbps data rate) polymer modulators using PAM-4 encoding to enable 800 Gbps
data rate systems. These ridge waveguide modulators are currently being packaged with our partner into prototype packages .
These
prototype packages will enable potential customers to evaluate the performance at 112 Gbaud. Once a potential customer generates technical
feedback on our prototype, we expect to be asked to optimize the performance to their specifications. Assuming this is successful, we
expect to enter a qualification phase where our prototypes will be evaluated more fully .
In
parallel, we are developing modulators for scalability to higher symbol rates above 112 Gbaud. In September 2018, we showed in conference
presentations the potential of our polymer modulator platform to operate at over 100 GHz bandwidth. This preliminary result corresponds
to 100 Gbps data rates using a simple NRZ data encoding scheme or 200 Gbps with PAM-4 encoding. With 4 lane arrays in our P 2 IC™
platform, the Company thus has the potential to address both 400 Gbps and 800 Gbps markets. While customers may start the engagement at
112 Gbaud, we believe potential customers recognize that scalability to higher speeds is an important differentiator of the polymer technology .
We
believe the ridge waveguide modulator Polymer Stack™ represents our first commercially viable device and targets the fiber optics
communications market. We have completed internal market analysis and are initially targeting interconnect reach distances of less than
1km. In these markets, the system network companies are looking to implement modulator-based transceivers that can handle aggregated data
rates 800 Gbps and above. The market opportunity for less than 10km is worth over $2B over the next decade.
Polymer Plus™
Using
our novel waveguide design, we are developing a more compact modulator to be implemented directly with existing integrated photonics platforms
such as silicon photonics and Indium Phosphide. As our electro-optic polymers are applied in liquid form, they can be deposited as a thin
film coating in a fabrication clean room such as may be found in semiconductor foundries. This approach we call Polymer Plus™. The
advantage of this approach is that it allows existing semiconductor integrated photonics platforms such as silicon photonics and indium
phosphide to be upgraded with higher speed modulation functionality with the use of polymers in a straight-forward and simple approach.
Further, our polymers are unique in that they are stable enough to seamlessly integrate into existing CMOS, Indium Phosphide (InP), Gallium
Arsenide (GaAs), and other semiconductor manufacturing lines.
A large
majority of commercial silicon photonics platforms utilize large silicon photonics foundries such as those that manufacture IC products
for a number of applications such as communications, computing, consumer, etc. In order to seamlessly integrate our polymer materials
to upgrade for example, silicon photonics designs, partnering with a silicon foundry is necessary.
23
Polymer Slot™
As
part of supporting further improvement and scalability of our platform, we continue to develop more advanced device structures that include
the Polymer Slot™. Our high performance, low power, extremely small footprint polymer photonics slot waveguide modulator utilizes
a slot design that is part of PIC platform such as silicon photonics with one of our proprietary electro-optic polymer material systems
as the enabling material layer. Performance results in 2023 from commercial foundries achieved key design specifications for the slot
modulator.
Preliminary
testing and initial data on our polymer photonics slot waveguide modulators fabricated at commercial foundries demonstrated extremely
high performance suitable for the hyperscaler and fiber optics markets. The tested polymer photonic slot chip had less than 1-millimeter
square footprint, enabling the possibility of sophisticated PIC architecture designs on a single silicon substrate. In addition, the waveguide
structure was a fraction of the length of a typical inorganic-based silicon photonics modulator waveguide and is suitable to be used as
an engine for state-of-the-art pluggable transceiver modules such as the OSFP and the QSFP-DD.
With
the combination of our proprietary electro-optic polymer material and the extremely high optical field concentration in the slot waveguide,
the test modulators demonstrated very low operating voltage. Initial speeds exceeded 70GHz in the telecom, 1310nm, and 1550 nanometer
frequency bands, and there were devices that exceeded over 100GHz 3dB bandwidth.
We are
also continuing our collaborative development of our polymer photonic slot waveguide modulators (Polymer Slot™) with a partner that
has advanced device design capabilities using Plasmonic technologies. Some of these devices demonstrated performance levels that exceeded
250GHz in 2022 with our partners.
Our
Long-Term Device Development Goal - Multilane Polymer Photonic Integrated Circuit (P 2 IC™)
Our P 2 IC™
platform is positioned to address markets with aggregated data rates of 100 Gbps, 400 Gbps, 800 Gbps and beyond. Our P 2 IC™
platform will contain several photonic devices that may include, over and above polymer-based modulators, photonic devices such as lasers,
multiplexers, demultiplexers, detectors, fiber couplers.
While our polymer-based ridge waveguide and slot modulators are currently
under development to be commercially viable products, our long-term device development goal is to produce a platform for the 400 Gbps,
800 Gbps, 1600Gbps and beyond fiber optic transceiver market. This has been stated in our photonics product roadmap that is publicly available
on our website. The roadmap shows a progression in speed from 50 Gbaud based modulators to 100 Gbaud based modulators. The roadmap shows
a progression in integration in which the modulators are arrayed to create a flexible, multilane P 2 IC™ platform that
spans 100 Gbps, 400 Gbps, 800 Gbps, 1.6Tbps (or 1600Gbps), and a scaling philosophy that will grow to 3.2Tbps line rates.
We showed
bandwidths of polymer-based modulator devices at a major international conference (ECOC – European Conference on Optical Communications
2018) with bandwidths that exceeded 100GHz. We noted that to achieve 100Gbaud, the polymer-based modulator only needs to achieve 80GHz
bandwidth. During ECOC 2019, we showed environmental stability. We continue to develop our polymer materials and device designs to optimize
additional metrics. We are now optimizing the device parameters for very low voltage operation. At the ECOC 2022 conference we demonstrated
two different world record performances using polymer slot-based modulators. In an invited presentation at OFC 2024 in San Diego, we presented
data that showed our packaged polymer slot modulators operating with open (clean) eye diagrams at 100GBaud PAM4 (or 200Gbps PAM4) at voltage
drive levels at 1V. We also showed polymer modulators with voltage drive levels that were below 1V. Driving voltage levels of around 1V
is important as it allows our polymer modulators to be driven directly from CMOS ICs (as opposed to dedicated driver integrated circuit
chips).
Our
Target Markets
Cloud computing and data
centers
Big
data is a general term used to describe the voluminous amount of unstructured and semi-structured data a Company creates – data
that would take too much time and cost too much money to load into a relational database for analysis. Companies are looking to cloud
computing in their data centers to access all the data. Inherent speed and bandwidth limits of traditional solutions and the potential
of organic polymer devices offer an opportunity to increase the bandwidth, reduce costs, improve speed of access, and to reduce power
consumption both at the device as well as the system level.
Datacenters
have grown to enormous sizes with hundreds of thousands and even millions of servers in a single datacenter. The number of so-called “hyperscale”
datacenters are expected to continue to increase in number. Due to their size, a single “datacenter” may consist of multiple
large warehouse-size buildings on a campus or even several locations distributed around a metropolitan area. Data centers are confronted
with the problem of moving vast amounts of data not only around a single data center building, but also between buildings in distributed
data center architecture. Links within a single datacenter building may be shorter than 500 meters, though some will require optics capable
of 2 km. Between datacenter buildings, there is an increasing need for high performance interconnects over 10km in reach.
24
Our modulators
are suitable for single-mode fiber optic links. We believe that our single mode modulator solutions will be competitive at 500m to 10km
link distance lengths, with inherent advantages for 800Gbps applications.
Telecommunications/Data
Communications
The
telecommunications industry has evolved from transporting traditional analogue voice data over copper wire into the movement of digital
voice and data. Telecommunication companies are faced with the enormous increasing challenges to keep up with the resulting tremendous
explosion in demand for bandwidth. The metropolitan network is especially under stress now and into the near future. Telecommunications
companies provide services to some data center customers for the inter-data center connections discussed above. 5G mobile upgrade, autonomous
driving and IoT are expected to increase the need for data stored and processed close to the end user in edge data centers. This application
similarly requires optics capable of very high speeds and greater than 10 km reach.
Industry issues of scaling
The
key issues facing the fiber-optic communications industry are the economic progress and scalability of any PIC based technological platform.
Our polymer platform is unique in that it is truly scalable and is expected to become a high-performance engine for transceiver modules.
Scalable means being able to scale up for high-speed data rates, while simultaneously being able to scale down in cost, and lower power
consumption. This allows a competitive cost per data rate or cost per Gbps metric to be achieved .
Fiber
optic datacenter and high-performance computing customers want to achieve the metric of $1/Gbps @ 800Gbps (this essentially means a single
mode fiber optic link that has a total cost of $800 and operates with a data rate of 800Gbps). Equally importantly, the datacenter industry
would like to reduce the power consumption of optical ports for 400Gbps, 800Gbps, etc., significantly. As industry tries to match this
target, it needs scalable PIC platforms to achieve this goal, of which our polymer platform is uniquely suited.
An article
by Dr. Michael Lebby that was recently published in broadband communities (BBC) magazine in early February 2023 discusses the virtues
of polymer-based technologies as part of an industry technology roadmap. The article is entitled ‘The internet is the brick wall
Nostradamus did not see coming.” In this article cost/performance metrics are discussed that show the trend to higher and higher
data rates using PIC platforms that include very high speed, low power modulator devices.
The
article also shows that electro-optic polymers play an important role in PICs over the next decade as they can reduce or close the gap
between customer expectations and technical performance through effective scaling increase of high performance with low cost for short
distance transceiver optical links.
25
Some
of the things needed to achieve the scaling performance of polymers in integrated photonics platforms is within sight today:
1. Increased
r33 (which leads to very low Vpi in modulator devices) and we are currently optimizing our polymers for this. With Vpi levels of 1V or
less will enable direct from associated electronics and potentially save network architects the cost of individual driver ICs.
2. Increase
temperature stability so that the polymers can operate at broader temperature ranges effective, where we have made significant progress
over the past few years .
3. Low
optical loss in waveguides and active/passive devices for improved optical budget metrics which is currently an ongoing development program
at our Company.
4. Higher
levels of hermeticity for lower cost packaging of optical sub-assemblies within a transceiver module, where our advanced designs are
being implemented into polymer-based packages that utilize atomic layer deposition (ALD) that is being developed in-house.
Scalability
in terms of cost reduction and high volume manufacturing can be enhanced by:
1. Leverage
of commercial silicon photonics manufacturing capacity through the use of silicon-based foundries. Our Polymer Plus™ platform seeks
to be additive to standard silicon photonics circuits .
2. Reduction
of optical packaging costs by integration at the chip level of multiple modulators and also with other optical devices. Our P 2 IC™
platform seeks to address device integration .
Scalability
in terms of cost reduction and high-volume manufacturing can be enhanced by:
1. Leverage
of commercial silicon photonics manufacturing capacity through the use of commercial silicon-based foundries running 200mm silicon wafers.
Our Polymer Plus™ platform seeks to be additive to standard silicon photonics circuits.
2. Reduction
of optical packaging costs by integration at the chip level of multiple modulators and also with other optical devices. Our P2IC™
platform seeks to address device integration .
26
The above
graphic shows the Company electro-optic material design philosophy of increased glass transition temperature. When the materials are designed
with Tg above 170C, this equates to approximately 100C above the normal operating temperatures in a data center environment. This feature
increases the material reliability significantly. Further, as the spider chart on the right of the above graphic indicates that key performance
metrics of the Company’s electro-optic chromophores perform well against competition in parameters such as photostability, decomposition
temperature, voltage, absorbance, glass transition temperature, and r33 (electro-optic efficiency). This positions the Company’s
materials very well in the marketplace and eliminates the need to cross-link the polymers which jeopardizes stability and reliability.
27
The above
graphic shows the increasing trend of improved electro-optic chromophores that have been developed by the Company. The graphic details
improvements in r33, a measure of electro-optic efficiency of Perkinamine® electro-optic material. The r33 has improved using a box
plot, approximately over 5X during the past 7 years, and is now very stable in testing.
The above
graphic shows the increasing trend of improved electro-optic chromophores that have been developed by the Company in respect to decomposition
temperature. The graphic details improvements in Td showing through the box plot extremely tight and improved material thermal stability
over the past 3 years, and excellent results over the past year.
28
The above
graphic shows the increasing trend of improved electro-optic chromophores that have been developed by the Company in respect to glass
transition temperature. The graphic details improvements in Tg showing through the box plot extremely tight and improved material with
Tg’s above 170C with tight control of the materials performance as measured in thin films.
Recent Significant Events and Milestones Achieved
During
February and March 2018, we moved our Newark, Delaware synthetic laboratory and our Longmont, Colorado optical testing laboratory and
corporate headquarters to office, laboratory and research and development space located at 369 Inverness Parkway, Suite 350, Englewood,
Colorado. The 13,420 square feet Englewood facility includes fully functional 1,000 square feet of class 1,000 cleanroom, 500 square feet
of class 10,000 cleanroom, chemistry laboratories, and analytic laboratories. The Englewood facility streamlines all of our Company’s
research and development workflow for greater operational efficiencies.
During
March 2018, our Company, together with our packaging partner, successfully demonstrated packaged polymer modulators designed for 50Gbaud,
which we believe will allow us to scale our P 2 IC™ platform with our Mach-Zehnder ridge waveguide modulator design as
well as other photonics devices competitively in the 100Gbps and 400Gbps datacom and telecommunications applications market. We are currently
fine-tuning the performance parameters of these prototypes in preparation for customer evaluations.
During
June 2018, our Company Acquired the Polymer Technology Intellectual Property Assets of BrPhotonics Productos Optoelectrónicos S.A.,
a Brazilian corporation, which significantly advanced our patent portfolio of electro-optic polymer technology with 15 polymer chemistry
materials, devices, packaging and subsystems patent and further strengthened our design capabilities to solidify our market position as
we prepare to enter the 400Gbps integrated photonics marketplace with a highly competitive, scalable alternative to installed legacy systems.
Also,
during June 2018, our Company promoted polymer PICs and Solidified Polymer PICs as Part of the Photonics Roadmap at the World Technology
Mapping Forum in Enschede, Netherlands, which includes our Company’s technology of polymers and polymer PICs that have the potential
to drive not only 400Gbps aggregate data rate solutions, but also 800Gbps and beyond.
29
In August
2018 we announced the completion (ahead of schedule) of our fully equipped on-site fabrication facility, where we are expanding our high-speed
test and design capabilities. We also announced the continuation of the building of our internal expertise with the hiring of world-class
technical personnel with 100Gbps experience.
In February
2019 we announced a major breakthrough in our development of clean technology polymer materials that target the insatiable demand for
fast and efficient data communications in the multi-billion-dollar telecom and data markets supporting Internet, 5G and IoT (Internet
of Things) webscale services. The improved thermally stable polymer has more than double the electro-optic response of our previous materials,
enabling optical device performance of well over 100 GHz with extremely low power requirements. This addition to the family of Perkinamine TM polymers
will hold back run-away consumption of resources and energy needed to support ever-growing data consumption demands. We continue to conduct
testing of the material and assessment of associated manufacturing processes and device structures prior to release to full development.
In
March 2019 we created an Advisory Board comprised of three world-class leaders in the photonics industry: Dr. Craig Ciesla, Dr. Christoph
S. Harder, and Mr. Andreas Umbach. In January 2022 Dr. Ciesla was named to our Board of Directors, and our Advisory Board is currently
comprised of Dr. Franky So, Dr. Christoph S. Harder, Mr. Andreas Umbach and Dr. Joseph A. Miller, who is a former member of our Board
of Directors. The Advisory Board is working closely with our Company leadership to enhance our Company’s product positioning and
promote our polymer modulator made on our proprietary Faster by Design ™ polymer P 2 IC™ platform. The mission
of the Advisory Board is initially to increase our Company’s outreach into the datacenter interconnect market and later to support
expansion into other billion-dollar markets. The Advisory Board members have each been chosen for their combination of deep technical
expertise, breadth of experience and industry relationships in the fields of fiber optics communications, polymer and semiconductor materials.
Each of the Advisory Board members has experience at both innovators like Lightwave Logic and large industry leaders of the type most
likely to adopt game-changing polymer-based products. In addition, they possess operational experience with semiconductor and polymer
businesses.
Also,
in March 2019, our Company received the “Best Achievement in PIC Platform” award for our 100 GHz polymer platform from the
PIC International Conference. The award recognizes innovative advances in the development and application of key materials systems driving
today’s photonic integrated circuits (PICs) and providing a steppingstone to future devices.
During
the second quarter of 2019, our Company promoted its polymers at CoInnovate in May and the World Technology Mapping Forum in June. CoInnovate
is a meeting of semiconductor industry experts. The World Technology Mapping Forum is a group authoring a photonics roadmap out to 2040.
In September
2019 at the prestigious European Conference on Communications (ECOC) in Dublin, Ireland, we showed measured material response over frequency
and the resulting optical data bits stream on our clean technology polymer materials, the newest addition to our family of Perkinamine™ polymers,
that meet and exceed of our near-term target speed of 80 GHz. We also released data demonstrating stability under elevated temperatures
in the activated (poled to create data carrying capability) state.
In October
2019, we reported that energy-saving polymer technology is highlighted in the recently published Integrated Photonics Systems Roadmap
- International (IPSR-I). The roadmap validates the need for low-voltage, high-speed technologies such as ours.
In May
2020, we announced that our latest electro-optic polymer material has exceeded target performance metrics at 1310 nanometers (nm), a wavelength
commonly used in high-volume datacenter fiber optics. This material demonstrates an attractive combination at 1310 nm of high electro-optic
coefficient, low optical loss and good thermal stability at 85 0 Celsius. The material is expected to enable modulators
with 80 GHz bandwidth and low drive power, and has an electro-optic coefficient of 200 pm/V, an industry measure of how responsive a material
is to an applied electrical signal. This metric, otherwise known as r33, is very important in lowering power consumption when the material
is used in modulator devices. This technology is applicable to shorter reach datacenter operators, for whom decreasing power consumption
is imperative to the bottom line of a facility. We considered this a truly historic moment—not only in our Company’s history,
but in our industry–as we have demonstrated a polymer material that provides the basis for a world-class solution at the 1310 nm
wavelength, something which other companies have spent decades attempting to achieve.
In July
2020, we announced the official launch of our new corporate website www.lightwavelogic.com, reflecting ongoing efforts to provide up-to-date
information for investors and potential strategic partners. The revamped website offers a clean, modern design integrated with helpful
tools and investor relations resources, including a new corporate explainer video, to illustrate the target markets and advantages of
Lightwave Logic’s proprietary electro-optic polymers.
In
August 2020, we announced the addition of Dr. Franky So, a leading authority in the OLED industry, to our Advisory Board. Dr. So is the
Walter and Ida Freeman Distinguished Professor in the Department of Materials Science and Engineering at North Carolina State University.
Previously, he was the Head of Materials and Device research for OLEDs at OSRAM Opto Semiconductors, as well as Motorola’s corporate
research lab in the 1990s. Dr. So was an early researcher in electro-optic (EO) polymer modulators at Hoechst Celanese. As a member of
the Company’s advisory board, Dr. So will work closely with management to enhance Lightwave’s product positioning for, as
well as the promotion of, its polymer modulators made on its proprietary platform. In addition, he will provide technical support and
advisory services to the Lightwave materials and device teams.
30
On
October 7, 2020, we announced the receipt of U.S. Patent number 10,754,093 that improves both the performance and reliability of our high-speed,
low-power electro-optic polymer modulators intended for datacenter and telecommunications applications. The patent allows multi-layered
electro-optic polymer modulators to perform more efficiently through the design of custom interfaces. These interfaces are designed into
the cladding layers that allow optical transmission, electrical conductivity, material integrity, as well as a prevention of solvents
affecting adjacent polymer materials. The net impact of all of this allows for our Company’s modulators to improve performance across
the board, enabling higher reliability in the fiber optic communications environment .
On October
15, 2020, we announced that our proprietary polymer technologies are compatible with currently available integrated photonics platforms.
Our proprietary electro-optic materials are currently in the prototyping phase and are fabricated onto standard silicon wafers, and this
Polymer Plus™ advancement, driven by the feedback our Company received from potential customers to-date, has allowed our materials
to be suitable for additive integration to integrated photonics platforms such as silicon photonics, as well as indium phosphide and other
standard platforms – therefore enabling simpler integration by customers. We believe this breakthrough allows a polymer modulator
to enhance the performance of existing integrated photonics solutions in the marketplace, enabling higher speed and lower power consumption
on foundry-fabricated photonics designs. Since our technology is additive to existing platforms such as silicon photonics, our electro-optic
polymers are not actually competing with integrated photonic platforms, but rather enabling them to be more competitive in the marketplace,
and it further validates our EO polymer platform as ideally suited to enable optical networking more efficiently than ever.
On October
21, 2020, we announced that we have optimized a robust, photo-stable organic polymer material for use in our next-generation modulators
intended to be trialed with potential customers under NDA. Our materials show high tolerance to high-intensity infrared light, common
in a fiber optic communications environment and increasingly important as higher density of devices access the network, directly resulting
in higher intensity infrared light levels. Our preliminary results suggest that our recently developed electro-optic polymer material,
designed based on potential customer input, displays unrivaled light tolerance (also known as photostability) compared to any organic
commercial solution in use today. Our results meet both our current internal criteria and address potential customer feedback.
On November
2, 2020, we disclosed results on our polymer material stability testing including further results for electro-optic efficiency for our
Company’s materials that operate both at 1550nm as well as 1310nm. We demonstrated test materials results for electro-optic efficiency
to 4000hrs, improvement in sensitivity to oxygen as part of a broadband exposure test, and stability for polymers exposed to 1310nm light
at 100mW.
On November
20, 2020 we announced the receipt of U.S. Patent number 10,591,755 that details an important invention that allows users of electro-optic
polymer modulators to not only operate the devices with high speed and low power directly from CMOS IC chips, but gives them the opportunity
to avoid the expense, physical footprint and power consumption of high-speed modulator driver ICs. Furthermore, this patent strengthens
our freedom of manufacturing, and directly enables our modulators to become more competitive in the marketplace.
On December
16, 2020 we announced the development of a new sealant for our future Chip-on-Board (COB) packaged polymer platform. The sealant, which
blocks oxygen and other atmospheric gases, is a key step in our Company’s development towards a polymer modulator without a package,
an important enabling technology for the industry. We plan to develop the sealant for commercial implementation in our future modulators.
Recent results suggest that our electro-optic polymer sealant material displays encouraging barrier properties and is expected to translate
to significant improvement in bare chip robustness against atmospheric gases, as compared to existing EO polymer commercial solutions
in use today. While the initial measurements are highly promising, our Company plans to continue development work to further optimize
the sealant material and barrier performance towards the chip-on-board goal.
On
January 13, 2021, we announced the receipt of U.S. Patent number 10,886,694 that details an invention that allows electro-optic polymer
modulators to be packaged in a hermetic environment using well-known, high-volume and low-cost fabrication processes that are available
in a typical semiconductor fabrication foundry – improving suitability for mass production. Further, the design of this capsule
package can improve both the reliability and the coupling interface between fiber optic cables and their laser sources for arrayed photonic
integrated circuit solutions. The package can also interpose signals from an underlying circuit board to the polymer modulators, lasers,
and other components for data transfer. The hermetic capsule is built from a semiconductor base that contains electrical and optical circuits
and components. A hermetic capsule chamber is created by the design of a semiconductor lid that is sealed to the semiconductor base platform
by a metallization process. Using standardized fabrication techniques we can now create a package that achieves the performance, reliability,
cost, and volume requirements that has been a challenge for the photonics industry for years.
On
May 11, 2021, we announced the receipt of U.S. Patent number 10,989,871 that details an invention that allows for improved protective
polymer layers in modulators when designed into advanced integrated photonic platforms, better positioning them for high-volume manufacturing
processes. The protective layers will enhance electro-optic polymer devices' performance through higher reliability, better optical performance
and enable the use of standardized manufacturing processes best suited for mass-production.
31
On June
7, 2021, we announced that our company’s common stock was added to the Solactive EPIC
Core Photonics EUR Index NTR as part of the index's semi-annual additions. The index includes global public companies with a common theme
of optoelectronics, photonics, and optical technologies in general that range from components, modules, manufacturers, and optical network
system companies. This inclusion broadens our exposure to the capital markets community, as well as credibility with potential partners
and customers.
On
June 16, 2021, we announced test results from new modulators fabricated in 2021, which exceeded bandwidth
design targets and achieved triple the data rate as compared to competing devices in use today. The breakthrough new devices demonstrated
3dB electro-optical with electrical bandwidths that exceed 100GHz – with measurements coming close to our Company’s state-of-the-art
110GHz test equipment capability. We expect this advancement to have a profound impact on the traffic flow on the internet.
On
June 24, 2021, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,042,051 that details a
breakthrough new device design that enables mass-volume manufacturing when designed into advanced integrated photonic platforms. The
device design enhances reliability, improves optical mode control and most important, lowers by consumption through the use of direct-drive,
low-voltage operation. The patent is entitled, “Direct drive region-less polymer modulator methods of fabricating and materials
therefor” and is expected to open the opportunity for low power consumption electro-optic polymers to be developed into large foundry
PDKs (process development kits) and be ready for mass volume commercialization. The patent emphasizes our technology platform using fabrication
techniques that would naturally fit into foundry PDKs.
On
August 4, 2021, we announced that we developed improved thermal design properties for electro-optic polymers used in our Polymer Plus™
and Polymer Slot™ modulators, enabling the speed, flexibility and stability needed for high-volume silicon foundry processes. We
successfully created a 2x improvement in r33, while allowing higher stability during poling and post-poling. This provides better thermal
performance and enables greater design flexibility in high-volume silicon foundry PDK (process development kit) processes.
On
August 9, 2021, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,067,748 entitled “Guide Transition Device and Method” that
covers a new invention that enables enhanced optical routing architectures for polymer-based integrated photonics that can be scaled with
partner foundries. This new invention will enable innovative, highly scalable optical routing architectures for integrated photonic platforms.
The patent provides novel optical waveguide transition designs using two planes of optical waveguides that are expected to be critical
for optical signal routing and optical switching, opening the opportunity for high speed, energy efficient electro-optic polymers to be
implemented into foundry PDKs (process development kits) to improve the performance of integrated photonic circuits. This breakthrough
technology opens the door for advanced integrated photonics architectural design. We believe the simplicity of the design is ideal for
production in foundries and will best position our Company to enable increased data traffic on the internet while using less power.
On September
1, 2021, our Company's common shares began trading on the Nasdaq Capital Market (“Nasdaq”). The Company’s Nasdaq listing
will help to expand our potential shareholder base, improve liquidity, elevate our public profile within the industry and should ultimately
enhance shareholder value.
On September
15, 2021, we announced the receipt of the 2021 Industry Award for Optical Integration from the European Conference on Optical Communications
(ECOC), a premier industry exhibition that was held in Bordeaux from September 13-15, 2021. ECOC created the fiber communication industry
awards in six categories to put the spotlight on innovation happening within the industry. The awards recognize and highlight key industry
achievements in advancing optical components, photonic integration, optical transport and data center innovation. The awards are selected
from top industry players, representing significant innovation in photonics integration at our prestigious exhibition.
On
September 16, 2021, we announced the achievement of world-record performance for a polymer modulator, as demonstrated in an optical transmission
experiment by ETH Zurich, using our Company's proprietary, advanced Perkinamine TM chromophores and Polariton Technologies
Ltd.'s newest plasmonic EO modulator, a silicon-photonics-based plasmonic racetrack modulator offering energy-efficient, low-loss, and
high-speed modulation in a compact footprint. The groundbreaking results were presented as a post-deadline paper at the prestigious European
Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) industry exhibition and conference in Bordeaux on September 16, 2021. Polariton's plasmonic
modulator transmitted 220 Gbit/s OOK and 408 Gbit/s 8PAM. Transmission of an optical signal was conducted over 100 m using a low-voltage
electrical drive of 0.6Vp, an on-chip loss of 1 dB, and an optical 3 dB bandwidth of beyond 110 GHz.
32
On
January 3, 2022, we announced the publication of our patent application 20210405504A1 by the United States Patent and Trademark Office
(USPTO) – entitled 'Nonlinear Optical Chromophores Having a Diamondoid Group Attached Thereto, Methods of Preparing the
Same, and Uses Thereof' – which significantly improves the overall stability and performance of our electro-optic polymers. The
Company's electro-optic chromophores are designed to have one or more diamondiod molecular groups attached to the chromophore. When such
chromophores are dispersed in a host polymer matrix, the electro-optic materials result in improved macroscopic electro-optic properties,
increased poling efficiency, increased loading as well as increased stability of these materials after poling. The impact of this technology
is that it will accelerate the path for very high-speed, low-power electro-optic polymers to be implemented into large foundry process
development kits (“ PDKs ”) to boost performance of integrated photonic circuits.
On
January 3, 2022, we announced that we e nhanced our Company’s Foundry Process Development Kit Offering with the addition of
Optical Grating Couplers. This expanded design tool kit will enable silicon foundries to implement
PDKs and fabricate modulators and optical gratings in a single fab run, further enhancing modulator efficacy. We are continuing to work
on additional design tool kit components to enable an expedited commercialization process through a more simplified manufacturing process
for our foundry partners.
On
January 3, 2022, we announced that we appointed respected industry leader Dr. Craig Ciesla to our Board of Directors and that
retired director Dr. Joseph A. Miller transitioned to our Company's Advisory Board. Dr. Ciesla
is currently the Vice President, Head of the Advanced Platforms and Devices Group at Illumina, a leading provider of DNA sequencing and
array technologies. There he leads a team driving innovation in sequencing platforms, microfluidics, electronics, and nanofabrication.
Prior to Illumina, he was Vice President of Engineering at Kaiam, where he was responsible for the development and production of 100G
transceivers for the data-center market. He was also the founding CEO of Tactus Technology, an innovator in the user interface industry,
where he was the co-inventor of Tactus' polymer morphing screen technology. Before Tactus he had a variety of roles at Intel, JDSU (now
Lumentum), Bookham (now Oclaro) and Ignis Optics developing a wide range of products in the fiber-optics market. He started his career
at Toshiba Research Europe, where he performed early terahertz images of skin cancer. Dr. Ciesla holds a BSc (Hons.) in Applied Physics
and Ph.D. in Physics from Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh.
On
February 10, 2022, we announced breakthrough photostability results on our electro-optic polymer modulators that are compatible with high-volume
silicon foundry processes. The improved photostability of our polymers are expected to minimize any optical losses and provide
a more robust platform for silicon foundries. This breakthrough photostability performance is incredibly important as we optimize our
polymers for high-volume silicon foundry processes.
On March
7, 2022, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,262,605 entitled, “Active
region-less polymer modulator integrated on a common PIC platform and method.” This invention will simplify modulator integration
for high-volume foundry manufacturing operations while enhancing polymer reliability to enable a more effective photonic engine. The essence
of the invention is a complete optical engine that fits into fiber optic transceivers (either pluggable or co-packaged) that are used
in routers, servers and elsewhere in optical networks. The engine is designed for high-volume manufacturing operations using silicon foundry
infrastructure. The patent illustrates the use of our polymer modulators as a high speed, low power engine not only for data communication
and telecommunication applications, but other new market opportunities as well.
On March 22, 2022 we announced
the achievement of world-class results for a polymer modulator, as demonstrated in an enhanced stability and high-speed measurement by
Polariton Technologies and ETH Zurich. The results were generated using the Company's proprietary, advanced Perkinamine™ chromophores
in Polariton's silicon-photonics-based plasmonic racetrack modulator that offers energy-efficient, low-loss, and high-speed modulation
in a compact footprint that is ideal for pluggable and/or co-packaging transceiver modules. The plasmonic modulator performance was compared
to that of silicon photonic microring modulators. The plasmonic device, using Lightwave Logic's electro-optic polymer material, was shown
to be 250-3000x more stable than the silicon devices relative to operating condition changes. In addition, the plasmonic modulator was
tested for 70+ minutes at 100 Gbps NRZ at 80C with no decrease in performance. The world-class results were presented as a contributed
peer-reviewed paper at the prestigious 2022 Optical Fiber Conference (OFC2022), the optical communication industry's leading international
technical conference and trade show, in San Diego on March 10, 2022.
On April 19, 2022, we announced
the publication of our patent application 2022/0113566 A1 entitled “TFP (thin film polymer) optical transition device and method”
that illustrates the design of a simpler to fabricate, lower cost hybrid integrated photonics chip using electro-optic polymers which
are more advantageous for high-volume production. The invention will simplify polymer modulator fabrication when integrated with silicon
photonics for high-volume foundry manufacturing applications. The simplified fabrication approach enables us to simplify the production
of very high speed, low power proprietary polymer modulators that will enable significantly faster data rates in the internet environment.
The essence of the invention is a hybrid polymer-silicon photonics engine that fits into fiber optic transceivers (either pluggable or
co-packaged) that are used in the routers, servers and network equipment that are proliferating with the growth of data centers, cloud
computing and optical communications capacity. The hybrid polymer-silicon photonics engine is designed to use high-volume silicon foundry
infrastructure.
33
On May 25, 2022, we announced
enhanced photostability results on our Company's proprietary electro-optic polymer modulators – demonstrating the reliability necessary
for commercial deployments – all based on a technology which can be ported into high-volume silicon foundries and integrated onto
a silicon photonics platform with other optical devices. Photostability is a critical performance metric required both in high volume
manufacturing processes (such as photolithography) and in offering the high reliability and network availability required for commercial
deployments. In the tests conducted, subjecting the Company's latest polymers to high intensity optical power for over 3000 hours produced
no change in device performance. The ability of our proprietary polymers to pass this accelerated photostability aging test provides assurance
that they will both tolerate the optical exposures which occur in high-volume manufacturing and support the reliability over the required
operating life of optical transceivers and network elements.
On June 21, 2022, we announced
the publication of our patent application 2022/0187637A1 entitled “Hybrid electro-optic polymer modulator with silicon photonics”
that details a novel fabrication process that allows our Company’s proprietary polymers to be fabricated by silicon foundries in
a high-volume manufacturing environment. The published patent application also details a more efficient process that allows for high yielding,
high stability poling of polymers in a high-volume foundry manufacturing environment. The development of the PDK for this new optical
hybrid optical modulator design is now in progress with our Company’s foundry partners.
June 23, 2022, we announced the
publication of our patent application 2022/0187638A1 entitled “Hybrid electro-optic polymer modulator with atomic layer deposition
(ALD) sealant layer” that allows our Company’s proprietary polymers to be sealed to moisture and other atmospheric gases
in a very low temperature and quasi-hermetic environment through the use of a chip-scale packaging approach that can be applied in parallel
at wafer level (i.e. in volume) and that eliminates the need for a separate hermetic enclosure or “gold box.” Chip-scale packaging
is a technique that has been gathering momentum in the silicon electronics industry for the past decade to reduce device chip packaging
costs and increase device performance – enabling high-volume front and back-end manufacturing as well as extremely small sizes in
miniaturization. Specifically, our electro-optic polymer modulators are sealed with a low-temperature conformal atomic layer deposition
dielectic layers that are supported on a silicon substrate with passive silicon photonics waveguides.
On June 27, 2022 our Company's
common stock was added to the Russell 3000 ® Index. We expect that the awareness of being included in one of the most
widely followed benchmarks will not only benefit our existing shareholders but will lead to a broader base of institutional investors.
The annual Russell index reconstitution captures the 4,000 largest US stocks as of May 6, ranking them by total market capitalization.
Our membership in the US all-cap Russell 3000® Index, which remains in place for one year, means automatic inclusion in the small-cap
Russell 2000® Index as well as the appropriate growth and value style indexes.
On June
30, 2022, we announced that our CEO, Dr. Michael Lebby, was again invited to co-chair the Photonic Integrated Circuits (PIC) International
Conference that took place June 28-29, 2022 in Brussels, Belgium. At the conference, Dr. Lebby led an invited talk entitled, “Enabling
lower power consumption optical networking using high speed, low power polymer modulators”, focusing on the issue of reducing power
consumption in datacenters and optical networks. He also contributed to a panel session, “Hybrid PICs technology challenges and
solutions,” on the need for hybrid integration addressing the volume production of 3D and 2.5 integrated electronic and photonic
integrated circuits (PICs) based on the utilization of large silicon foundries. This included a discussion on the use of silicon photonics
with hybrid technologies such as electro-optic polymers, polymer based plasmonics, silicon nitride and III-V laser sources.
On September
22, 2022, we announced the achievement of world record performance for low-power consumption ultra-high-speed ‘green’ slot
modulators in collaboration with Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) and its spin-off SilOriX as part of a peer-reviewed post-deadline
paper presented at the prestigious 2022 European Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) in Basel, Switzerland on September 22, 2022.
The team presented the first sub-1mm Mach Zehnder-type modulators with sub-1V drive voltage that rely on Lightwave’s proprietary
advanced Perkinamine™ chromophores. The devices rely on the slot-waveguide device concept developed at KIT and commercialized through
SilOriX. Further, the material has experimentally proven thermal stability at 85°C and offers extreme energy-efficiency along with
high-speed modulation in a compact footprint. Additionally, this shows that our material can perform in a variety of device structures
and designs and is positioned to significantly reduce power consumption of optical networking and to become a true 'green photonics’
enabler for the industry.
On September
22, 2022, we announced the achievement of a world-record demonstration of a 250GHz super high bandwidth electro-optical-electrical (EOE)
link through a collaboration with ETH Zurich. The link was demonstrated by ETH Zurich and uses Polariton's high-speed plasmonic modulators
containing Lightwave's proprietary Perkinamine™ chromophores and ETH Zurich's high-speed graphene photodetectors. The link contained
a plasmonic modulator using electro-optic polymer material as well as a novel metamaterial enhanced graphene photodetector featuring a
200 nm spectral window and a setup-limited 1 ; bandwidth of 500 GHz. The EOE link achieved a world record
and unprecedented 250 GHz 3dB bandwidth 2 . This is an optical link that utilizes devices with extremely
high bandwidths, and the plasmonic demonstration shows that hybrid technologies such as our electro-optic polymers and graphene together
form an important technology platform for volume scalability using large silicon foundries for mass commercialization. The
groundbreaking results were presented by Stephan Koepfli as part of a peer-reviewed post-deadline paper presented at the prestigious 2022
European Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) in Basel, Switzerland on September 22, 2022.
On November 15, 2022, we announced
the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,435,603 B2 entitled “TFP (thin film polymer) optical transition device and method,” which
illustrates the design of a simpler to fabricate, lower cost hybrid integrated photonics chip using electro-optic polymers which are more
advantageous for high-volume production. The simplified fabrication approach enables streamlined production of very high speed, low power
proprietary polymer modulators that will enable significantly faster data rates in the internet environment. The essence of the invention
is a hybrid polymer-silicon photonics engine that fits into fiber optic transceivers (either pluggable or co-packaged) that are used in
the routers, servers and network equipment that are proliferating with the growth of data centers, cloud computing and optical communications
capacity.
________________________
1
Set-up limited’ indicates that the measurement was limited by the testing equipment.
2 University of Kiel,
Germany supported the digital signal processor (DSP), and ETHZ supported the photodetector.
34
On November
17, 2022, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,435,604 B2 entitled “Hybrid electro-optic polymer modulator with silicon
photonics,” which allows Lightwave Logic’s proprietary polymers to be fabricated by silicon foundries in a high-volume manufacturing
environment. The patent also details a more efficient process that allows for high yielding, high stability poling of polymers in a high-volume
foundry manufacturing environment. From a commercial standpoint, this patent enables our polymers to be mass-produced using existing silicon
foundry equipment, simplifying production for the foundry's we are working with.
On November 29, 2022, we announced
our acquisition of the polymer technology and intellectual property assets of Chromosol Ltd (UK). The acquisition significantly strengthened
our Company's design capabilities with foundry PDKs with extremely low temperature atomic layer deposition (ALD) processes that effectively
hermetically seal polymer devices that have been prepared for high volume manufacturing. The advanced fabrication processes of ALD with
temperatures below 100C will solidify our Company's market position with both the Company's manufacturing foundry partners as well as
end-users as we prepare to enter the 800Gbps integrated photonics marketplace. The acquisition also advanced our Company’s patent
portfolio of electro-optic polymer technology with an innovative polymer chemistry device patent that has potential to increase the performance
of integrated modulators through optical amplification in a photonic integrated circuit (PIC) and enhance the functionality of the PIC
by integrating laser light sources made using the polymer-based gain and a laser optical cavity defined on the Silicon photonic platform,
with our Company’s high speed, high efficiency modulators. Having access to extremely low temperature ALD allows our Company's polymer
modulators to be protected from the environment without the need for expensive and large footprint gold box packaging, propelling our
Company forward with chip-scale packaging as required by major hyper-scaler end-users. The patent opens a new class of PICs which expands
our variety of devices. The Patent is US patent number 9837794, EU patent number 3017489, China registration number 201480048236 &
201910230856, and is entitled, “Optoelectronic devices, methods of fabrication thereof and materials therefor.”
On December 12, 2022, we announced
the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,506,918 B2 entitled “Hybrid electro-optic polymer modulator with atomic layer deposition (ALD)
sealant layer,” which allows our proprietary polymers to be sealed to moisture and atmospheric gases in a very low temperature and
quasi-hermetic environment through the use of a chip-scale packaging approach that can be applied in parallel at wafer level (i.e. in
volume) and that eliminates the need for a separate hermetic enclosure or "gold box." Specifically, our electro-optic polymer
modulators will be sealed with low-temperature conformal atomic layer deposition dielectric layers that are supported on a silicon substrate
with passive silicon photonics waveguides. The sealant process will enable lower cost system implementation in a high-volume foundry environment.
On
December 13, 2022, we provided a world-class figure-of merit performance for modulators using electro-optical polymers and a plasmonic
device design in conjunction with Polariton Technologies. Building from the world record performance and demonstration of a 250 GHz super
high bandwidth electro-optical-electrical (EOE) link that was presented at the 2022 European Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) 3 through
a collaboration with ETH Zurich, these latest figure of merit results show the potential for extreme power savings for optical network
equipment and demonstrated clearly that polymer-based technology platforms are positioned well for general implementation. These results
were achieved using Polariton's electro-optic polymer-based plasmonic devices with Lightwave's electro-optic materials, with a bandwidth
greater than 250 GHz. While these high-speed results have been reported previously, here Lightwave Logic reported for the first time that
the voltage-length product Figure of Merit (FoM) for this modulator is just 60 Vum, which is approximately 10X better than the performance
of the optical semiconductor modulators that are incumbent in the optical network and internet today. This figure of merit will allow
ultra-low voltage operation and, enabled by Polariton's plasmonic modulator, the ability to carry significantly more data per modulator
while consuming much less power. The net positive effect on system level equipment is expected not only to be significant, but perhaps
more importantly, also a strong driver of a ''green photonics" platform. These results position our Company extremely well for next
generation ultra-high-capacity interconnects for the hyper-scale market. The combination of electro-optic polymers and plasmonics is becoming
an ideal sunrise technology platform to address the 'Achilles heel' of the data industry: high power consumption. As the industry contemplates
the implementation of PAM4 200G lanes for 2023 and 2024, these optical devices already have shown capability for at least 2X these lane
speeds.
On January 12, 2023, our Chief
Executive Officer, Dr. Michael Lebby, hosted a presentation and participated in an industry panel discussion at the 2023 Photonics Spectra
Conference, a prominent virtual conference within the photonics industry. In the panel discussion, Dr. Lebby and a panel of industry experts
from the entire photonics integrated chip (PIC) value chain, discussed lessons learned when scaling PIC production for volume applications.
In his presentation, Dr. Lebby reviewed the potential solutions that electro-optical polymer modulators offer to integrated and hybrid
photonics integrated chips (PICs), discussing their relevance to PIC packaging operations as well as how electro-optic polymers boost
PIC speed and power efficiency.
On January 30, 2023, our Chief
Executive Officer, Dr. Michael Lebby, participated in an industry panel discussion at the 2023 Laser Focus World Executive Forum. The
Laser Focus World Executive Forum is one of the industry's premier events for senior-level executives, technology directors, and business
managers from technology companies around the world, delivering an in-depth analysis of the global laser and photonics market. In this
discussion, Dr. Lebby joined a panel of industry experts to discuss how the success of Silicon Photonics is based on the premise that
it is a semiconductor technology, and hence it can be manufactured in volume by semiconductor fabs. The panel addressed the manufacturing
plans of photonic integrated circuits (PICs) by semiconductor fabs and how the photonic industry can transfer their processes to the semiconductor
industry.
________________________
3
The groundbreaking results were presented by Stefan Koepfli (ETH Zurich) as part of a peer-reviewed post-deadline paper presented at the
prestigious 2022 European Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) in Basel, Switzerland on September 22, 2022. The post-deadline paper
is titled “>500 GHz Bandwidth Graphene Photodetector Enabling Highest-Capacity Plasmonic-to-Plasmonic Links.”
35
On March 22, 2023, we announced
that our latest commercial-class electro-optic polymer material achieved breakthrough performance metrics at 1310 nanometers (nm), a wavelength
popular in hyperscale datacenter applications. These commercial-class improvements include a significantly higher electro-optic coefficient
exceeding 200 pm/V, which allows for very low drive power of 1 volt or less. Other characteristics include optimized chromophore loading,
superior low optical loss, excellent temporal stability at 85 0 Celsius, and extremely high thermal and photo stability. The
breakthrough commercial-class electro-optic material is expected to enable ultra-small footprint modulators with at least 100 GHz bandwidth
as well as meeting all critical requirements for pluggable transceivers, on-board optics and co-packaging solutions. Additionally, the
achievement of these results at the 1310nm bandwidth positions us for potential near-term licensing opportunities in datacenter applications.
In
April 2023, our Chief Executive Officer, Dr. Michael Lebby, co-chaired the Photonic Integrated Circuits (PIC) International Conference
in Brussels, Belgium. Industry-leading insiders delivered more than 30 presentations spanning six sectors at the conference. The conference
provided attendees with an up-to-date overview of the status of the global photonics industry as well as the opportunity to meet many
other key players within the community. In addition to serving as co-chair of the event, Dr. Lebby hosted a presentation for in-person
attendees within the “Scaling PICs in Volume Using Foundries” track, focusing on the industry's consideration of electro-optic
polymer modulators due to their increased modulation speed, lower power consumption, and potential for future multi-Tbps aggregated data-rates
in the next decade. Additionally, Dr. Lebby discussed the latest results on foundry fabricated EO polymers, as well as the latest work
in photonics roadmaps on both the integrated photonics (PIC) level as well as PIC packaging level.
On
May 4, 2023, we announced, that in conjunction with our research partners at the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and Solarix, the achievement
of record optical modulator performance using our Company's latest Perkinamine ® Series 5 material at extremely low
cryogenic temperatures, delivering the potential to revolutionize applications in supercomputers, quantum circuits and advanced computing
systems. Building from the world record performance and demonstration of super high bandwidth, and super low voltage electro-optic modulators
with Karlsruhe Institute of Technology and Silorix over the past year, the results have the potential to enable supercomputing and quantum
systems to be more competitive than standard computational systems given its faster speeds at low temperatures. This achievement opens
huge opportunities to our Company in the areas of supercomputing and quantum systems by giving access to very high data rate, low power
optical modulators.
On
May 18, 2023, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,614,670 B2 entitled “Electro-optic polymer devices having high performance
claddings and methods of preparing the same,” which is a cutting-edge design technique, enhancing the performance of polymer modulators
through the use of innovative polymer cladding design that is amenable for high-volume foundry fabrication when integrated with silicon
photonics. The patent details a novel fabrication process that allows our proprietary polymers to perform more effectively and to be fabricated
by silicon foundries in a high-volume manufacturing environment. It also introduces a more efficient process for improving the performance
of the polymer claddings, leading to increased poling efficiency and lower losses in both optical and RF aspects. This patent is helping
us move forward with our commercial discussions through the enabling of enhanced performance and simplified manufacturing of our polymer
modulators with silicon photonics.
On
May 25, 2023, we announced our Company's first commercial material supply license agreement for our Perkinamine ® chromophore
materials. This agreement is to provide Perkinamine ® chromophore materials for polymer based photonic devices and
photonic integrated circuits (PICs). Supplying licensed materials is one prong of our Company's three-prong revenue model and business
strategy that includes polymer modulator products as well as technology transfer. This agreement recognizes market acceptance and competitive
advantage of our technology and validates the first prong of our business model. Further, it represents tangible commercial progress for
electro-optic polymers as part of our business plan.
On
May 31, 2023, we announced the receipt of U.S. patent number 11,661,428 entitled “Nonlinear Optical Chromophores, Nonlinear Optical
Materials Containing the Same, and Uses Thereof in Optical Devices,” which details an innovative organic chromophore design using
a novel 'thiophene bridge' to significantly improve material performance in a production environment. This is accomplished by designing
thiophene-containing bridging groups that are positioned between the electron-donating and electron-accepting ends of the chromophore.
These designs provide nonlinear optical chromophores with significantly improved optical properties and improved stability. We expect
this patent will help us progress our commercial discussions with potential customers.
In
June 2023, we announced the publication of World International Property Organization (WIPO) PCT Patent Publication - PCT Patent No. WO
2023/102066 entitled “Nonlinear Optical Materials Containing High Boiling Point Solvents, and Methods of Efficiently Poling The
Same,” which illustrates novel organic chemical structural designs that offer increased poling efficiency, as well as thermal stability
for electro-optic materials. These designs provide non-linear optical chromophores with significantly improved material properties and
stability for processing and fabrication by commercial foundries. Specifically, the patent teaches material processing and poling methods
that directly leads to significantly enhanced electro-optic efficiency (r33) as compared to previous poling techniques. We consider this
WIPO PCT Patent Publication to be a strong step forward in the scaling and volume commercialization of our polymer technology platform.
36
On
August 1, 2023, we appointed respected industry executive Laila Partridge to our Board of Directors. Ms. Partridge brings over
30 years of executive experience in technology, corporate innovation and finance to our Board – having worked with a wide range
of technologies, including telecommunications, internet infrastructure, AI, internet of things and more. She was named by Boston Business
Journal as one of the ten “2017 Women to Watch in Science and Technology”. She currently serves as Founder and Chief Executive
Officer of The HardTech Project, a new venture with a novel approach to early-stage hardware investing. Previously, she was Managing Director
of the STANLEY + Techstars Accelerator where she directed a global effort for Stanley Black & Decker's Chief Technology
Officer to identify and invest in innovative technologies for industrial applications with an emphasis on electrification, sustainability
and advanced manufacturing. Prior to that, she began her technology career at Intel Capital, serving as a Director of Strategic Investments.
Ms. Partridge began her career at Wells Fargo, where she ultimately achieved the role of VP of Corporate Banking, having led complex corporate
finance transactions for the company's senior secured debt agencies in the Midwest. Ms. Partridge brings significant board experience
to the Board of Directors, including at Intel Capital serving privately-held technology companies, and in her current role as an independent
Director at Cambridge Trust (NASDAQ: CATC). She holds a Bachelor's degree with Honors from Wellesley College.
On
August 21, 2023, we announced the completion of new laboratory production facilities, expanding our corporate headquarters by over 65%,
nearly 10,000 square feet, for a total of approximately 23,500 square feet to support new commercial activity, including enabling commercial
device testing and evaluation, production reliability testing, laser characterization, SEM analysis and the expansion of our Company's
chemical synthesis production line.
On
October 3, 2023, we announced our receipt of the 2023 Industry Award for Most Innovative Hybrid PIC/Optical Integration Platform from
the European Conference on Optical Communications (ECOC) – a premier industry exhibition – held in Glasgow,
Scotland from October 2-4, 2023. ECOC is one of the leading conferences on optical communication and attracts top industry minds
from across the world. The ECOC awards emphasize technology and product commercialization, highlighting significant achievements in advancing
the business of optical communications, transport, networking, fiber-based products, photonic integration circuits and related developments.
The Innovative Product category with 5 subcategories looks across the industry at new products driving change in their respective market
segment, and what is timely and helping to increase the use of optics. Metrics include design features that are photonics, electronics,
thermal, mechanical, chemical, environmental and carbon footprint based.
On
March 24, 2024, at the 2024 Optical Fiber Conference in San Diego, California (OFC 2024), we presented world-class results for our Company’s
200Gbps heterogeneous polymer/silicon photonic modulator at a record low drive voltage, which are based on a novel packaged heterogeneous
polymer EO modulator design leveraging silicon photonics devices from a 200mm production foundry process and Lightwave Logic’s proprietary
high temperature, high performance EO Polymer material. Each modulator was operated at 100GBaud PAM4 and achieved all drive voltages below
2V, and as low as 1V which is excellent for low power operation. We discussed the test set-up for the high-speed results, and how electro-optic
polymer-based modulators based on 200mm silicon foundry wafers are ideal for 4 lane 200Gbps per lane 800Gbps pluggable optical transceivers
for datacenter applications. We also shared updated lifetime and reliability data for both the electro-optic polymer materials and electro-optic
polymer devices. Our results demonstrate that a hybrid approach, leveraging the cost and integration benefits of silicon photonics along
with the unparalleled bandwidth and low power advantages of Lightwave Logic’s proprietary EO polymers, lays a clear path for competitive
performance and integration for today’s and future optical pluggable transceivers, and we expect these results will position our
Company to support the burgeoning demand of generative AI as datacenters around the world begin to upgrade their hardware faster than
expected to meet the demands of the future.
On
March 28, 2024, we announced world-class performance of the Company’s Perkinamine® EO polymer material operating in an optical
interconnect link, at 437.1Gbps employing a PAM8 178GBaud signal encoded by a plasmonic Mach Zehnder modulator (MZM). In this work, intensity
modulated, direct detection (IM/DD) techniques were utilized to drive higher performance. The paper, authored by our teammates ETH Zurich
and Polariton Technologies, demonstrated data rates beyond 400Gbps for a IM/Dd optical interconnect link for the first time. This world-class
result, achieving data rates of 400Gbps per lane, demonstrates that our Company’s EO polymers are capable of exceeding double the
current industry expectation. This has the potential to enable 4 lane 1.6Tbps (1600Gbps) pluggable transceiver modules, which is on the
roadmap of datacenter operators today.
On
April 1, 2024 we announced the issuance of patent 11,921,401 by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) – entitled
‘Nonlinear Optical Chromophores Having a Diamondoid Group Attached Thereto, Methods of Preparing the Same, and Uses Thereof‘
issued on March 5, 2024, which has been shown to significantly improve the overall stability and performance of our Company’s EO
chromophores. This materials-based chemical-engineered invention advances the overall performance of our Company’s EO chromophores
and their use in high-speed, low power and commercial-grade EO polymer modulators that operate at 200Gbps with drive voltage levels of
1V. The proprietary chromophores are designed with Diamondoid molecular groups that are attached to the chromophore. Results show that
when these chromophores are dispersed in a host polymer matrix, the EO materials result in improved macroscopic EO properties, increased
poling efficiency, increased loading as well as increased stability of these materials after poling. The impact of the technology disclosed
is significant in that it will increase the overall robustness of polymer materials that are utilized in optical modulator devices. Further,
the materials can be easily utilized in silicon foundries for high-volume manufacturing processes. We believe this invention will help
us bring in more commercial license deals for our EO polymers, especially as we work with high-volume manufacturing silicon foundries
and 200mm silicon wafers. Additionally, we consider this material as a key component for next generation 800Gbps and 1600Gbps pluggable
optical transceiver modules that support the rise of generative AI and upgrading of datacenter hardware equipment.
37
On
April 16, 2024, we announced our substantial contributions to the recently published “Integrated Photonics System Roadmap -
International” (IPSR-I) to accelerate the high-volume commercial manufacturing of high-value integrated photonics over the
next decade and beyond. More than 400 technology, academic and industrial organizations from around the world contributed to IPSR-I.
The IPSR-I describes a route toward building a global, aligned integrated photonics industry with the ability to help solve major
societal challenges. It includes a comprehensive overview of major technology gaps for volume manufacturing of photonic integrated
circuits (PIC) and a detailed analysis of the challenges that the integrated photonics industry needs to overcome to achieve its
potential. Lightwave Logic was instrumental in two chapters of the IPSR-I, serving as co-chair of the “Transceivers”
chapter and chair of the “Polymers” chapter. Our Company also contributed to the “Interconnects” chapter.
‘Transceivers’ are a critical commercial pluggable optical engine, for example in hyperscaler datacenters, telelcom
networks, and high-performance computing. 'Interconnects' focuses on optical fiber links that connect pluggable optical transceivers
together for routers, switches, computational systems etc. ‘Polymers’ focuses on active electro-optic polymers for
optical modulators as well as passive polymers that guide and manipulate light in fiber optic communications markets. The integrated
photonics roadmaps both plan and anticipate commercial opportunities as well as potential roadblocks and/or critical needs on the
way to scaling the manufacturing of integrated photonics through 2040. The silicon semiconductor industry has relied on these types
of roadmaps for the past 50 years and with IPSR-I, the photonics industry is becoming organized and more influential as well.
On
May 21, 2024, we announced our collaboration with Advanced Micro Foundry (AMF), a leading Silicon Photonics volume foundry, to develop
state-of art polymer slot modulators utilizing AMF's silicon photonics platform. These modulators have been shown to achieve a record
low drive voltage below 1V and data rates of 200Gbps PAM4. This performance will enable a new generation of 800 Gb/s and 1.6T Gb/s pluggable
transceivers to address fast growing requirements for optical connectivity for large generative AI computing clusters. Lightwave Logic
and AMF have collaborated over the past year to develop the electro optic polymer slot modulators utilizing AMF's standard manufacturing
process flow on 200-mm wafers. This successful demonstration marked a significant milestone in integrated photonics, blending Silicon
photonics with polymer materials. Building on this demonstration, both parties are aiming to enhance the modulators to ensure these advanced
components are readily accessible to product companies on a manufacturing scale. This accomplishment puts our Company in a very strong
position to ramp volume both for our polymers as well as 200-mm silicon wafer volume with AMF. It also opens exciting opportunities to
develop novel solutions for commercial-grade-compatible EO polymer modulators seamlessly integrated with AMF's standard processes.
On
August 1, 2024, we appointed Yves LeMaitre to our Board of Directors. Mr. LeMaitre brings over 30 years of executive experience
in technology, corporate strategy and marketing to the Board of Directors. He currently serves as a Strategic Board Advisor to Trumpf
Photonic Components, a global technology company specializing in the development of lasers for optics, and as a strategic advisor to the
Optical, RF & Micro-Electronics division of Sanmina AMT. Mr. LeMaitre most recently served as CEO of Astrobeam.Space, where he launched
the startup's development of next-generation of laser beam steering for satellite to satellite communication. Previously, Mr. LeMaitre
was the Head of the Optical Coherent Division of IPG Photonics, where he advised and oversaw the division's divestiture to Lumentum. Prior
to that, he was the SVP of Luna Innovations' North America Business Operation (following the company's acquisition of RIO Lasers where
he served as President). Previously, he spent 10 years in varying roles of increasing responsibility through multiple acquisitions with
Oclaro (later acquired by Lumentum), ultimately achieving the roles of Chief Strategy Officer at Lumentum. During his time at OCLARO,
he played a key role in positioning OCLARO as a leader in the optical connectivity business, driving the growth of Indium Phosphide lasers
in the datacenter (now Generative AI front-end networks) segments. He holds a degree from Télécom Paris and a
"Maitrise" Degree in Computer Science and Mathematics from Nantes Université in France.
As we
move forward to diligently meet our goals, we continue to work closely with our packaging and foundry partners for 112Gbaud prototypes,
and we are advancing our reliability and characterization efforts to support our prototyping. Depending on electrical encoding schemes
such as PAM4, or PAM8, or wavelength optical multiplexing, these Gigabaud rates roughly translate to 200Gbps and 300Gbps per lane, and
are the key speed rates for emerging 800Gbps to future possible 1200Gbps applications. Our partnership with silicon-based foundries will
allow us to scale commercial volumes of electro-optic polymer modulator devices using large silicon wafers, and we are currently working
to have our fabrication processes accepted into foundry PDKs (process development kits). These are the recipes that foundries use to manufacture
devices in their fabrication plants.
We are
actively engaged with test equipment manufacturers of the most advanced test equipment to test our state-of-the-art polymer devices. We
continue to engage with multiple industry bodies to promote our roadmap. We continue to fine tune our business model with target markets,
customers, and technical specifications. Our business model includes the licensing of our strong IP and Patent portfolio, as well as technology
transfer to entities such as foundries. Discussions with prospective customers are validating that our modulators are ideally suited for
the datacenter and telecommunications markets that are over 10km in length. Details and feedback of what these prospective customers are
seeking from a prototype are delivered to our technical team.
38
Capital Requirements
We commenced
commercial operations in May 2023, and we do not generate sufficient revenues to pay for our operating expenses. We have incurred substantial
net losses since inception. We have satisfied our capital requirements since inception primarily through the issuance and sale of our
common stock.
Results of Operations
Comparison of three months
ended June 30, 2024 to three months ended June 30, 2023
Revenues
During the three months ended
June 30, 2024, we recognized $19,355 of licensing and royalty revenue. As a development stage company, during the three months ended June
30, 2023, we had no revenues. The Company is in various stages of photonic device and materials development and evaluation with potential
customers and strategic partners, and commercialization. The Company expects to continue obtaining a revenue stream from technology licensing
agreements, to obtain additional revenue streams from technology transfer agreements and direct sale of its own electro-optic device components.
Cost of Sales
During the three months ended June 30, 2024
and June 30, 2023 we recognized $0 in Cost of Sales.
Operating Expenses
Change from
Percent
For the Three
For the Three
Prior Three
Change from
Months Ending
Months Ending
Month
Prior Three
June 30, 2024
June 30, 2023
Period
Month Period
Research and development
$ 4,362,258
$ 4,166,110
$ 196,148
5 %
General and administrative
1,896,672
1,174,590
722,082
61 %
$ 6,258,930
$ 5,340,700
$ 918,230
17 %
Research and development
expenses increased for the three months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the three months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to increases
in research and development salary expenses, research and development equipment depreciation expense, laboratory and wafer fabrication
materials and supplies expenses, research and development rent expenses, property tax expenses, repair expenses, and research and development
equipment rental expenses, offset by a decrease in prototype device development expenses, research and development employee relocation
expenses, research and development non-cash stock option amortization expenses, and research and development recruiting fees.
· Research and development salary
expenses increased by $303,501 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development equipment
depreciation expense increased by $131,173 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Laboratory and wafer fabrication
materials and supplies expenses increased by $108,513 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development rent
expenses increased by $56,072 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development property
tax expenses increased by $50,743 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development repair
expenses increased by $20,922 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development equipment
rental expenses increased by $18,563 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· These increases were offset
by a $195,297 decrease in prototype device development expenses, a $178,626 decrease in research and development employee relocation expenses,
a $69,509 decrease in research and development non-cash stock option amortization expenses, and a $62,412 decrease in research and development
recruiting fees in the three months ended June 30, 2024 compared to the same period in 2023.
39
We expect to continue to incur
substantial research and development expense developing and commercializing our photonic devices, and electro-optic materials platform.
These expenses will increase as a result of accelerated development effort to support commercialization of our non-linear optical polymer
materials technology; to build photonic device prototypes; working with semiconductor foundries; hiring additional technical and support
personnel; engaging senior technical advisors; pursuing other potential business opportunities and collaborations; customer testing and
evaluation; and incurring related operating expenses.
General and administrative expenses
increased for the three months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the three months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to increases in
general and administrative non-cash stock option amortization expenses, general and administrative salary expenses, consulting fees, sales
and marketing expenses, legal fees, depreciation expense, general and administrative rent expenses, and general and administrative travel
expenses, offset by decreases in auditing and accounting fees.
· General and administrative non-cash
stock option amortization expenses increased by $265,459 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative salary
expenses increased by $181,022 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative consulting
fees increased by $100,611 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Sales and marketing expenses
increased by $51,360 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Legal fees increased by $42,817
in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Depreciation expense increased
by $28,336 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative rent
expenses increased by $17,602 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative travel
expenses increased by $17,593 in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· These increases were offset
by a $40,778 decrease in auditing expenses and a $23,106 decrease in accounting fees in the three months ended June 30, 2024, compared
to the same period in 2023.
Other Income (Expense)
Change from
Percent
For the Three
For the Three
Prior Three
Change from
Months Ending
Months Ending
Month
Prior Three
June 30, 2024
June 30, 2023
Period
Month Period
Other Income/(Expense)
$ 219,891
$ (117,047 )
$ 336,938
288 %
Other income increased
for the three months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the three months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to a $148,044 increase in
interest income on money market account and a $191,749 decrease in commitment fee associated with the purchase of shares by an institutional
investor for sale under a stock purchase agreement.
Net Loss
Change from
Percent
For the Three
For the Three
Prior Three
Change from
Months Ending
Months Ending
Month
Prior Three
June 30, 2024
June 30, 2023
Period
Month Period
Net Loss
$ 6,019,684
$ 5,457,747
$ 561,937
10 %
Net loss was $6,019,684 and $5,457,747
for the three months ended June 30, 2024 and 2023, respectively, for an increase of $561,937 due primarily to increases in salary expenses,
non-cash stock option amortization expenses, depreciation expense, laboratory and wafer fabrication materials and supplies expenses, consulting
fees, rent expenses, property taxes, sales and marketing expenses and legal fees. These increases were offset by decreases in prototype
device development expenses, commitment fee associated with the purchase of shares by an institutional investor for sale under a stock
purchase agreement, employee relocation expenses, recruiting fees, auditing expenses and accounting fees, and an increase in interest
income on money market account.
40
Comparison of six months ended June 30, 2024 to
six months ended June 30, 2023
Revenues
During the six months ended June
30, 2024, we recognized $36,022 of licensing and royalty revenue. As a development stage company, during the six months ended June 30,
2023, we had no revenues.
Cost of Sales
During the six months ended June 30, 2024,
we recognized $5,175 in Cost of Sales, and $0 in Cost of Sales during the six months ended June 30, 2023.
Operating Expenses
Change from
Percent
For the Six
For the Six
Prior Six
Change from
Months Ending
Months Ending
Month
Prior Six
June 30, 2024
June 30, 2023
Period
Month Period
Research and development
8,982,920
$ 7,965,817
$ 1,017,103
13 %
General and administrative
3,152,122
2,534,761
617,361
24 %
$ 12,135,042
$ 10,500,578
$ 1,634,464
16 %
Research and development
expenses increased for the six months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the six months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to increases
in research and development salary expenses, prototype device development expenses, laboratory and wafer fabrication materials and supplies
expenses, depreciation expense, research and development rent expenses, research and development travel expenses, property taxes, repair
expenses and equipment rental expenses, offset by a decrease in research and development non-cash stock option amortization expenses,
research and development employee relocation expenses, and research and development recruiting fees.
· Research and development salary
expenses increased by $890,641 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Prototype device development
expenses increased by $553,472 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Laboratory and wafer fabrication
materials and supplies expenses increased by $208,213 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Depreciation expense increased
by $169,896 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development rent
expenses increased by $115,080 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development travel
expenses increased by $68,985 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Property tax expenses increased
by $63,692 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development repair
expenses increased by $35,424 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Research and development equipment
rental expenses increased by $34,597 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· These increases were offset
by a $883,101 decrease in research and development non-cash stock option amortization expenses, a $178,626 decrease in research and development
employee relocation expenses and a $141,119 decrease in research and development recruiting fees in the six months ended June 30, 2024,
compared to the same period in 2023.
41
We expect to continue to incur
substantial research and development expenses developing and commercializing our photonic devices, and electro-optic materials platform.
These expenses will increase as a result of accelerated development effort to support commercialization of our non-linear optical polymer
materials technology; to build photonic device prototypes; working with semiconductor foundries; hiring additional technical and support
personnel; engaging senior technical advisors; pursuing other potential business opportunities and collaborations; customer testing and
evaluation; and incurring related operating expenses.
General and administrative expenses
increased for the six months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the six months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to increases in general
and administrative salary expenses, consulting fees, depreciation expense, general and administrative recruiting fees, sales and marketing
expenses and software expenses, offset by decreases in legal fees and general and administrative non-cash stock option amortization expenses.
· General and administrative salary
expenses increased by $312,560 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative consulting
fees increased by $156,086 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Depreciation expense increased
by $99,250 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· General and administrative recruiting
fees increased by $53,817 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Sales and marketing expenses
increased by $51,360 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· Software expenses increased
by $39,465 in the six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
· These increases were offset
by a $132,711 decrease in legal expenses and a $99,579 decrease in general and administrative non-cash stock option amortization in the
six months ended June 30, 2024, compared to the same period in 2023.
Other Income (Expense)
For the Six
Months Ending
June 30, 2024
For the Six
Months Ending
June 30, 2023
Change from
Prior Six
Month
Period
Percent
Change from
Prior Six
Month Period
Other Income/(Expense)
$ 390,850
$ (433,187 )
$ 824,037
190 %
Other income increased
for the six months ended June 30, 2024, as compared to the six months ended June 30, 2023, primarily due to a $476,466 decrease in commitment
fee associated with the purchase of shares by an institutional investor for sale under a stock purchase agreement and a $359,218 increase
in interest income on money market account.
Net Loss
For the Six
Months Ending
June 30, 2024
For the Six
Months Ending
June 30, 2023
Change from
Prior Six
Month
Period
Percent
Change from
Prior Six
Month Period
Net Loss
$ 11,699,595
$ 10,933,765
$ 765,830
7 %
Net loss was $11,699,595 and $10,933,765
for the six months ended June 30, 2024 and 2023, respectively, for an increase of $765,830 due primarily to increases in salary expenses,
prototype device development expenses, depreciation expense, laboratory and wafer fabrication materials and supplies expenses, consulting
fees, rent expense, travel expenses, and property tax expenses. These increases were offset by decreases in non-cash stock option amortization,
commitment fee associated with the purchase of shares by an institutional investor for sale under a stock purchase agreement, employee
relocation expenses, legal expense, and recruiting fees and an increase in interest income on money market account.
42
Liquidity and Capital Resources
Our primary
source of operating cash inflows was (i) proceeds from the sale of common stock to Lincoln Park, an
institutional investor, pursuant to purchase agreements with Lincoln Park (the institutional
investor) and proceeds from sale of common stock by Roth Capital pursuant to the at the market sale agreement with the investment
banking company as described in Note 10 to the Financial Statements and (ii) proceeds received pursuant to the exercise of options and
warrants.
On
July 2, 2021, the Company filed a $100 million universal shelf registration statement (the “ 2021 shelf registration statement ”)
which became effective on July 9, 2021. On October 4, 2021, our Company entered into the 2021 purchase agreement with Lincoln Park to
sell up to $33 million of common stock over a 36-month period. All of the registered shares under the October 4, 2021 purchase agreement
with Lincoln Park have been issued as of December 31, 2023. On February 28, 2023, our Company entered into the 2023 purchase agreement
with Lincoln Park to sell up to $30 million of common stock over a 36-month period, with $6.4 million remaining on the 2023 Purchase
Agreement as of the date of this filing. On December 9, 2022, our Company entered into the at the market sale agreement with Roth Capital,
as sales agent, whereby pursuant to the at the market sale agreement, our Company may offer and sell up to $35,000,000 in shares of our
common stock, from time to time through Roth Capital. As of the date of this filing $32.9 million remains available to our Company pursuant
to the at the market sale agreement. The 2021 shelf registration statement expired in July 2024 and on July 26, 2024, and the Company
filed a $100,000,000 universal shelf registration statement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission which became effective on
August 5, 2024 (the “ 2024 shelf registration statement ”). The unsold securities relating to the 2023 purchase agreement
with Lincoln Park and the at the market sale agreement with Roth Capital were carried over from the 2021 Shelf Registration to the 2024
Shelf Registration.
During
the six months ended June 30, 2024, the Company received $7,495,600 in proceeds pursuant to the 2023 purchase agreement with Lincoln Park,
$499,883 in proceeds pursuant to the at the market sale agreement with Roth Capital, and $245,250 in proceeds pursuant to the exercise
of options and warrants and $63,884 in cash collections from customer contracts, of which $50,000 related to the proceeds received under
a material supply and license agreement and $13,884 – to the proceeds received for a contract for processing work on the devices
supplied by a customer. During the year ended December 31, 2023, the Company received $19,993,359 in proceeds pursuant to the 2021 purchase
agreement and 2023 purchase agreement with Lincoln Park, $1,515,878 in proceeds pursuant to the at the market sale agreement with Roth
Capital, $1,013,924 in proceeds pursuant to the exercise of options and warrants and $50,000 in a proceed received under a material supply
and license agreement of which $39,875 is recorded as deferred revenue as of December 31, 2023.
During
the six months ended June 30, 2024, our primary sources of cash outflows from operations included payroll, rent, utilities, payments to
vendors including prototypes development and foundries expenses, laboratory and wafer fabrication materials and supplies expenses, and
third-party service providers. During the year ended December 31, 2023, our primary sources of cash outflows from operations included
payroll, rent, utilities, payments to vendors including prototypes development and foundries expenses and third-party service providers.
Our
future expenditures and capital requirements will depend on numerous factors, including: the progress of our research and development
efforts; the rate at which we can, directly or through arrangements with original equipment manufacturers, introduce and sell products
incorporating our polymer materials technology; the costs of filing, prosecuting, defending and enforcing any patent claims and other
intellectual property rights; market acceptance of our products and competing technological developments; and our ability to establish
cooperative development, joint venture and licensing arrangements. We expect that we will incur approximately $1,840,000 of
expenditures per month over the next 12 months.
We expect
the proceeds received pursuant to the 2023 purchase agreement and any future purchase agreements with Lincoln Park, the at the market
sale agreement with Roth Capital, the exercise of options and warrants and commercial operations to provide us with sufficient funds
to maintain our operations over the next 12 months. Our current cash position enables us to finance our operations through October 2025
before we will be required to replenish our cash reserves. Our cash requirements are expected to increase at a rate consistent with our
Company’s revenue growth as we expand our activities and operations with the objective of increasing our revenue stream from the
commercialization of our electro-optic polymer technology. We currently have no debt to service.
We expect
that our cash used in operations will continue to increase during 2024 and beyond as a result of the following planned activities:
•
The addition of management, sales, marketing, technical and other staff to our workforce;
•
Increased spending for the expansion of our research and development efforts, including purchases of additional laboratory and production equipment;
•
Increased spending in marketing as our products are introduced into the marketplace;
•
Partnering with commercial foundries to implement our electro-optic polymers into accepted PDKs by the foundries;
•
Developing and maintaining collaborative relationships with strategic partners;
•
Developing and improving our manufacturing processes and quality controls; and
•
Increases in our general and administrative activities related to our operations as a reporting public company and related corporate compliance requirements.
43
2023 Purchase Agreement
with Lincoln Park
On February
28, 2023, our Company entered into the 2023 purchase agreement with Lincoln Park, pursuant to which Lincoln Park agreed to purchase from
us up to $30 million of our common stock (subject to certain limitations) from time to time over a 36-month period. Pursuant to the 2023
purchase agreement, Lincoln Park is obligated to make purchases as the Company directs in accordance with the purchase agreement, which
may be terminated by the Company at any time, without cost or penalty. Sales of shares will be made in specified amounts and at prices
that are based upon the market prices of our common stock immediately preceding the sales to Lincoln Park. We expect this and any future
purchase agreements with Lincoln Park to provide us with sufficient funds to maintain our operations for the foreseeable future. With
the additional capital, we expect to achieve a level of revenues attractive enough to fulfill our development activities and adequate
enough to support our business model for the foreseeable future.
There
are no trading volume requirements or restrictions under the 2023 purchase agreement, and we will control the timing and amount of any
sales of our common stock to Lincoln Park. Lincoln Park has no right to require any sales by us, but is obligated to make purchases from
us as we direct in accordance with the 2023 purchase agreement. We can also accelerate the amount of common stock to be purchased under
certain circumstances. There are no limitations on the use of proceeds, financial or business covenants, restrictions on future financings
(other than restrictions on the Company’s ability to enter into a similar type of agreement or equity line of credit during the
term, excluding an at-the-market transaction with a registered broker-dealer), rights of first refusal, participation rights, penalties
or liquidated damages under the 2023 purchase agreement.
At
the Market Sale Agreement – Roth Capital
On December 9, 2022, we
entered into the at the market sale agreement with Roth Capital, as sales agent. Pursuant to the at the market sale agreement, our Company
may offer and sell up to $35,000,000 in shares of our common stock, from time to time through Roth Capital. Upon delivery of a placement
notice based on our Company’s instructions and subject to the terms and conditions of the at the market sale agreement, Roth Capital
may sell the shares by methods deemed to be an “at the market offering” as defined in Rule 415(a)(4) promulgated under the
Securities Act, including sales made directly on or through The Nasdaq Capital Market, on any other existing trading market for the Company’s
common stock, in negotiated transactions at market prices prevailing at the time of sale or at prices related to such prevailing market
prices, or by any other method permitted by law, including negotiated transactions, subject to the prior written consent of our Company.
We are not obligated to make any sales of shares under this agreement. The Company or Roth Capital may suspend or terminate the offering
of shares upon notice to the other party, subject to certain conditions. Roth Capital will act as sales agent on a commercially reasonable
efforts basis consistent with its normal trading and sales practices and applicable state and federal law, rules and regulations
and the rules of Nasdaq. We have agreed to pay Roth Capital commissions for its services of acting as agent of 3.0% of the gross
proceeds from the sale of the shares pursuant to the at the market sale agreement.
The amount
of proceeds we receive from the at the market sale agreement, if any, will depend upon the number of shares of our common stock sold and
the market price at which they are sold. There can be no assurance that we will be able to sell any shares under or fully utilize this
agreement. Roth Capital is not required to sell any specific number of shares of our common stock under the agreement. We intend to use
net proceeds from the at the market sale agreement for general corporate purposes, including, without limitation, sales and marketing
activities, product development, making acquisitions of assets, businesses, companies or securities, capital expenditures, and for working
capital needs.
We cannot
assure you that we will meet the conditions of the 2023 purchase agreements with Lincoln Park in order to obligate Lincoln Park to purchase
our shares of common stock, and we cannot assure you that we will be able to sell any shares under or fully utilize the at the market
sale agreement with Roth Capital. In the event we fail to do so, and other adequate funds are not available to satisfy long-term capital
requirements, or if planned revenues are not generated, we may be required to substantially limit our operations. This limitation of operations
may include reductions in capital expenditures and reductions in staff and discretionary costs.
Analysis of Cash Flows
For the six months ended June 30, 2024
Net cash used in operating
activities was $8,823,788 for the six months ended June 30, 2024, primarily attributable to the net loss of $11,699,595 adjusted by $2,337,460
in options issued for services, $203,521 amortization of deferred compensation, $105,960 in common stock issued for services, $804,737
in depreciation expenses and patent amortization expenses, $94,753 amortization of right of use asset, $3,166 loss on disposal of property
and equipment, $22,311 in accounts receivable, $476,730 in prepaid expenses and other current assets and ($1,172,831) in accounts payable,
accrued bonuses, accrued expenses, deferred revenue and other liabilities. Net cash used in operating activities consisted of payments
for research and development, legal, professional and consulting expenses, rent and other expenditures necessary to develop our business
infrastructure.
Net cash used in investing
activities was $1,653,217 for the six months ended June 30, 2024, consisting of $67,445 in cost for intangibles and $1,585,772 in asset
additions for the Colorado headquarter facility and labs.
Net cash provided by
financing activities was $8,240,733 for the six months ended June 30, 2024 and consisted of $245,250 in proceeds from exercise of options
and warrants, $7,495,600 in proceeds from resale of common stock to an institutional investor and $499,883 in proceeds from at the market
sale of common stock by an investment banking company.
On June
30, 2024, our cash and cash equivalents totaled $29,195,815, our assets totaled $39,798,833, our liabilities totaled $4,176,940 and we
had stockholders’ equity of $35,621,893.
44
For the six months ended June
30, 2023
Net cash used in operating activities
was $7,004,008 for the six months ended June 30, 2023, primarily attributable to the net loss of $10,933,765 adjusted by $3,389,804 in
options issued for services, $133,854 amortization of deferred compensation, $582,426 in common stock issued for services, $531,046 in
depreciation expenses and patent amortization expenses, $92,812 amortization of right of use asset, $581 loss on disposal of property
and equipment, ($162,748) in prepaid expenses and ($638,019) in accounts payable, accrued expenses, deferred revenue and other liabilities.
Net cash used in operating activities consisted of payments for research and development, legal, professional and consulting expenses,
rent and other expenditures necessary to develop our business infrastructure.
Net cash used by investing activities
was $513,095 for the six months ended June 30, 2023, consisting of $177,245 in cost for intangibles, $978,560 in asset additions for the
Colorado headquarter facility and labs offset by $642,120 in a loan repayment and $590 in proceeds on sale of property and equipment.
Net cash provided by financing
activities was $16,050,739 for the six months ended June 30, 2023 and consisted of $456,801 in proceeds from exercise of options and warrants,
$14,950,409 in proceeds from resale of common stock to an institutional investor and $643,529 in proceeds from at the market sale of common
stock by an investment banking company.
On June 30, 2023, our cash and
cash equivalents totaled $32,635,787, our assets totaled $40,552,039, our liabilities totaled $3,775,958 and we had stockholders’
equity of $36,776,081.
Contractual Obligations
There
have been no material changes outside the ordinary course of business in our contractual commitments during the six months ended June
30, 2024. See Note 8 to the financial statements herein for a discussion of our contractual commitments.
Significant Accounting Policies
We believe
our significant accounting policies affect our more significant estimates and judgments used in the preparation of our financial statements.
Our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2023 contains a discussion of these significant accounting policies. The
Company’s significant accounting policies have not materially changed since that report
was filed.
Text extracted from the filing as submitted to EDGAR. Formatting, tables and exhibits are simplified for reading; the original document is authoritative for anything you rely on.