Item 1. Business
Item 1. Business
Introduction
Tenon Medical, Inc. (the “Company”),
was incorporated in the State of Delaware on June 19, 2012 and was headquartered in San Ramon, California until June 2021 when it relocated
to Los Gatos, California. The Company is a medical device company that has developed The Catamaran™ SI Joint Fusion System (“the
Catamaran System”) that offers a novel, less invasive approach to the sacroiliac joint (the “SI Joint”) using a single,
robust, titanium implant for treatment of the most common types of SI Joint disorders that cause lower back pain. The Company received
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) clearance in 2018 for The Catamaran System and is currently focused on the US market.
Since the national launch of the Catamaran System in October 2022, the Company is focused on three commercial opportunities: 1) Primary
SI Joint procedures, 2) Revision procedures of failed SI Joint implants and 3) SI Joint fusion adjunct to a spine fusion construct.
The Opportunity
We estimate that over 30 million American adults
have chronic lower back pain. Published clinical studies have shown that 15% to 30% of all chronic lower back pain is associated with
the SI-Joint. For patients whose chronic lower back pain stems from the Sacroiliac Joint (“SI-Joint”), our experience in both
clinical trials and commercial settings indicates the system to be introduced by Tenon could be beneficial for patients who are properly
diagnosed and screened for surgery by trained healthcare providers.
In 2019, approximately 475,000 patients in the
United States were estimated to have received an aesthetic injection to temporarily alleviate pain emanating from the SI-Joint and/or
to diagnose SI-Joint pain. Additionally, several non-surgical technologies have been introduced in the past 10 years to address patients
who do not respond to conservative options, including systemic oral medications, opioids, physical therapy and injection therapy.
To date, the penetration of a surgical solution
for this market has been relatively low (5-7%). We believe this is due to complex surgical approaches and suboptimal implant design of
existing options. The penetration of this market with an optimized surgical solution is Tenon’s focus.
We believe the SI-Joint is the last major joint
to be successfully addressed by the spine implant industry. Studies have shown that disability resulting from disease of the SI-Joint
is comparable to the disability associated with a number of other serious spine conditions, such as knee and hip arthritis and degenerative
disc disease, each of which has surgical solutions where an implant is used, and a multi-billion-dollar market exists.
The SI-Joint
The SI-Joint is a strong weight bearing synovial
joint situated between the lumbar spine and the pelvis and is aligned along the longitudinal load bearing axis of the human spine when
in an upright posture. It functions as a force transfer conduit where it transfers axial loads bi-directionally from the spine to the
pelvis and lower extremities and allows forces to be transmitted from the extremities to the spine. It also provides load sharing between
the hip and spine to contribute towards attenuation of impact shock and stress from activities of daily living.
1
The SI-Joint is a relatively immobile joint that
connects the sacrum (the spinal segment that is attached to the base of the lumbar spine at the L5 vertebra) and the ilium of the pelvis.
Each SI-Joint is approximately 2-4mm wide and irregularly shaped.
Motion of the SI-Joint features vertical shear
and rotation. Although the rotational forces about the SI-Joint are relatively low, repetitive motions created by daily activities such
as walking, jogging, twisting at the hips, and jumping can increase the stresses on the SI-Joint. If the SI-Joint is compromised through
injury or degeneration, the load bearing and motion restraints from the surrounding anatomical structures of the SI-Joint will be compromised
resulting in abnormal stress transfers across the joint to these structures, thereby further augmenting the degenerative cascade of the
SI-Joint. Eventual pain and cessation of an individual’s normal activities due to a painful and unstable SI-Joint have led to an
increase in the recent development of SI-Joint stabilization devices.
Non-Surgical Treatment of Sacroiliac Joint
Disease
Several non-surgical treatments exist for suspected sacroiliac
joint pain. These conservative steps often provide desired relief for the patient. Non-surgical treatments include:
● Drug Therapy : including
opiates and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medications.
● Physical Therapy : which
can involve exercises as well as massage.
● Intra-Articular Injections
of Steroid Medications : which are typically performed by physicians who specialize in pain treatment or anesthesia.
● Radiofrequency Ablation :
or the cauterizing of the lateral branches of the sacral nerve roots.
When conservative steps fail to deliver sustained
pain relief and return to quality of life, specific diagnostic protocols are utilized to explore if a surgical option should be considered.
Diagnosis
Historically, diagnosing pain from the SI-Joint
was not routinely a focus of orthopedic or neurosurgery training during medical school or residency programs. Due to its invasiveness,
post-operative pain, and muscle disruption along with a difficult procedure overall, the open SI-Joint fusion procedure was rarely taught
in these settings.
The emergence of various SI-Joint surgical technologies
has generated a renewed discussion of SI-Joint issues. Of particular focus is the diagnostic protocol utilized to properly select patients
for SI-Joint surgery. Patients with low back pain typically start with primary care physicians who often refer to pain specialists. Here,
the patient will undergo traditional physical therapy combined with oral medications (anti-inflammatory, narcotic, etc.). If the patient
fails to respond to these steps the pain specialist may move to therapeutic injections of the SI-Joint. These injections may serve to
lessen inflammation to the point that the patient is satisfied. However, the impact from these injections is often transient. In this
case the patient is often referred to a clinician to determine if the patient may be a candidate for surgical intervention. A series of
provocative tests in clinic, combined with a specific injection protocol to isolate the SI-Joint as the pain generator is then utilized
to confirm the need for surgical intervention. Published literature has shown this technique to be a very effective step to determine
the best treatment to alleviate pain.
Limitations of Existing Treatment Options
Surgical fixation and fusion of the SI-Joint with
an open surgical technique was first reported in 1908, with further reports in the 1920s. The open procedure uses plates and screws, requires
a 6 to 12-inch incision and is extremely invasive. Due to the high invasiveness and associated morbidity, the use
of this procedure is limited to cases involving significant trauma, tumor, etc.
Less invasive surgical options along with implant
design began to emerge over the past 15 years. These options feature a variety of approaches and implant designs and have been met with
varying degrees of adoption. Lack of a standard and accepted diagnostic approach, complexity of approach, high morbidity of approach,
abnormally high complication rates and inability to radiographically confirm fusion have all been cited as reasons for low adoption of
these technologies.
2
Commercialization
Tenon initiated its national commercial launch
of the Catamaran System in October 2022 to address what we believe is a large market opportunity. The Catamaran System includes instruments
and implants designed to prepare and fixate the SI-Joint for fusion. The Catamaran System is distinct from other competitive offerings
in the following ways:
● Transfixes the SI-Joint
● Inferior / Posterior Sacroiliac Fusion Approach
● Reduced Approach Morbidity
● Direct And Visualized Approach to the SI-Joint
● Single Implant Technique
● Insertion Trajectory Away from the Neural Foramen
● Insertion Trajectory Away from Major Lateral Vascular Structures
● Autologous Bone Grafting in the Ilium, Sacrum and Bridge
● Radiographic Confirmation of Bridging Bone Fusion of the
SI-Joint
The fixation device and
its key features are shown below:
Key
Features
“Pontoon”
in the ilium
“Pontoon”
in the sacrum
“Pontoons
and Bridge” filled with autologous bone from drilling process
Leading
edge osteotome creates defect and facilitates ease of insertion
The Catamaran System is a singular implant designed
with several proprietary components which allow for it to be explicitly formatted to address the SI-Joint with a single approach and implant.
This contrasts with several competitive implant systems that require multiple approach pathways and implants to achieve fixation. In addition,
the inferior-posterior approach is designed to be direct to the joint and through limited anatomical structures which may minimize the
morbidity of the approach. The implant features a patented dual pontoon open cell design which enables the clinician to pack the pontoons
with the patient’s own autologous bone designed to promote bone fusion across the joint. The Catamaran System is designed specially
to resist vertical shear and rotation of the joint in which it was implanted, helping stabilize the joint in preparation for eventual
fusion.
The instruments we have developed are proprietary
to the Catamaran System and specifically designed to transfix the SI-Joint and facilitate an inferior-posterior approach that is unique
to the system.
Tenon also has developed a proprietary 2D placement
protocol as well as a protocol for 3D navigation utilizing the latest techniques in spine surgery. These Tenon advancements are intended
to further enhance the safety of the procedure and encourage more physicians to adopt the procedure.
In October 2022, we received Institutional Review
Board (“IRB”) approval from WCG IRB for two separate Tenon-sponsored post market clinical studies of the Catamaran System.
The approval by WCG allows designated Catamaran study centers to begin recruiting and enrolling patients into the clinical studies. The
first approval from WCG IRB will support a prospective, multi-center, single arm post market study that will evaluate the clinical outcomes
of patients with sacroiliac joint disruptions or degenerative sacroiliitis treated with the Catamaran System. Patients will be followed
out to 24 months assessing various patient reported outcomes, radiographic assessments, and adverse events. The second prospective, multi-center,
Catamaran study will evaluate 6-to-12-month radiographic outcomes to assess fusion of patients that have already undergone treatment with
the Catamaran System. In addition, retrospective and prospective clinical outcomes will be evaluated. We anticipate completing enrollment
by the end of the second quarter of 2024.
3
The Market
Based on market research and internal estimates,
Tenon believes the potential market for surgical intervention of the SI-Joint to be 279,000 procedures annually in the U.S. alone, for
a potential annual market of approximately $2.0 billion. These estimates are driven by coding data for SI-Joint injections to treat pain
and informed assumptions relative to surgical intervention candidacy
Based on public information, we believe that the
largest clinical device supplier in this market does approximately 16,000 SI-Joint fixations a year representing the largest market share.
The other competitive devices that are offered are all products generally part of much larger companies with a variety of orthopedic devices
and as such do not specifically call out the number of specific SI-Joint procedures performed with their products. It is our belief that
all other competitive devices represent approximately another 5,000 potential SI-Joint procedures.
Based on this analysis we believe the market is
vastly underserved and only penetrated 5-7%, leaving tremendous upside for a next generation device that meets the needs of this market.
Competitive Landscape
We believe Tenon is the first company to develop
and manufacture a novel Inferior-Posterior approach featuring a dual pontoon fixation technology cleared by the FDA expressly for SI-Joint
fusion. The approach, referred to as Inferior Posterior Sacroiliac Fusion is focused on these critical aspects of the surgical procedure:
1.
Designed for Safety: the approach trajectory and angle are away from the neural foramen and major vascular structures.
2.
Focus on Efficiency: the approach is designed to be direct to the SI-Joint, which allows for visualization of the joint and is designed to pass through minimal muscle structures, which may result in a faster and more efficient surgical procedure and reduced post-op pain for the patient.
3.
Targeted Anatomy: the approach places the implant in the aspect of the SI-Joint with the densest bone, designed to provide maximum fixation and resistance to vertical shear. This is designed to provide a secure press fit of the implant, reducing the incidence of revision surgery due to implant loosening, which we believe is the reason for many competitive device failures as reported to the FDA Medical Device Reporting (MDR).
Note the trajectory used in the Inferior Posterior
approach:
The following are the primary factors on which companies compete in
our industry:
●
product and clinical procedure effectiveness;
●
ease of surgical technique and use of associated instruments;
4
●
safety;
●
published clinical outcomes and evidence;
●
sales force knowledge and service levels;
●
product support and service, and customer service;
●
comprehensive training, including disease, anatomy, diagnosis, and treatment;
●
product innovation and the speed of innovation;
●
intellectual property;
●
accountability and responsiveness to customers’ demands;
●
pricing and reimbursement;
●
scientific (biomechanics) data; and
●
attracting and retaining key personnel.
Tenon believes that refined approaches and improved
implant design will open the door to enhanced adoption and further penetration of this important market.
The Catamaran™ SI-Joint Fusion System
Solution
Until October 2022, Tenon sold the Catamaran
System to a limited number of clinician advisors to refine the product for a full commercial launch. In October 2022, Tenon initiated
a full commercial launch at the NASS meeting in Chicago. The Catamaran System includes instruments and implants designed to prepare and
fixate the SI-Joint for fusion. We believe the Catamaran System will address a large market opportunity with a superior product and is
distinct from other competitive offerings in the following ways:
●
Transfixes the SI joint
●
Inferior-Posterior Sacroiliac Fusion Approach
●
Reduced Approach Morbidity
●
Direct And Visualized Approach to the SI-Joint
●
Single Implant Technique
●
Insertion Trajectory Away from the Neural Foramen
●
Insertion Trajectory Away from Major Vascular Structures
●
Autologous Bone Grafting in the Ilium, Sacrum and Bridge
●
Radiographic Confirmation of Bridging Bone Fusion of the SI-Joint
5
The fixation device and its key features are shown
below:
Key Features
“Pontoon” in the ilium
“Pontoon” in the sacrum
“Pontoons and Bridge” filled with autologous bone from
drilling process
Leading edge osteotome creates defect and facilitates ease of insertion
The Catamaran System is a singular implant designed
with several proprietary components which allow for it to be explicitly formatted to transfix the SI-Joint with a single approach and
implant. This contrasts with several competitive implant systems that require multiple approach pathways and implants to achieve fixation.
In addition, the Inferior-Posterior approach is designed to be direct to the joint and through limited anatomical structures which may
minimize the morbidity of the approach. The implant features a patented dual pontoon open cell design which enables the clinician to pack
the pontoons with the patient’s own autologous bone designed to promote bone fusion across the joint. The Catamaran System is designed
specially to resist vertical shear and rotation of the joint in which it was implanted, helping stabilize the joint in preparation for
eventual fusion.
The instruments we have developed are proprietary
to The Catamaran System and specifically designed to facilitate an Inferior Posterior approach that is unique to the system.
Tenon also has developed a proprietary 2D placement
protocol as well as a protocol for 3D navigation utilizing the latest techniques in spine surgery. These Tenon advancements are intended
to further enhance the safety of the procedure and encourage more physicians to adopt the procedure.
The Catamaran System, as mentioned previously,
is placed in the densest aspect of the SI-Joint as confirmed by the pre-op planning images below:
Surgical Plan Key:
Yellow: Guidewire
Purple: Lateral Pontoon (Ilium)
Green: Medial Pontoon
(Sacrum)
Notes:
Upper Right Quadrant: The green and purple pontoons represent the placement
in the dense bone inferior – contrasted with the dorsal gap superiorly where competitive systems are most often placed.
Lower Right Quadrant: The yellow and purple outlines represent the
Catamaran System pontoons, illustrating the angle of insertion is away from the sacral neuro foramen providing for a much safter
trajectory for device implantation.
The Procedure
We believe the Catamaran System and its differentiated
characteristics allow for an efficient and effective procedure designed to deliver short-term stabilization and long-term fusion that
can be confirmed radiographically. Shown below is an illustration demonstrating the unique placement of the Catamaran System inserted
Inferior-Posterior and coming directly down to and transfixing the joint
6
The Catamaran System procedure is typically performed
under general anesthesia using a specially designed instrument set we provide to prepare for the Inferior-Posterior access to the SI-Joint.
Specially designed imaging and navigation protocols are designed to ensure the clinician has the proper entry point, trajectory, angle
and depth so that the pontoons of the Catamaran System are placed for maximum fixation. The Catamaran System incorporates two pontoons
and is designed so that when the system is impacted into the bone one pontoon is on the Illum side and the other is in the Sacrum side
with the bridge spanning the joint, preventing shear and rotation of the joint. The device also features an open cell design where the
patient’s own (autologous) bone is packed into the pontoons and the bridge to facilitate fusion across the joint. The leading edge
of the bridge is designed to act as an osteotome, providing a self-created deficit upon insertion. These features are designed to create
an ideal environment for bone ingrowth and fusion. Below is a fluoroscopic image of an implanted Catamaran Fixation Device spanning the
SI-Joint.
Tenon believes the surgical approach and implant
design it has developed, along with the 2D and 3D protocols for proper implantation will be received well by the clinician community who
have been looking for a next generation device. Our initial clinical results indicate that the Catamaran System is promoting fusion across
the joint as evidenced by post-op CT scans (the recognized gold standard widely accepted by the Clinical community).
Post-Op fluoroscopic image of
implant spanning the SI-Joint
6-Month CT-Scan showing clear
bridging bone fusion
A preliminary 18 case series (Michael Joseph Chaparro,
MD, F.A.A.N.S., F.A.C.S.) has documented that the Catamaran System does in fact promote fusion across the SI-Joint, which many of our
competitors have not been able to demonstrate. While products from some of our competitors use screws and triangular wedges to treat the
SI-Joint, most do not effectively resist the vertical shear and twisting within the joint. This 18 patient series was presented at the
North American Spine Society Annual Meeting in Chicago, IL in October 2022.
An independent biomechanical study (Lisa Ferrara,
Ph.D. OrthoKinetic Technologies, LLC now part of Element) demonstrated that a single Catamaran SIJ Fixation Device was superior to predicate
device in the areas of Fixation Strength, Shear Stiffness, Dynamic Endurance and Pullout Strength. We hold issued patents on the Catamaran
System and its unique features including the dual pontoons and the open cell structure for bone graft packing. We also hold an issued
patent for the method of placing the Catamaran System into the SI-Joint where one pontoon is in the ilium and the other in the sacrum.
7
The Catamaran System’s unique design has
already demonstrated radiographically confirmed fusion in initial patients. We believe that this beneficial advantage along with a simpler,
safer, and less painful procedure will make this the procedure of choice for most physicians. Tenon has initiated post market, IRB controlled
clinical trials to demonstrate this technology delivers on these advantages.
Coverage and Reimbursement
When a Tenon procedure utilizing the Catamaran
System is performed, the healthcare facility, either a hospital (inpatient or outpatient clinic), and the clinician submit claims
for reimbursement to the patient’s insurer. Generally, the facility obtains a lump sum payment, or facility fee, for SI-Joint fusions.
Our products are purchased by the facility, along with other supplies used in the procedure. The facility must also pay for its own fixed
costs of operation, including certain operating room personnel involved in the procedure, ICD and other medical services care. If these
costs exceed the facility reimbursement, the facility’s managers may discourage or restrict clinicians from performing the procedure
in the facility or using certain technologies, such as the Catamaran System, to perform the procedure.
The Medicare 2022 national average hospital inpatient
payment for SI-Joint procedures ranges from approximately $25,000 to approximately $59,000 depending on the procedural approach and the
presence of Complication and Comorbidity/Major Complication and Comorbidity.
The Medicare 2022 national average hospital outpatient
clinic payment is $21,897. We believe that insurer payments to facilities are generally adequate for these facilities to offer the Catamaran
System procedure.
Physicians are reimbursed separately for their
professional time and effort to perform a surgical procedure. Depending on the surgical approach, the incision size, type and extent
of imaging guidance, indication for procedure, and the insurer, the Catamaran System procedure may be reported by the physician using
any one of the applicable following CPT ® codes 27279, 27280, 27299. The Medicare 2022 national average payment for CPT ®
27279 is $807 and $1,352 for 27280. CPT ® 27299 has no national valuation. Clinicians, however, can present a crosswalk
to another procedure believed to be fairly equivalent and/or comparison to a code for which there is an existing valuation.
For some governmental programs, such as Medicaid,
coverage and reimbursement differ from state to state, and some state Medicaid programs may not pay an adequate amount for the procedures
performed with our products, if any payment is made at all. Similar to Medicaid, many private payors’ coverage and payment may differ
from one payer to another.
We believe that some clinicians view the current
Medicare reimbursement amount as insufficient for current SI-Joint procedures, given the work effort involved with the procedure, including
the time to diagnose the patient and obtain prior authorization from the patient’s health insurer when necessary. Many private payors
require extensive documentation of a multi-step diagnosis before authorizing SI-Joint fusion for a patient. We believe that some private
payors apply their own coverage policies and criteria inconsistently, and clinicians may experience difficulties in securing approval
and coverage for sacroiliac fusion procedures. Additionally, many private payors limit coverage for open SI-Joint fusion to trauma, tumors
or extensive spine fusion procedures involving multiple levels.
We believe the unique design of the Catamaran
System and the fact the Catamaran System may be placed both via an open procedure based on the clinician’s determination of trauma
induced SI-Joint pain or as a minimally invasive approach provides a unique and differentiated approach for the clinician to determine
the reimbursement code that best fits the clinical problem. We believe this is a significant advantage over competitive devices by providing
the clinician the clinical flexibility of offering the best clinical solution and approach for patients.
Sales and Marketing
We market and sell the Catamaran System primarily
through independent distributors and sales representatives specializing in spine sales. Our target customer base includes approximately
12,000 physicians who perform spine and/or pelvic surgical procedures.
We provide general sales and marketing training
to our independent sales representative along with comprehensive, hands-on cadaveric and dry-lab training sessions focusing on the clinical
benefits of the Catamaran System and the importance of using the 2D and 3D protocols we have developed. We believe many clinicians have
already been trained using one of the alternative products but have not been satisfied with the approach and technology. This provides
Tenon with an opportunity to demonstrate to an already-trained-clinician the unique attributes of the Catamaran System.
8
Our business objective is to introduce the Next
Generation Implant for SI-Joint Fixation. The past 10 years has seen an acceleration in recognition and discussion of the SI-Joint as
a cause of pain that can be treated. However, adoption has been hindered by complexity of the procedure as evidenced by the significant
number of reported Medical Device Records (MDR’s). The need for multiple implants and resulting post-op pain has also contributed
to low adoption numbers. Our strategy is to provide a safer, faster, and better surgical experience and a significant pain reduction benefit
for the patient. Our goals are simple but impactful and as such we plan on the following:
●
Educate and inform physicians and other healthcare providers, payors, and patients about the growing body of evidence supporting what we believe is the safety, durable clinical effectiveness, economic benefit, and reduction in opioid use associated with SI-Joint fixation and the Catamaran System procedure.
●
Utilize the most effective means of training via video and in-person labs demonstrating the ease of use with 2D and 3D navigation. Since many physicians have already been trained but have not incorporated SI-Joint fixation into their practices we will work with these physicians to reengage and train them on the Next Generation of an SI-Joint implant which incorporates a safer and simpler approach.
●
Utilize the best approaches of direct-to-consumer outreach to educate patients that there is a safe solution to help them improve their quality of life. Additionally, to reach the broadest physician and patient audience on case study results from around the United States we plan to implement an active social media campaign incorporating Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, etc.
●
Invest in our independent sales representative network to ensure that all Tenon representatives have the latest in marketing and education tools to reduce the time from training to adoption.
●
Remain true to our next generation product development strategy by continually bringing out new advancements in and around the SI-Joint and pelvic region.
●
Continue to grow our existing intellectual property portfolio.
●
Execute post-market clinical research to confirm the benefits of the distinct approach and implant.
Regulatory Status
Tenon has received FDA 510(k) clearance to market
and sell the Catamaran System for sacroiliac joint fusion for conditions including sacroiliac joint disruptions and degenerative sacroiliitis.
Research & Development
Our initial development of the Catamaran System
has incorporated several differentiating features which we believe will make an important contribution for many patients suffering from
SI-Joint pain. To our knowledge, no other competitive product incorporates these Next Generation features:
● Dual Pontoon implant that transfixes
the targeted joint;
● Open cell design designed for
utilizing the patient’s own autologous bone for promotion of fusion;
● Bridge design between the dual
pontoons for enhanced strength;
● Leading edge of the implant
designed to function as an osteotome providing a self-creating defect feature not available with competitive systems;
● Single implant designed with
varying pontoon sizes to ensure a robust fixation based on anatomy; and
● Additional smaller Catamaran
designed for smaller anatomy and/or revision surgery.
The Tenon development plan is to expand the Catamaran
System offering by introducing a series of implant lengths so that the clinician has a full complement of sized implants to choose from
depending on the patient’s anatomy. These product enhancements will enable the clinician to optimize the size of each implant to
ensure full fixation based on anatomy. Tenon believes, based on literature searches of prior SI-Joint fixation technologies, that adverse
event incidence where the implant has loosened or been misplaced thereby requiring a revision surgery could reach 20%. Tenon believes
that its ability to make the Catamaran System a specifically sized fixation device will benefit many patients requiring a revision surgery.
9
The Catamaran System shown below has been cleared
by the FDA for commercialization. This patented titanium implant incorporates the Catamaran SI-Joint Fixation Device pontoon design and
the open cell configuration which we believe, when filled with the patient’s autologous bone, promotes fusion. The two images below
show a comparison of a competitive implant requiring three implants and the Catamaran System unique pontoon design showing the need of
only one implant to cover the same amount of the SI-Joint.
The Catamaran™ SIJ Fusion
System Single Implant
SI Bone iFuse ® Three Implants
Our mission will be to continue developing enhancements
to the Catamaran System to meet our customers’ changing needs and to improve the surgery’s effectiveness. This includes revision
surgery options as well as options as an adjunct to long fusion constructs in the lumbar spine.
Additionally, Tenon will initiate various post
marketing clinical studies in accordance with FDA cleared indications for use. Since we have already received FDA 510(k) clearance to
market the Catamaran System, our clinical study activities will be focused on capturing post-market safety and efficacy data. Tenon has
received IRB approval for two post-market trials, including a 50 patient, 10 center multi-center trial and a prospective CT trial to demonstrate
fusion in patient who have already been treated with the Catamaran System. Clinical study endpoints may include but are not limited to;
pain scoring, length of surgical procedure, blood loss, post-op pain, length of stay, duration of non-weight-bearing post-op, radiographic
confirmation of fusion and surgical complication rates. Statistical analysis plans may be designed to demonstrate non-inferiority to historical
control, as reported in published literature, which may be used for submission to peer reviewed articles / posters / presentations and
the like.
Intellectual Property
Developing and maintaining a strong intellectual
property position is an important element of our business. We maintain the intellectual property through a combination of patent protection,
trademarks, and trade secrets. We have sought, and will continue to seek, patent protection for our technology, for improvements to our
technology, as well as for any of our other technologies where we believe such protection will be advantageous.
As of March 29, 2024, we own four (4) issued
U.S. utility patents, sixteen (16) pending U.S. utility patent applications, four (4) issued foreign utility patents in Australia, Canada,
Japan and Israel, and two (2) pending foreign utility patent applications in the European Community, Brazil and Japan. We also have thirteen
(13) registered trademarks (seven (7) U.S. and six (6) foreign) and twelve (12) pending trademark applications in the U.S.
Our utility patents and patent applications are
directed to several different aspects of our sacroiliac (SI) joint stabilization technology and related patent platform. By way of example,
our granted patents and pending patent applications cover various structural features of our unique Catamaran SI-Joint prosthesis and
means for employing same to stabilize a dysfunctional SI-Joint.
The term of individual patents depends on the
legal term for patents in the countries in which they are granted. In most countries, including the United States, the patent term for
a utility patent is generally 20 years from the earliest claimed filing date of a nonprovisional patent application in the applicable
country. Our issued U.S. and foreign utility patents are anticipated to naturally expire around 2031, and our U.S. pending utility patent
applications, if issued into patents, are similarly anticipated to naturally expire around 2031, excluding any additional patent term
adjustment(s) or extension(s), and assuming payment of all applicable maintenance or annuity fees. Once a patent expires, patent protection
ends and an invention enters the public domain allowing anyone to commercially exploit the invention without infringing the patent.
10
We cannot guarantee that patents will be issued
from any of our pending applications or that issued patents will be of sufficient scope or strength to provide meaningful protection for
our technology. Notwithstanding the scope of the patent protection available to us, a competitor could develop methods or devices that
are not covered by our patents or circumvent these patents. Furthermore, although, at present, we are unaware of any patent applications
that may result in one or more issued patents that our existing products or technologies may be alleged to infringe, since U.S. and foreign
applications can take many months to publish, there may be applications unknown to us that may result in one or more issued patents that
our existing products or technologies may be alleged to infringe.
As of March 29, 2024, we also have priority rights
in and to several significant trademarks that support our products and brand, including seven (7) registered U.S. trademarks, twelve
(12) U.S. trademark applications and six (6) foreign trademark applications in the European Community (excluding the United Kingdom),
Australia and Japan.
Regulation
Domestic Regulation of Our Products and
Business. Our research, development and clinical programs, as well as our manufacturing and marketing operations, are subject
to extensive regulation in the United States and other countries. Most notably, all of our products sold in the United States are subject
to the federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (the “FDCA”), as implemented and enforced by the FDA. The FDA governs the following
activities that we perform or that are performed on our behalf, to ensure that medical products distributed domestically or exported internationally
are safe and effective for their intended uses:
●
product design, development, and manufacture;
●
product safety, testing, labeling, and storage;
●
record keeping procedures;
●
product marketing, sales, distribution and export; and
●
post-marketing surveillance, complaint handling, medical device reporting, reporting of deaths, serious injuries or device malfunctions, and repair or recall of products.
There are numerous FDA regulatory requirements
governing the clearance or approval and marketing of our products. These include:
●
product listing and establishment registration, which helps facilitate FDA inspections and other regulatory action;
●
investigational device exemptions to conduct premarket clinical trials, which include extensive monitoring, recordkeeping, and reporting requirements;
●
QSR, which requires manufacturers, including contract manufacturers, to follow stringent design, testing, control, documentation and other quality assurance procedures during all aspects of the manufacturing process;
●
labeling regulations and FDA prohibitions against the promotion of products for uncleared, unapproved or off-label use or indication;
● clearance of product modifications
that could significantly affect safety or effectiveness or that would constitute a major change in intended use of one of our cleared
devices;
● approval of product modifications
that affect the safety or effectiveness of one of our approved devices;
●
medical device reporting regulations, which require that manufacturers comply with FDA requirements to report if their device may have caused or contributed to a death or serious injury, or has malfunctioned in a way that would likely cause or contribute to a death or serious injury if the malfunction of the device or a similar device were to recur;
●
post-approval restrictions or conditions, including post-approval study commitments;
●
post-market surveillance regulations, which apply when necessary to protect the public health or to provide additional safety and effectiveness data for the device;
11
●
the FDA’s recall authority, whereby it can ask, or under certain conditions order, device manufacturers to recall from the market a product that is in violation of governing laws and regulations;
●
regulations pertaining to voluntary recalls; and
●
notices of corrections or removals.
The FDA has broad post-market and regulatory enforcement
powers. We and our contract manufacturers are subject to announced and unannounced inspections by the FDA to determine our compliance
with the QSR and other regulations and these inspections may include the manufacturing facilities of our suppliers. Tenon has a robust
Supplier Qualification and Audit process as part of our quality system that ensures contract manufacturers, and their suppliers meet all
requirements.
An FDA pre-approval inspection is not required
for the Catamaran System due to its lower device classification, class II versus the higher class III. As is the case for most medical
device firms, Tenon is subject to routine and “for cause” FDA inspections. Routine inspections are mandated by
law every 2 years for class II and class III device manufacturers and make up the majority of FDA’s inspections. If a serious public health
risk is identified during a routine inspection, the inspection may convert to a “for cause” inspection. In the current
environment, FDA has limited compliance resources and has not been able to perform routine inspections in accordance with the 2-year mandate. Therefore,
FDA uses a risk-based approach when deciding which firms should be selected for a routine inspection. Using the Establishment Registration
and Device Listing databases, FDA identifies who manufactures and/or distributes which devices. The firms are then prioritized by risk,
class III > class II > class I. Firms that have recently introduced a new device to the market also are given higher priority, as
well as those that have had significant prior violations and complaints. At present, Tenon has not been selected for an FDA inspection. Tenon
uses best practices to secure and maintain regulatory compliance by engaging with suppliers and contract manufacturing firms that are
ISO 13485 (or equivalent) compliant and by periodically performing internal, external, and third-party inspections and audits of the facilities
and systems to assess compliance.
FDA Premarket Clearance and Approval Requirements.
Unless an exemption applies, each medical device we wish to commercially distribute in the United States will require either premarket
notification, or 510(k), clearance or approval of a PMA from the FDA. The FDA classifies medical devices into one of three classes. Devices
deemed to pose lower risks are placed in either Class I or II, which typically requires the manufacturer to submit to the FDA a premarket
notification requesting permission to commercially distribute the device. This process is generally known as 510(k) clearance. Some low-risk
devices are exempted from this requirement. Devices deemed by the FDA to pose the greatest risks, such as life-sustaining, life- supporting
or implantable devices, or devices deemed not substantially equivalent to a previously cleared 510(k) device, are placed in Class III,
requiring a PMA. If the FDA agrees that the device is substantially equivalent to a predicate device currently on the market, it will
grant 510(k) clearance to commercially market the device. If the FDA determines that the device is “not substantially equivalent”
to a previously cleared device, the device is automatically designated as a Class III device. The device sponsor must then fulfill
more rigorous PMA requirements or can request a risk-based classification determination for the device in accordance with the “de
novo” process, which is a route to market for novel medical devices that are low to moderate risk and are not substantially equivalent
to a predicate device. All of our currently marketed products are Class II devices, subject to 510(k) clearance.
After a device receives 510(k) marketing clearance,
any modification that could significantly affect its safety or effectiveness, or that would constitute a major change or modification
in its intended use, will require a new 510(k) marketing clearance or, depending on the modification, PMA approval. The determination
as to whether or not a modification could significantly affect the device’s safety or effectiveness is initially left to the manufacturer
using available FDA guidance. Many minor modifications today are accomplished by a “letter to file” in which the manufacture
documents the rationale for the change and why a new 510(k) is not required. However, the FDA may review such letters to file to evaluate
the regulatory status of the modified product at any time and may require the manufacturer to cease marketing and recall the modified
device until 510(k) clearance or PMA approval is obtained. The manufacturer may also be subject to significant regulatory fines or penalties.
Clinical Trials. Clinical trials
are generally required to support a PMA application and are sometimes required for 510(k) clearance. Such trials for implanted devices
such as the Catamaran SIJ Fixation Device generally require an investigational device exemption application, or IDE, approved in advance
by the FDA for a specified number of subjects and study sites, unless the product is deemed a nonsignificant risk device eligible for
more abbreviated IDE requirements. Clinical trials are subject to extensive monitoring, recordkeeping, and reporting requirements. Clinical
trials must be conducted under the oversight of an institutional review board, or IRB, for the relevant clinical trial sites and must
comply with FDA regulations, including but not limited to those relating to good clinical practices. To conduct a clinical trial, we also
are required to obtain the subjects’ informed consent in form and substance that complies with both FDA requirements and state and
federal privacy and human subject protection regulations. We, the FDA, or the institutional review board, or IRB, could suspend a clinical
trial at any time for various reasons, including a belief that the risks to study subjects outweigh the anticipated benefits. Even if
a trial is completed, the results of clinical testing may not adequately demonstrate the safety and effectiveness of the device or may
otherwise not be sufficient to obtain FDA clearance or approval to market the product in the United States.
12
Pervasive and Continuing Regulation. After
a device is placed on the market, numerous regulatory requirements continue to apply. These include:
●
Product listing and establishment registration, which helps facilitate FDA inspections and other regulatory action;
●
QSR, which requires manufacturers, including contract manufacturers, to follow stringent design, testing, control, documentation, and other quality assurance procedures during all aspects of the manufacturing process;
●
labeling regulations and FDA prohibitions against the promotion of products for uncleared, unapproved, or off-label use or indication;
●
clearance of product modifications that could significantly affect safety or effectiveness or that would constitute a major change in intended use of one of our cleared devices;
●
approval of product modifications that affect the safety or effectiveness of one of our approved devices;
●
post-approval restrictions or condition, including post-approval study commitments;
●
post-market surveillance regulations, which apply when necessary to protect the public health or to provide additional safety and effectiveness data for the device;
●
the FDA’s recall authority, whereby it can ask, or under certain conditions order, device manufacturers to recall from the market a product that is in violation of governing laws and regulations;
●
regulations pertaining to voluntary recalls; and
●
notices of corrections or removals.
The FDA has broad post-market and regulatory enforcement
powers. We are subject to unannounced inspections by the FDA to determine our compliance with the QSR and other regulations, and these
inspections may include the manufacturing facilities of some of our subcontractors. Failure by us or by our suppliers to comply with applicable
regulatory requirements can result in enforcement action by the FDA or other regulatory authorities, which may result in sanctions including,
but not limited to:
●
untitled letters, warning letters, fines, injunctions, consent decrees, and civil penalties;
●
unanticipated expenditures to address or defend such actions
●
customer notifications for repair, replacement, refunds;
●
Recall, detention, or seizure of our products;
●
operating restrictions or partial suspension or total shutdown of production;
●
refusing or delaying our requests for 510(k) clearance or PMA approval of new products or modified products;
●
operating restrictions;
●
withdrawing 510(k) clearances or PMA approvals that have already been granted:
●
refusal to grant export approval for our products; or
●
criminal prosecution.
13
The FDA has not yet inspected our contract manufacturer’s manufacturing
facilities.
Promotional Materials “Off-Label”
Promotion. Advertising and promotion of medical devices, in addition to being regulated by the FDA, are also regulated by the
Federal Trade Commission and by state regulatory and enforcement authorities. If the FDA determines that our promotional materials or
training constitutes promotion of an unapproved use, it could request that we modify our training or promotional materials or subject
us to regulatory or enforcement actions, including the issuance of an untitled letter, a warning letter, injunction, seizure, civil fine,
or criminal penalties. It is also possible that other federal, state, or foreign enforcement authorities might take action if they consider
our promotional or training materials to constitute promotion of an unapproved use, which could result in significant fines or penalties
under other statutory authorities, such as laws prohibiting false claims for reimbursement. In that event, our reputation could be damaged,
and adoption of the products would be impaired.
In addition, under the federal Lanham Act and
similar state laws, competitors, and others can initiate litigation relating to advertising claims.
Healthcare Fraud and Abuse
Federal and state governmental agencies and equivalent
foreign authorities subject the healthcare industry to intense regulatory scrutiny, including heightened civil and criminal enforcement
efforts. These laws constrain the sales, marketing and other promotional activities of medical device manufacturers by limiting the kinds
of financial arrangements we may have with hospitals, physicians and other potential purchases of our products. Federal healthcare fraud
and abuse laws apply to our business when a customer submits a claim for an item or service that is reimbursed under Medicare, Medicaid,
or other federally funded healthcare programs. Descriptions of some of the laws and regulations that may affect our ability to operate
follows.
The federal Anti-Kickback Statute prohibits, among
other things, persons from knowingly and willfully soliciting, receiving, offering, or paying remuneration, directly or indirectly, in
cash or in kind, to induce or reward either the referral of an individual for, or the purchase, order or recommendation of, items or services
for which payment may be made, in whole or in part, under federal healthcare programs. The term “remuneration” has been broadly
interpreted to include anything of value, and the government can establish a violation of the Anti-Kickback Statute without proving that
a person or entity had actual knowledge of, or a specific intent to violate, the law. The Anti-Kickback Statute is subject to evolving
interpretations and has been applied by government enforcement officials to a number of common business arrangements in the medical device
industry. There are a number of statutory exceptions and regulatory safe harbors protecting some common activities from prosecution; however,
those exceptions and safe harbors are drawn narrowly, and there is no exception or safe harbor for many common business activities. Failure
to meet all of the requirements of a particular statutory exception or regulatory safe harbor does not make the conduct per se illegal
under the Anti-Kickback Statute, but the legality of the arrangement will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis based on the totality of
the facts and circumstances. A number of states also have anti-kickback laws that establish similar prohibitions that may apply to items
or services reimbursed by government programs, as well as by any third-party payors, including commercial payors.
The civil False Claims Act prohibits, among other
things, knowingly presenting or causing the presentation of a false or fraudulent claim for payment of federal funds, or knowingly making,
or causing to be made, a false record or statement material to a false or fraudulent claim to avoid, decrease or conceal an obligation
to pay money to the federal government. A claim including items or services resulting from a violation of the Anti- Kickback Statute constitutes
a false or fraudulent claim for purposes of the False Claims Act. Actions under the False Claims Act may be brought by the government
or as a qui tam action by a private individual in the name of the government. Qui tam actions are filed under seal and impose
a mandatory duty on the U.S. Department of Justice to investigate such allegations. Most private citizen actions are declined by the Department
of Justice or dismissed by federal courts. However, the investigation costs for a company can be significant and material even if the
allegations are without merit. There are also criminal penalties, including imprisonment and criminal fines, for making or presenting
a false or fictitious or fraudulent claim to the federal government.
False Claims Act liability is potentially significant
in the healthcare industry because the statute provides for treble damages and mandatory penalties of $11,181 to $22,363 per claim (adjusted
annually for inflation). Because of the potential for large monetary exposure, healthcare companies often resolve allegations without
admissions of liability for significant and sometimes material amounts to avoid the uncertainty of treble damages and per claim penalties
that may awarded in litigation proceedings. Moreover, to avoid the risk of exclusion from federal healthcare programs as a result of a
False Claims Act settlement, companies may enter into corporate integrity agreements with the government, which may impose substantial
costs on companies to ensure compliance.
In addition, HIPAA created federal criminal statutes
that prohibit, among other actions, knowingly and willfully executing, or attempting to execute, a scheme to defraud any healthcare benefit
program, including private third-party payors, knowingly and willfully embezzling or stealing from a healthcare benefit program, willfully
obstructing a criminal investigation of a healthcare offense, and knowingly and willfully falsifying, concealing or covering up a material
fact or making any materially false, fictitious or fraudulent statement in connection with the delivery of or payment for healthcare benefits,
items or services.
The federal Physician Payment Sunshine Act, implemented
by CMS as the Open Payments program, requires manufacturers of drugs, devices, biologics and medical supplies for which payment is available
under Medicare, Medicaid, or the Children’s Health Insurance Program to report annually to CMS information related to payments or
other “transfers of value” made to physicians and teaching hospitals, and requires applicable manufacturers to report annually
to CMS ownership and investment interests held by physicians and their immediate family members and payments or other “transfers
of value” to such physician owners.
14
Certain states also mandate implementation of
corporate compliance programs, impose restrictions on device manufacturer marketing practices, and/or require tracking and reporting of
gifts, compensation, and other remuneration to healthcare professionals and entities.
The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and similar
anti-bribery laws in other countries, such as the UK Bribery Act, generally prohibit companies and their intermediaries from making improper
payments to government officials and/or other persons for the purpose of obtaining or retaining business. Our policies mandate compliance
with these anti-bribery laws.
Violations of these federal and state fraud abuse
laws can subject us to administrative, civil, and criminal penalties, including imprisonment, substantial fines, penalties, damages, and
exclusion from participation in federal healthcare programs, including Medicare and Medicaid.
Data Privacy and Security Laws
HIPAA requires the notification of patients, and
other compliance actions, in the event of a breach of unsecured PHI. If notification to patients of a breach is required, such notification
must be provided without unreasonable delay and in no event later than 60 calendar days after discovery of the breach. In addition, if
the PHI of 500 or more individuals is improperly used or disclosed, we could be required to report the improper use or disclosure to the
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, or HHS, which would post the violation on its website, and to the media. Failure to comply
with the HIPAA privacy and security standards can result in civil monetary penalties up to $55,910 per violation, not to exceed $1.68 million
per calendar year for non-compliance of an identical provision, and, in certain circumstances, criminal penalties with fines up to $250,000
per violation and/or imprisonment.
In addition, even when HIPAA does not apply, according
to the FTC, failing to take appropriate steps to keep consumers’ personal information secure constitutes unfair acts or practices
in or affecting commerce in violation of Section 5(a) of the FTCA, 15 U.S.C § 45(a). The FTC expects a company’s data
security measures to be reasonable and appropriate in light of the sensitivity and volume of consumer information it holds, the size and
complexity of its business, and the cost of available tools to improve security and reduce vulnerabilities. Medical data is considered
sensitive data that merits stronger safeguards. The FTC’s guidance for appropriately securing consumers’ personal information
is similar to what is required by the HIPAA Security Rule.
We are subject to the supervision of local data
protection authorities in those jurisdictions where we are established or otherwise subject to applicable law. We depend on a number of
third parties in relation to our provision of our services, a number of which process personal data on our behalf. With each such provider
we enter into contractual arrangements to ensure that they only process personal data according to our instructions, and that they have
sufficient technical and organizational security measures in place. Where we transfer personal data outside the EEA, we do so in compliance
with the relevant data export requirements. We take our data protection obligations seriously, as any improper disclosure, particularly
with regard to our customers’ sensitive personal data, could negatively impact our business and/or our reputation.
Manufacturing and Supply
We do not manufacture any products or component
parts and currently use five contract manufacturers to produce all of our instruments, implants and sterilization cases. The majority
of our instruments have a secondary manufacturing supplier, and we continually work with additional manufacturers to establish secondary
manufacturing suppliers. Our contract manufacturers source and purchase all raw materials used in the manufacture of the Catamaran System
which includes mainly stainless steel and aluminum for our instruments and sterilization cases and titanium for our implants.
We do not currently have manufacturing agreements
with any of our contract manufacturers and orders are controlled through purchase orders. The Company does not believe its relationship
with any one contract manufacturer is material to its business.
We believe the manufacturing operations of our
contract manufacturers, and those of the suppliers of our manufacturers, comply with regulations mandated by the FDA, as well as Medical
Devices Directive regulations in the EEA. Manufacturing facilities that produce medical devices or component parts intended for distribution
world-wide are subject to regulation and periodic planned and unannounced inspection by the FDA and other domestic and international regulatory
agencies.
15
In the United States, the product we sell is required
to be manufactured in compliance with the QSR, which covers the methods used in, and the facilities used for, the design, testing, control,
manufacturing, labelling, quality assurance, packaging, storage, and shipping.
We are required to demonstrate continuing compliance
with applicable regulatory requirements and will be subject to FDA inspections. Further, we and certain of our contract manufacturers
are required to comply with all applicable regulations and current good manufacturing practices. As set forth above, these FDA regulations
cover, among other things, the methods and documentation of the design, testing, production, control, quality assurance, labeling, packaging,
sterilization, storage, and shipping of our products. Compliance with applicable regulatory requirements is subject to continual review
and is monitored rigorously through periodic inspections. If we or our manufacturers fail to adhere to current good manufacturing practice
requirements, this could delay production of our products and lead to fines, difficulties in obtaining regulatory approvals, recalls,
enforcement actions, including injunctive relief or consent decrees, or other consequences, which could, in turn, have a material adverse
effect on our financial condition or results of operations.
Product Liability and Insurance
The manufacture and sale of our products subjects
us to the risk of financial exposure to product liability claims. Our products are used in situations in which there is a risk of serious
injury or death. We carry insurance policies which we believe to be customary for similar companies in our industry. We cannot assure
you that these policies will be sufficient to cover all or substantially all losses that we experience.
We endeavor to maintain executive and organization
liability insurance in a form and with aggregate coverage limits that we believe are adequate for our business purposes.
Human Capital Resources
As of March 29, 2024, we have a total of 21 employees,
all of whom are full-time, and 5 senior consulting advisors of various specialty including product development, general administrative
and accounting. None of our employees is subject to a collective bargaining agreement, and we consider our relationship with our employees
to be good.
Our human capital resources objectives include,
as applicable, identifying, recruiting, retaining, incentivizing and integrating our existing and new employees, advisors and consultants.
The principal purposes of our equity and cash incentive plans are to attract, retain and reward personnel through the granting of stock-based
and cash-based compensation awards, in order to increase stockholder value and the success of our Company by motivating such individuals
to perform to the best of their abilities and achieve our objectives.
Corporate Information
We were incorporated on June 6, 2012, in Delaware.
Our principal executive offices are located at 104 Cooper Court, Los Gatos, CA 95032 and our telephone number is (408) 649-5760. Our
website address is www.tenonmed.com. The information on, or that can be accessed through, our website is not part of this report.
We have included our website address as an inactive textual reference only.
16