2 unchanged sentences
Portions of the following information are based on assumptions, qualifications and procedures which are not fully described herein.
−Removed: Reference should be made to the full text of the NORI Technical Report Summary, which has been filed as Exhibit 96.1 to this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
+Added: Reference should be made to the full text of the NORI Technical Report Summary, which has been incorporated by reference as Exhibit 96.1 to this Annual Report.
The NORI Technical Report Summary is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
4 unchanged sentences
The CCZ is located in international waters between Hawaii and Mexico.
−Removed: The western-end of the CCZ is approximately 1,000 km south of the Hawaiian island group.
−Removed: From here, the CCZ extends almost 5,000 km east-northeast, in an approximately 600 km wide trend, with the eastern limits approximately 2,000 km west of southern Mexico.
+Added: The western-end of the CCZ is approximately 1,000 kilometers south of the Hawaiian island group.
+Added: From here, the CCZ extends almost 5,000 kilometers east-northeast, in an approximately 600 kilometers wide trend, with the eastern limits approximately 2,000 kilometers west of southern Mexico.
The region is well-located to ship nodules to the American continent or across the Pacific to Asian markets.
−Removed: The NORI Contract Area comprises four separate blocks (A, B, C and D) in the CCZ with a combined area of 74,830 km 2 .
+Added: The NORI Contract Area comprises four separate blocks (A, B, C and D) in the CCZ with a combined area of 74,830 square kilometers.
NORI Contract Area extents
4 unchanged sentences
Tenements and permits
−Removed: See Business-Government Regulations-The NORI Exploration Contract, Business-Government Regulations-The NORI Sponsorship Agreement and Business-Government Regulations- International Seabed Authority above for information related to tenements and permits in the NORI Contract Area.
+Added: See Business Regulations-The NORI Exploration Contract, Business Regulations-The NORI Sponsorship Agreement and Business Regulations- International Seabed Authority above for information related to tenements and permits in the NORI Contract Area.
NORI obligations and sponsorship
−Removed: See Business-Government Regulations-The NORI Exploration Contract, Business-Government Regulations-The NORI Sponsorship Agreement above for information related to this agreement in the NORI Contract Area.
+Added: See Business Regulations-The NORI Exploration Contract, Business Regulations-The NORI Sponsorship Agreement above for information related to this agreement in the NORI Contract Area.
Royalties and taxes
−Removed: See Business -Government Regulations-Royalties and taxes above for information with respect to our obligations for royalties and taxes in the NORI Contract Area.
+Added: See Business Regulations-Royalties and taxes above for information with respect to our obligations for royalties and taxes in the NORI Contract Area.
History of previous exploration activities in the NORI Contract Area
8 unchanged sentences
OMI completed a successful trial collection operation in 1978.
−Removed: Hydraulic pumps, an air lift system, and towed collectors were tested in approximately 4,500 m of water.
+Added: Hydraulic pumps, an air lift system, and towed collectors were tested in approximately 4,500 meters of water.
Approximately 800 tonnes of nodules were recovered.
18 unchanged sentences
The CCZ seafloor forms part of the Abyssal Plains, which are the largest physiographic province on Earth.
−Removed: The average depth of the seafloor in the Project Area is 3,800 to 4,200 m.
−Removed: Overall, the seafloor slopes at approximately 0.57˚ (1 m per km) but the Abyssal Plains are traversed by ridges, with amplitude of 50 to 300 m (maximum 1,000 m) and wavelength of 1 to 10 km.
−Removed: The Abyssal Plains are punctuated by extinct volcanoes rising 500 to 2,000 m above the seafloor.
+Added: The average depth of the seafloor in the Project Area is 3,800 to 4,200 meters.
+Added: Overall, the seafloor slopes at approximately 0.57˚ (1 meter per kilometer) but the Abyssal Plains are traversed by ridges, with amplitude of 50 to 300 meters (maximum 1,000 meters) and wavelength of 1 to 10 kilometers.
+Added: The Abyssal Plains are punctuated by extinct volcanoes rising 500 to 2,000 meters above the seafloor.
Seafloor polymetallic nodules rest on the seafloor at the seawater — sediment interface.
21 unchanged sentences
● detailed seafloor survey work with an autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV), utilizing an MBES, Side Scan Sonar (SSS), Sub-Bottom Profiler (SBP), and camera payload;
−Removed: ● a total of 252 box core samples collected using a 0.75 m 2 box corer, mainly on a 10 km by 10 km square grid were used for resource evaluation.
+Added: ● a total of 252 box core samples collected using a 0.75 square meters box corer, mainly on a 10 kilometers by 10 kilometers square grid were used for resource evaluation.
The nodules in the box cores were collected, and their characteristics measured and recorded in detail.
15 unchanged sentences
Seafloor areas with slopes steeper than 6° were excised from the mineral resource estimate.
−Removed: The measured mineral resource was assigned to the area within NORI Area D where box-core sampling was conducted on a nominal 7 km by 7 km spacing and infilled with estimates of nodule abundance from seafloor photography to a spacing of 3.5 km by 3.5 km.
−Removed: The indicated mineral resource was assigned to the area within NORI Area D where box-core sampling was conducted on a nominal spacing of 7 km by 7 km or 10 km by 10 km but without additional photo-estimates of nodule abundance.
+Added: The measured mineral resource was assigned to the area within NORI Area D where box-core sampling was conducted on a nominal 7 kilometers by 7 kilometers spacing and infilled with estimates of nodule abundance from seafloor photography to a spacing of 3.5 kilometers by 3.5 kilometers.
+Added: The indicated mineral resource was assigned to the area within NORI Area D where box-core sampling was conducted on a nominal spacing of 7 kilometers by 7 kilometers or 10 kilometers by 10 kilometers but without additional photo-estimates of nodule abundance.
The inferred mineral resource was assigned to the areas of abyssal plain in the southeast corner of NORI Area D that are largely unsampled.
The volcanic high in the southeast corner was excluded from the mineral resource estimate due to the high level of uncertainty about nodule abundance and grades in this domain.
−Removed: The mineral resource estimate for NORI Area D at a 4 kg/m 2 abundance cut-off is set forth below.
+Added: The mineral resource estimate for NORI Area D at a 4 kilogram/square meters abundance cut-off is set forth below.
This cut-off is derived from the estimates of costs and revenues presented in the NORI Technical Report Summary, generalized as follows:
1.7 Mt minimum annual tonnage mined;
−Removed: $0.25 million/km 2 for offshore operating costs;
−Removed: 1,036 km 2 collected area processed;
+Added: $0.25 million/square kilometers for offshore operating costs;
+Added: 1,036 square kilometers collected area processed;
$95/dry tonne for transport costs;
19 unchanged sentences
nickel metal $16,472/t;
−Removed: nickel in nickel sulfate $18,807/t Ni;
copper metal $6,872/t;
cobalt metal $46,333/t;
−Removed: cobalt in cobalt sulfate $56,920/t Co;
−Removed: manganese in manganese silicate $4.50/dmtu.
+Added: cobalt in manganese in manganese silicate $4.50/dmtu.
The price estimates are long term (2034 – 2046) forecasts provided in a report by CRU International Limited (CRU, October 23, 2020).
The Qualified Person considered that this timeframe is reasonable in view of the likely time required to bring the majority of the NORI mineral resources into production.
−Removed: Sampling of NORI Area D at a spacing of 10 km by 10 km during the 2019 campaign confirmed that the nodules have low variability and high continuity.
+Added: Sampling of NORI Area D at a spacing of 10 kilometers by 10 kilometers during the 2019 campaign confirmed that the nodules have low variability and high continuity.
The mineral resource estimate set forth above is 4 Mt Measured and 341 Mt indicated, and 11 Mt inferred mineral resources.
14 unchanged sentences
These estimates are presented on an undiluted basis without adjustment for resource recovery.
−Removed: Information concerning our mineral properties in the NORI Technical Report Summary and in this Annual Report on Form 10-K includes information that has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
+Added: Information concerning our mineral properties in the NORI Technical Report Summary and in this Annual Report includes information that has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
Under SEC standards, mineralization, such as mineral resources, may not be classified as a “reserve” unless the determination has been made that the mineralization could be economically and legally produced or extracted at the time of the reserve determination.
12 unchanged sentences
Additionally, this phased development will allow for an adaptive approach to environmental management providing learning at small-scale which would be applied as the development increases in scale.
+Added: The development plan has been refined since the creation of the NORI Technical Report Summary.
The proposed seafloor development phases are as follows:
−Removed: ● The Collector Test is designed to perform proof of concept for the methods of collecting and lifting the nodules while acquiring sufficient data to design a commercial system.
−Removed: The Collector Test would use a converted sixth generation drillship, the Hidden Gem .
−Removed: Nodules collected during the test would be stored on the Hidden Gem and brought to shore for use in large scale process pilot testing.
−Removed: The test would not demonstrate the transshipment of nodules to a shore-based facility.
−Removed: ● Project Zero would be an extension of the Collector Test using an upgrade of the Hidden Gem to produce a sufficient and continuous quantity of nodules to support a relatively small commercial operation of at least 1.3 Mtpa (wet) nodules delivered to a shore-based facility.
+Added: ● The Collector Test was designed to perform proof of concept for the methods of collecting and lifting the nodules while acquiring sufficient data to design a commercial system.
+Added: The Collector Test used a converted sixth generation drillship, the Hidden Gem .
+Added: Nodules collected during the test were stored on the Hidden Gem and brought to shore for use in large scale process pilot testing.
+Added: The test did not demonstrate the transshipment of nodules to a shore-based facility.
+Added: ● Project Zero System would be an extension of the Collector Test using an upgrade of the Hidden Gem to produce a sufficient and continuous quantity of nodules to support commercial operation commencing at 1.3 Mtpa increasing in staged increments to 3.0 Mtpa of wet nodules delivered to a shore-based facility.
This operation would demonstrate a more continuous collection operation at a larger scale than the Collector Test and would demonstrate the transshipment of nodules to a processing facility.
It would also allow for the implementation and testing of adaptive management systems to ensure environmental compliance.
−Removed: ● Project One would increase production in a further three steps:
−Removed: 1) introduction of a second converted drillship (Drill Ship 2) with a capacity of up to 3.6 Mtpa (wet), 2) a further upgrade of the Hidden Gem to up to 3.6 Mtpa (wet) and 3) construction of a new purpose-built production support vessel (Collector Ship 1) with capacity of up to 8.2 Mtpa (wet).
−Removed: Project One would benefit from lessons learned on the Collector Test and Project Zero.
+Added: ● Project Zero Plan of Work application contemplates that an increase in production is achieved via the introduction of another production vessel with the capacity of up to 3.0 Mtpa.
● The processing of the polymetallic nodules would also be ramped up in phases:
● In Project Zero, NORI proposes to toll-treat polymetallic nodules at existing RKEF smelters, utilizing excess industry capacity.
−Removed: NORI advises there is significant interest from many parties in China and Japan to utilize RKEF plants which may become stranded as a result of the Indonesian government nickel laterite ore export ban restricting supply of the nickel laterite feedstock that they currently utilize.
−Removed: These RKEF plants were originally built to convert nickel laterite to nickel pig iron and could be converted to smelt polymetallic nodules.
+Added: NORI advises there is significant interest from many parties in China, Indonesia and Japan to utilize RKEF plants which may become stranded as a result of the Indonesian government nickel laterite ore export ban restricting supply of the nickel laterite feedstock that they currently utilize and the significant recent build-out of capacity in Indonesia which may have resulted in processing capacity oversupply.
+Added: These RKEF plants were originally built to convert nickel laterite to nickel pig iron and could be converted to smelt polymetallic nodules with minor modifications.
● In Project One, a purpose-built process plant would be constructed, including pyrometallurgical (~50% of Project One production, with the other ~50% tolled through existing RKEF facilities) and hydrometallurgical circuits (100% of Project One production).
25 unchanged sentences
The PSVs are intended to be equipped with controllable thrusters and to be capable of dynamic positioning (DP), which should allow the vessels and risers to track the collectors.
−Removed: The Collector Ship 1 PSV is expected to be similar in size to an Aframax or New Panamax class of tanker, displacing approximately 103,000 t, and housing a crew of around 120 personnel.
+Added: The Collector Ship 1 PSV is expected to be similar in size to an Aframax or New Panamax class of tanker, displacing approximately 103,000 tonnes, and housing a crew of around 120 personnel.
Nodules are planned to be discharged from the RALS to the PSVs, where they are expected to be dewatered and temporarily stored or transferred directly to a transport vessel.
77 unchanged sentences
The project is expected to provide a source of revenue to our sponsor country, Nauru, and the ISA.
−Removed: The onshore environmental and social impacts have not yet been assessed because the process plant has not been designed in detail, and the location and host country (and hence regulatory regime) not confirmed.
+Added: The onshore environmental and social impacts are in the process of being evaluated as part of the feasibility being undertaken by PAMCO under the binding MoU signed in November 2023 for nodules that would be processed at their existing facility in Hachinohe, Japan.
+Added: This is an existing facility that has processed laterite ores since the mid 1960’s and has all the required operating permits to do so.
+Added: PAMCO are working with Japanese authorities to ensure that the environmental impacts of treating nodules are minimized and can be undertaken within PAMCO existing permissions or ensuring appropriate permissions are issued if required.
+Added: It is likely that additional facilities beyond PAMCO will be required as production expands.
+Added: This could involve processing through additional tolling facilities or potentially newly built facilities.
+Added: The onshore environmental and social impacts of these facilities have not been assessed because the tolling facilities have not been identified or a new-build process plant has not been designed in detail, and the location and host country (and hence regulatory regime) not confirmed.
The planned metallurgical process will not generate solid waste products, and the deleterious elements (for example, cadmium and arsenic) content of the nodules is very low, indicating that with careful management the environmental impacts of the processing operation could be very low.
180 unchanged sentences
Portions of the following information are based on assumptions, qualifications and procedures which are not fully described herein.
−Removed: Reference should be made to the full text of the TOML Technical Report Summary, which has been filed as exhibit 96.2 to this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
+Added: Reference should be made to the full text of the TOML Technical Report Summary, which has been incorporated by reference as exhibit 96.2 to this Annual Report.
In the event that we determine that any of modifying factors, estimates and other scientific and technical information in the report materially change, we may update or file a new technical report in the future.
3 unchanged sentences
The CCZ is located in international waters between Hawaii and Mexico.
−Removed: The western-end of the CCZ is approximately 1,000 km south of the Hawaiian island group.
−Removed: From here, the CCZ extends over 4,500 km east-northeast, in an approximately 600 km wide trend, with the eastern limits approximately 2,000 km west of southern Mexico.
+Added: The western-end of the CCZ is approximately 1,000 kilometers south of the Hawaiian island group.
+Added: From here, the CCZ extends over 4,500 kilometers east-northeast, in an approximately 600 kilomeers wide trend, with the eastern limits approximately 2,000 kilometers west of southern Mexico.
The region is well-located to ship nodules to the American continent or across the Pacific to Asian markets.
−Removed: The TOML Contract Area comprises six separate blocks (A through F) in the CCZ with a combined area of 74,713 km 2 .
+Added: The TOML Contract Area comprises six separate blocks (A through F) in the CCZ with a combined area of 74,713 square kilometers.
TOML Contract Area extents
DD — Decimal degrees, UTM — Universal Transverse Mercator map projection
−Removed: The CCZ lies between Hawaii and Mexico and is accessible by ship from various ports in the United States and South America.
+Added: The CCZ lies between Hawaii and Mexico and is accessible by ship from various ports in the U.S.
+Added: and South America.
As the CCZ deposit does not include any habitable land and is not near coastal waters, there is no requirement to negotiate access rights from landowners for seafloor collection operations.
2 unchanged sentences
Tenements and permits
−Removed: See Business-Government Regulations-The TOML Exploration Contract, Business-Government Regulations-The TOML Sponsorship Agreement and Business-Government Regulations- International Seabed Authority above for information related to tenements and permits in the TOML Contract Area
+Added: See Business Regulations-The TOML Exploration Contract, Business Regulations-The TOML Sponsorship Agreement and Business Regulations- International Seabed Authority above for information related to tenements and permits in the TOML Contract Area
TOML obligations and sponsorship
−Removed: See Business-Government Regulations-The TOML Exploration Contract, Business-Government Regulations-The TOML Sponsorship Agreement above for information related to this agreement in the TOML Contract Area.
+Added: See Business Regulations-The TOML Exploration Contract, Business Regulations-The TOML Sponsorship Agreement above for information related to this agreement in the TOML Contract Area.
Royalties and taxes
−Removed: See Business-Government Regulations-Royalties and taxes above for information with respect to our obligations for royalties and taxes in the TOML Contract Area.
+Added: See Business Regulations-Royalties and taxes above for information with respect to our obligations for royalties and taxes in the TOML Contract Area.
History of previous exploration activities in the TOML Area
17 unchanged sentences
The CCZ seafloor forms part of the Abyssal Plains, which are the largest physiographic province on Earth.
−Removed: This mineral field is essentially a single mineral deposit almost 5,000 km in length and up to 600 km wide.
+Added: This mineral field is essentially a single mineral deposit almost 5,000 kilometers in length and up to 600 kilometers wide.
The size and level of uniformity of mineralization is unmatched by any mineral deposit of similar value on land.
39 unchanged sentences
Estimation of tonnage and grade for the TOML Contract Area within the CCZ was undertaken using only sample data within the TOML Contract Area in the second quarter of 2016.
−Removed: The estimates are based on the historical box-core and free fall-grab nodule sampling (262 samples) supplemented with recently acquired TOML nodule box core (113 samples) and photo-profile data (20,857 frames over 587 line km).
+Added: The estimates are based on the historical box-core and free fall-grab nodule sampling (262 samples) supplemented with recently acquired TOML nodule box core (113 samples) and photo-profile data (20,857 frames over 587 line kilometers).
Only sample data within the TOML Contract Area was used to inform the estimates.
Six block models were constructed using the geostatistical modelling programs Gstat 1.1-3 and R 3.2.5, one for each TOML Exploration Area (A to F), in three passes.
−Removed: The first pass used a parent block dimension of 1.75 km by 1.75 km and filled the areas defined as measured mineral resource.
−Removed: The second pass for indicated mineral resource used a parent block size of 3.5 km by 3.5 km while the third pass for inferred mineral resource used a parent block size of 7.0 km by 7.0 km.
+Added: The first pass used a parent block dimension of 1.75 kilometers by 1.75 kilometers and filled the areas defined as measured mineral resource.
+Added: The second pass for indicated mineral resource used a parent block size of 3.5 kilometers by 3.5 kilometers while the third pass for inferred mineral resource used a parent block size of 7.0 kilometers by 7.0 kilometers.
The modelling methodology used for estimating the mineral resource was determined through careful consideration of the scale of deposit, mechanism of nodule formation, geological controls and nature of the sampling method.
4 unchanged sentences
The Qualified Person also considered that the combination of the TOML and historical nodule sample data (physical samples and photo based long axis estimates) combined with detailed backscatter, photo profiling and geological interpretation is sufficient to estimate polymetallic nodule indicated mineral resources and, in one small especially data rich area, measured mineral resources.
−Removed: Inferred mineral resource classification was based on sampling by pioneer contractors on a nominal spacing of 20 km, the variation and uncertainty in the sample quality, and the likely presence of short-range variation to nodule abundance.
−Removed: Indicated mineral resource classification was based on box core sampling by TOML on a nominal spacing of approximately 7 km by 7 km (including photo profiling in some cases at 7 km by 3 km), supplemented by sampling by pioneer contractors.
−Removed: Measured mineral resource was based on box core sampling by TOML on a nominal spacing of approximately 7 km by 7 km plus photo-profiling on a nominal spacing of 3.5 km by 3.0 km, supplemented by sampling by pioneer contractors.
−Removed: The mineral resource estimate for the TOML Contract Area, and at a 4 kg/m 2 abundance cut-off is set forth below.
+Added: Inferred mineral resource classification was based on sampling by pioneer contractors on a nominal spacing of 20 kilometers, the variation and uncertainty in the sample quality, and the likely presence of short-range variation to nodule abundance.
+Added: Indicated mineral resource classification was based on box core sampling by TOML on a nominal spacing of approximately 7 kilometers by 7 kilometers (including photo profiling in some cases at 7 kilometers by 3 kilometers), supplemented by sampling by pioneer contractors.
+Added: Measured mineral resource was based on box core sampling by TOML on a nominal spacing of approximately 7 km by 7 kilometers plus photo-profiling on a nominal spacing of 3.5 kilometers by 3.0 kilometers, supplemented by sampling by pioneer contractors.
+Added: The mineral resource estimate for the TOML Contract Area, and at a 4 kilogram/square meters abundance cut-off is set forth below.
The estimated mineral resources were determined in 2021, as of December 31, 2020, and also reflect the estimated mineral resources as of December 31, 2023, as none of the mineral resources in these areas were depleted by mining or any other activities.
15 unchanged sentences
1.7 Mt minimum annual tonnage mined;
−Removed: $0.25 Million/km 2 for offshore operating costs;
−Removed: 1,036 km 2 collected area processed;
+Added: $0.25 million/square kilometers for offshore operating costs;
+Added: 1,036 square kilometers collected area processed;
$95/dry tonne for transport costs;
8 unchanged sentences
nickel metal $16,472/t;
−Removed: nickel in nickel sulfate $18,807/t Ni;
copper metal $6,872/t;
cobalt metal $46,333/t;
−Removed: cobalt in cobalt sulfate $56,920/t Co;
manganese in manganese silicate $4.50/dmtu.
11 unchanged sentences
These changes show that it is reasonable to expect that the majority of inferred mineral resources could be upgraded to indicated or measured resources with further exploration.
−Removed: Information concerning our mineral properties in the TOML Technical Report Summary and in this Annual Report on Form 10-K includes information that has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
+Added: Information concerning our mineral properties in the TOML Technical Report Summary and in this Annual Report includes information that has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
Under SEC standards, mineralization, such as mineral resources, may not be classified as a “reserve” unless the determination has been made that the mineralization could be economically and legally produced or extracted at the time of the reserve determination.
−Removed: As used in this Annual Report on Form 10-K, the terms “mineral resource,” “measured mineral resource,” “indicated mineral resource” and “inferred mineral resource” are defined and used in accordance with the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
+Added: As used in this Annual Report, the terms “mineral resource,” “measured mineral resource,” “indicated mineral resource” and “inferred mineral resource” are defined and used in accordance with the SEC Mining Rules set forth in subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
You are specifically cautioned not to assume that any part or all of the mineral deposits in these categories will ever be converted into mineral reserves, as defined by the SEC.
123 unchanged sentences
Compared sentence by sentence after normalising whitespace, quotation marks, case and digits, so re-formatting and restated figures do not read as changed language. Wording changes appear as one removal and one addition. The current filing and the prior one are authoritative.