Item 1. Legal Proceedings
Item 1. Legal Proceedings.
Our company is aware that we have been named in a lawsuit filed
on August 9, 2017, by Steven P. Nickolas, a stockholder of our company and our
former president and chief executive officer and a former director of our
company, in the Maricopa County, Arizona, Superior Court, styled as Nickolas v.
The Alkaline Water Company, Inc., et al., cause number CV2017-007786. In the
complaint in that action, Mr. Nickolas seeks damages and injunctive relief
compelling our company to issue a certificate for 1,500,000 shares of our common
stock, which he alleges to have converted from the same number of Series C
preferred stock on July 16, 2017. This lawsuit has been dismissed with prejudice
pursuant to a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims dated October
31, 2017 detailed below in this Item 1.
Our company is a defendant in a lawsuit filed on April 11, 2017
by Steven P. Nickolas in the Maricopa County, Arizona, Superior Court, Nickolas
v. The Alkaline Water Company, Inc., et al., cause number CV2017-053064. Mr.
Nickolas seeks damages arising out of the alleged breach of a written employment
agreement between our company and Mr. Nickolas. Mr. Nickolas alleges that our
company wrongfully terminated the employment agreement and has failed to pay
wages due to him under the employment agreement. Our company denies the
allegations of the claims, and has counterclaimed against Mr. Nickolas for
damages suffered by our company as a result of numerous breaches of fiduciary
duty owed to our company by Mr. Nickolas in his capacity as officer and director
of our company, including diversion of corporate assets to personal matters, and
actively interfering with our companys suppliers and customers. This lawsuit
against our company, along with our counterclaims, has been dismissed with
prejudice pursuant to a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims dated
October 31, 2017 detailed below in this Item 1.
Our company is a nominal defendant in a lawsuit filed on April
6, 2017 by Steven P. Nickolas derivatively on behalf of our company against
Richard A. Wright, David Guarino, and Aaron Keay (current directors of our
company), and Daniel Lorey (current employee of our company) and our companys
former accounting firm, Seale & Beers, LLC. The lawsuit is pending in the
Maricopa County, Arizona, Superior Court, Steven P. Nickolas, derivatively on
behalf of the Alkaline Water Company, v. Richard A. Wright, et al. cause number
CV2017-005488 (the Derivative Action). Mr. Nickolas alleges a range of conduct
including breach of fiduciary and general duties owed to our company. Some of
these allegations were first raised by Mr. Nickolas in August, 2016 and, at that
time, our company appointed an independent director, Mr. Keay, to conduct an
investigation of the allegations. Mr. Keay conducted the investigation and
concluded that the claims were without merit. Though our company is a nominal
defendant in this action, our company believes the claims in the action are
baseless and has denied the claims. We anticipate that the other defendants will
defend the action vigorously, and is paying the cost of defending against the
claims, subject to a reservation of rights in the event of a finding the
principal defendants breached duties owed to our company and are not eligible
for indemnification. This lawsuit against all of the parties, including our
company as a nominal defendant, is currently in the process of being dismissed
with prejudice pursuant a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims
dated October 31, 2017 detailed below in this Item 1.
Steven P. Nickolas also filed virtually an identical lawsuit to
the Derivative Action in his individual capacity against Richard A. Wright,
David Guarino, and Dan Lorey. The lawsuit was filed on April 6, 2017 and is
pending in the Maricopa County, Arizona, Superior Court, Steven P. Nickolas vs.
Richard A. Wright et al. cause number CV2017-005486 (the Individual Action).
The allegations in the Individual Action are nearly identical to those in
the Derivative Action. We anticipate that the defendants will defend the action vigorously, and are paying the cost of defending against the claims, subject to a reservation of rights in the event of a finding the principal defendants breached
duties owed to our company and are not eligible for indemnification. This lawsuit against all of the individual parties has been dismissed with prejudice pursuant to a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims dated October 31, 2017 detailed
below in this Item 1.
On October 31, 2017, our company and its subsidiaries entered into a Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims (the “Settlement Agreement”) with Steven P. Nickolas, the Nickolas Family Trust, Water Engineering Solutions, LLC and
Enhanced Beverages, LLC, companies and trust that are controlled or owned by Mr. Nickolas, (collectively, the “Nickolas Parties”) and McDowell 78, LLC and Wright Investments Group, LLC, a company controlled or owned by Richard A. Wright,
(collectively, “Wright/McDowell”).
The Settlement Agreement provides, among other things, the following:
1.
Simultaneous with the full execution of the Settlement Agreement, we agreed to pay Mr. Nickolas $110,000 in one lump sum (paid);
2.
From the date of the Settlement Agreement, we agreed to waive the application of our Insider Trading Policy as to Mr. Nickolas, thereby removing any black-out periods for all future sales of our common stock by Mr. Nickolas;
3.
Within three business date of the full execution of the Settlement Agreement, we agreed to instruct our transfer agent to issue to Mr. Nickolas 700,000 shares of our common stock (issued);
4.
Within 10 business days of the full execution of the Settlement Agreement, we agreed to issue to Mr. Nickolas 300,000 shares of our Series D Preferred Stock (issued);
5.
In exchange of 700,000 shares of our common stock and 300,000 shares of our Series D Preferred Stock described above, Mr. Nickolas forfeited his 10,000,000 shares of our Series A Preferred Stock, to be cancelled for no further
consideration;
6.
Upon the full execution of the Settlement Agreement, Mr. Nickolas and our company agreed to file the stipulations to dismiss the complaints and counterclaim filed by each of them with prejudice, with each side to bear its own
costs and attorney’s fees. In addition, our company and Wright/McDowell agreed that they will effectuate the dismissal of an arbitration proceeding against the Nickolas Parties with prejudice, with each side to bear its own attorneys’
fees and costs;
7.
Mr. Nickolas surrendered all right, interest or claim to the shares of our common stock owned by WIN Investments, LLC and Lifewater Industries, LLC for no additional consideration;
8.
Mr. Nickolas acknowledged and agreed that the employment agreement between Mr. Nickolas and our company was terminated as of April 7, 2017 and no further amounts are owed to Mr. Nickolas under the employment agreement and we
agreed to waive restrictive covenants set out in the employment agreement.
9.
We agreed to assume financial responsibility for the federal tax obligations in the total amount of $45,738.68 owed by Mr. Nickolas and certain outstanding invoice in the amount of $21,008.71;
10.
Mr. Nickolas acknowledged and agreed that 1,500,000 stock options with an exercise price of $0.52 issued to Mr. Nickolas on or about March 1, 2016 has expired and a total of 148,000 stock options issued to Mr. Nickolas before
2016 will automatically expire 90 days from October 6, 2017, the date Mr. Nickolas ceased being a director of our company;
11.
We agreed that Mr. Nickolas will have access to a reasonable amount of Alkaline88 water, not to exceed 30 cases at the time of pickup at our facility, for his personal consumption only at no cost while Mr. Nickolas is a direct stockholder of our company and Mr. Nickolas will be limited to an average of 20 cases per month for his personal consumption; and
12.
The parties also agreed to mutual release of claims.
Our company was named as a defendant in a lawsuit filed on April 6, 2017, by Douglas Horn in the Maricopa County, Arizona, Superior Court, styled as “Horn v. The Alkaline Water Company, Inc., et al.,” cause number CV2017-005485. Mr. Horn
sought damages arising out of the alleged breach of a written employment agreement between our company and Mr. Horn. Mr. Horn alleged that our company has failed to pay wages and to transfer stock allegedly owed to him under the terms of his
employment agreement. Our company denied the allegations of the claims, and moved to dismiss pursuant to the terms of the employment agreement which require that all disputes be resolved by arbitration. In response, Mr. Horn filed a notice of
dismissal of all claims in that court, without prejudice. On September 21, 2017, Mr. Horn filed a Demand for Arbitration with the American Arbitration Association, asserting the same claims. The claim has been assigned No. 01-17-0005-6474. Our
company has responded, denying any liability to Mr. Horn. No date for arbitration has yet been set. Our company intends to defend the claim vigorously.
Except as detailed above, we know of no material pending legal proceedings to which our company or any of our subsidiaries is a party or of which any of our properties, or the properties of any of our subsidiaries, is the subject. In addition, we do
not know of any such proceedings contemplated by any governmental authorities.
Except as detailed above, we know of no material proceedings in which any of our directors, officers or affiliates, or any registered or beneficial stockholder is a party adverse to our company or any of our subsidiaries or has a material interest
adverse to our company or any of our subsidiaries.
Item 1A. Risk Factors.
Information regarding risk factors appears in our Annual Report on Form 10-K filed on July 14, 2017. There have been no material changes since July 14, 2017 from the risk factors disclosed in that Form 10-K.
Text extracted from the filing as submitted to EDGAR. Formatting, tables and exhibits are simplified for reading; the original document is authoritative for anything you rely on.