Item 1. Business
Item 1. Business
INTRODUCTION
Ambac Financial Group, Inc. ("AFG"), headquartered in New York City, is a financial services holding company incorporated in the State of Delaware on April 29, 1991 . References to “Ambac,” the “Company,” “we,” “our,” and “us” are to AFG and its subsidiaries, as the context requires. Ambac operates three principal businesses:
• Legacy Financial Guarantee ("LFG") Insurance — Ambac's financial guarantee business includes the activities of Ambac Assurance Corporation ("AAC") and its wholly owned subsidiaries, including Ambac Assurance UK Limited (“Ambac UK”) and Ambac Financial Services LLC ("AFS"). Both AAC and Ambac UK are financial guarantee insurance companies that have been in run-off, having not underwritten any new business since 2008. AFS is AAC's legacy interest rate swap provider which is also currently being run-off.
• Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance — Ambac's specialty property and casualty program business ("Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance") includes five admitted carriers and an excess and surplus lines (“E&S” or “nonadmitted”) carrier (collectively, “Everspan”). Everspan carriers have an AM Best rating of 'A-' (Excellent).
• Insurance Distribution — Ambac's insurance distribution business includes managing general agents/underwriters (collectively "MGAs" or "MGA/Us") and insurance brokers operating as part of Cirrata Group.
Beginning in 2022, the Company began reporting these three business operations as segments; see Note 3. Segment Information for further information.
AFG, on a standalone basis, had $211 million in net assets (excluding its investment in subsidiaries) and net operating loss carry-forwards of $ 3,400 million ($ 1,760 million of which is allocated to AAC) at December 31, 2023. See Schedule II for more information on the holding company.
Strategies to Enhance Shareholder Value
The Company's primary goal is to maximize long-term shareholder value through the execution of targeted strategies for its (i) Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance and Insurance Distribution businesses and (ii) Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance business.
Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance and Insurance Distribution strategic priorities include:
• Growing our Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance business to generate underwriting profits from a diversified portfolio of commercial and personal liability risks accessed primarily through program administrators.
• Expanding our Insurance Distribution business based on deep domain knowledge in specialty and niche classes of
risk which generate attractive margins at scale. This will be achieved through acquisitions, establishing new businesses “de-novo,” and organic growth and diversification supported by a centralized technology led shared services offering.
• Making opportunistic investments that are strategic to both the Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance and Insurance Distribution businesses.
Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance strategic priorities include:
• Actively managing, de-risking and mitigating insured portfolio risk, and pursuing recoveries of previously paid losses.
• Improving operating efficiency and optimizing our asset and liability profile.
• Exploring strategic options to further maximize value for AFG.
DESCRIPTION OF THE BUSINESS
Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance:
Financial guarantee insurance policies provide an unconditional and irrevocable guarantee which protects the holder of a debt obligation against non-payment when due of the principal and interest on the obligations guaranteed. Pursuant to such guarantees, AAC and Ambac UK make payments if the obligor responsible for making payments fails to do so when due. AAC and Ambac UK last wrote insurance policies in 2008 and have been in run-off ever since.
Financial guarantee revenues consist mostly of premiums earned from run-off insurance contracts, net of reinsurance, and income on investments held in AAC's and Ambac UK's investment portfolios. Financial guarantee expenses consist of: (i) loss and commutation payments; (ii) loss adjustment expenses; (iii) interest expense on debt, (iv) operating expenses and (v) insurance intangible amortization.
Ambac's Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance business strategy is to increase the residual value of AAC and Ambac UK with the ultimate goal of monetizing such value through (i) dividends and capital distributions while managing their active run-off; (ii) one or more reinsurance transactions or other de-risking transactions that will accelerate or enhance the ability of AAC and/or Ambac UK to pay dividends and make capital distributions; (iii) the sale of all or portions of AAC and/or Ambac UK; or (iv) other strategic transactions to accelerate and/or enhance the above-stated corporate strategy.
Ambac and its advisors are actively discussing strategic options for its Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance business with interested parties. While we anticipate that these discussions will be completed in 2024 there can be no assurance that we will ultimately complete any strategic initiative.
AAC and Ambac UK have been reducing risk within their insured portfolios focusing on exposures to financially stressed insured exposures as well as large and concentrated exposures. Opportunities for remediating losses on poorly performing
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 2
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
insured exposures depend on a number of factors including market conditions, the structure of the underlying risk, the perception of AAC’s or Ambac UK’s creditworthiness, as well as counterparty specific factors. Their ability to remediate risk and commute policies may be limited by available liquidity. Additionally, AAC and Ambac UK are actively managing their regulatory frameworks and seeking to optimize capital allocation in complex insured portfolios that include long duration obligations.
The execution of Ambac’s strategy to increase and monetize the value of its investment in AAC is subject to the restrictions set forth in the Settlement Agreement, dated as of June 7, 2010, as amended (the "Settlement Agreement"), by and among AAC, Ambac Credit Products LLC ("ACP"), AFG and certain counterparties to credit default swaps with ACP that were guaranteed by AAC, as well as the Stipulation and Order among the OCI, AFG and AAC that became effective on February 22, 2024 (the “Stipulation and Order”), replacing the Stipulation and Order that became effective on February 12, 2018, as amended (the “2018 Stipulation and Order”), each of which requires the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance for the State of Wisconsin ("OCI") and, under certain circumstances, holders of surplus notes, to approve certain actions taken by or in respect of AAC. In exercising its approval rights, OCI will act for the benefit of policyholders, and will not take into account the interests of AFG.
• The Settlement Agreement limits certain activities of AAC and its subsidiaries, such as issuing indebtedness; engaging in mergers and similar transactions; disposing of assets; making restricted payments; creating or permitting liens; engaging in transactions with affiliates; modifying or creating tax sharing agreements; and taking certain actions with respect to surplus notes (among other restrictions and limitations). The Settlement Agreement includes certain allowances with respect to these activities and generally requires the approval of OCI and, in some cases, holders of surplus notes issued pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, for consents, waivers or amendments.
• The Stipulation and Order requires AAC to maintain a level of surplus and contingency reserves as regards policyholders which provide reasonable security against contingencies affecting AAC’s financial position that are not otherwise fully covered by reserves or reinsurance; discount loss reserves in a manner approved by OCI; maintain OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework (as defined and described below) according to parameters specified by OCI; pay the costs of consultants and other experts retained by OCI; refrain from certain affiliate transactions and the payment of any dividend or other distribution without the prior non-disapproval of OCI; notify OCI of events that would or would be reasonably likely to cause a material adverse effect to AAC or its affiliates; obtain OCI’s non-disapproval to exercise certain control rights with respect to certain policies that were previously allocated to the Segregated Account of AAC; obtain OCI’s approval for non-ordinary course transactions involving consideration to be paid by AAC of $100 million or more; and obtain OCI’s approval of any changes to AAC’s investment policy or derivative use plan. The Stipulation and Order also requires AFG to use its best efforts to preserve the use of
NOLs for the benefit of AAC and its subsidiaries. The Stipulation and Order differs from the 2018 Stipulation and Order in that the 2018 Stipulation and Order (i) did not refer to OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework; (ii) included certain affirmative covenants concerning books and records, and reporting of information or events, that were not included in the Stipulation and Order; and (iii) contained a more restrictive limitation on transactions with affiliates. The Stipulation and Order has no fixed term and may be terminated or modified only with the approval of OCI. OCI reserved the right to modify or terminate the Stipulation and Order in a manner consistent with the interests of policyholders, creditors and the public generally.
The execution of Ambac’s strategy to increase the value of its investment in AAC may be affected by a new capital framework developed and implemented by OCI to assist OCI with making decisions related to capital management at AAC ("OCI's Runoff Capital Framework"). OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework applies risk-based and other adjustments to AAC’s assets and insured liabilities, as determined by OCI in its sole discretion. OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework allows AAC to understand the likely impact of various developments and actions now or in the future on AAC’s capital position thereunder. No changes in AAC’s current management of the business are required by OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework. AAC’s ability to use capital for potential future deleveraging transactions or distributions will require AAC to sustain an excess of risk-adjusted assets over risk-adjusted insured liabilities according to OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework, and to obtain OCI’s approval, and there can be no assurance that OCI will approve any such use of capital. The results of OCI’s Runoff Capital Framework are expected to vary over time based on changes in AAC’s financial position, insured portfolio developments, the impact of strategic actions taken by AAC, the impact of asset/liability management by AAC and, possibly, changes to the inputs and assumptions utilized by OCI.
AAC has a significant amount of debt outstanding in the form of principal and accrued but unpaid interest on surplus notes. Surplus notes are treated as capital for regulatory purposes as the obligation to pay principal and interest on them is subordinated to the obligation to pay policyholder claims and such payments cannot be made without the explicit authorization of the OCI.
AAC’s ability to pay dividends to AFG has also been significantly restricted by AAC’s financial condition and by regulatory, legal and contractual restrictions. Substantial uncertainty remains as to AAC's ability to pay dividends to AFG and the timing of any such dividends, which constrains AFG's liquidity. Refer to "Dividend Restrictions, Including Contractual Restrictions" below and to Note 8. Insurance Regulatory Restrictions to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in this Annual Report on Form 10-K, for more information on dividend payment restrictions.
Interest rate derivative transactions were executed through AFS, a wholly-owned subsidiary of AAC. All remaining interest rate derivative positions, which are substantially economically hedged, relate to legacy financial guarantee customer swaps. Until the second quarter of 2023, interest rate derivatives were also used to partially hedge interest rate risk in the financial
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 3
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
guarantee insurance and investment portfolios. AFS continues to be required to post collateral in excess of the market value of certain interest rate derivatives when they are in a mark-to-market loss position. While not anticipated, early termination of AFS’s derivatives could result in losses. AFS has borrowed cash and securities from AAC to help support its collateral and margin posting requirements and other cash needs.
Ambac manages a variety of risks inherent in its businesses, including credit, market, liquidity, operational and legal. These risks are identified, measured, and monitored through a variety of control mechanisms, which are in place at different levels throughout the organization. See “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk” included in Part II, Item 7A in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information.
Risk Management
Ambac’s financial guarantee insurance policies expose the Company to the direct credit risk of the assets and/or obligor supporting the guaranteed obligation. In addition, insured transactions expose Ambac to indirect risks that may increase our overall risk, such as credit risk separate from, but correlated with, our direct credit risk; market; model; economic, including the risk of economic recession; natural disaster; pandemic and mortality or other non-credit type risks. Please refer to Item 7 “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations - Financial Guarantees in Force” section below for details on the financial guarantee insured portfolio.
The Risk Management Group ("RMG") is primarily responsible for the management of the insured financial guarantee portfolio, including Surveillance and Risk Remediation (including through the pursuit of recoveries in respect of paid claims and commutations of policies). Our ability to execute certain risk management activities may be limited by the restrictions set forth in the Settlement Agreement and the Stipulation and Order, among other constraints. To the extent OCI's approval is required in connection with risk management activities, OCI's decisions may be guided by OCI's Runoff Capital Framework. See Note 1. Background and Business Description to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information.
Surveillance
Surveillance is focused on the early identification of potential stress and/or credit deterioration and the related analysis of credit exposures in the insured portfolio. Additionally, Surveillance evaluates the impact of changes in the economic, regulatory or political environment on the insured portfolio.
Analysts perform periodic credit reviews of insured exposures according to a schedule based on the risk profile of the guaranteed obligations or as necessitated by specific credit events or other macro-economic variables. Surveillance strategies have been developed for each bond type with review periods and scope of review based upon each bond type’s risk profile. The risk profile is assessed regularly in response to our own experience and judgments or external factors such as the economic environment and industry trends. The focus of a credit review is to assess performance, identify credit trends and recommend credit classifications, ratings and changes to a
transaction or bond type’s review period and surveillance requirements. Please refer to Note 2. Basis of Presentation and Significant Accounting Policies to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further discussion of the various credit classifications utilized by Ambac.
The insured portfolio contains exposures that are correlated and/or concentrated. RMG's surveillance activities include identifying these types of exposures and identifying the risks that would or could trigger credit deterioration across these related exposures. This is the case with student loans and residential mortgage-backed securities ("RMBS"), for example, which have several correlations including those associated with consumer lending, unemployment, interest rates and home prices. In the future, Ambac’s portfolio may be subject to similar credit deterioration arising from concentrated and/or correlated risks. Examples of other such risks that could impact our portfolio, and that our surveillance is designed to monitor include the impact of potential municipal bankruptcy contagion, the impact of large-scale domestic military spending or troop level cutbacks on our privatized military housing portfolio and event risk such as pandemics (e.g., COVID-19), natural disasters or other regional stresses. Most such risks cannot be predicted and may materialize unexpectedly or develop rapidly. Although our surveillance allows us to connect the event and stress to the related exposures and assign an adverse credit classification and estimate losses across the affected credits, when necessary, we may not have adequate resources or contractual rights and remedies to mitigate loss arising from such risks.
Watchlist and Adversely Classified Credits
Watch list and adversely classified credits are tracked closely and are discussed as part of scheduled RMG credit meetings. A summary of developments regarding adversely classified credits and credit trends is also provided to AFG’s, AAC’s and Ambac UK's Boards of Directors no less than quarterly.
Ambac assigns internal credit ratings to individual exposures as part of the Surveillance process. These internal credit ratings, which represent Ambac’s independent judgments, are based upon underlying credit parameters consistent with the exposure type.
Risk Remediation
Risk Remediation activities are centered on exposure reduction and loss mitigation related to the insured portfolio. In particular, the focus is on reducing exposure to credits that have negative developing trends, the potential for future adverse development or are already adversely classified by, among other things, exercising rights and remedies, which may help to mitigate losses in the event of further deterioration or events of default, or, as available, working with an issuer to refinance, defease or otherwise retire debt.
Loss mitigation focuses on the execution of commutation and related claims reduction or workout strategies for policies with potential future claims. For certain adversely classified, survey list and watch list credits (as described in Note 2. Basis of Presentation and Significant Accounting Policies to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 of this Annual Report on Form 10-K), risk remediation or loss
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 4
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
mitigation plans are developed and implemented that may include actions such as working with the issuer, trustee, bond counsel, servicer and other interested parties in an attempt to remediate the problem and minimize Ambac’s exposure to potential loss. Other actions could include working with bond holders and other economic stakeholders to negotiate, structure and execute solutions, such as commutations. In addition, reinsurance is used as a remediation tool to reduce exposure to certain targeted policies and large concentrations. In some cases, the RMG will engage restructuring or workout experts, attorneys and/or other consultants with appropriate expertise in the targeted loss mitigation area to assist in examining the underlying contracts or collateral, providing industry specific advice and/or executing strategies.
Control Rights
In certain domestic and international structured finance transactions, structured public finance transactions, public-private partnerships and other transactions, AAC and Ambac UK may be the control party as a result of insuring a transaction’s senior class or tranche of debt obligations. The control party may direct specified parties, usually the trustee, to take or not take certain actions following contractual defaults or trigger events. Control rights and the scope of direction and remedies vary considerably among our insured transactions. Because AAC and Ambac UK are party to and/or have certain rights in documents supporting transactions in the insured portfolio, they may receive requests for amendments, consents and waivers (“ACW”). Decisions to approve or reject ACWs are made by AAC’s and Ambac UK’s risk management groups based upon certain credit factors, such as the issuer’s ability to repay the bonds and the bond’s security features and structure.
P&C Industry Overview
We operate within the $875 billion U.S. P&C insurance market with a particular focus on the commercial MGA/U program market both on an Admitted and Excess & Surplus Lines ("E&S") basis.
Admitted and E&S Insurance
Insurance carriers sell commercial P&C products in the United States through one of two markets: the Admitted market and the E&S market.
The Admitted insurance market, which has highly regulated rates and policy forms, is more consistent in price and coverage. In the E&S market, there is increased flexibility in pricing, terms, and conditions in response to evolving market dynamics, and E&S carriers can tailor insurance products to facilitate coverage that would not otherwise be attainable. This unique flexibility lends itself to providing solutions for unique risks, which has driven meaningful growth within the E&S market over the last decade exceeding the growth rate of the Admitted market.
According to data from AM Best, the E&S market generated approximately $99 billion of direct written premium in 2022 an increase of 19.2% over the prior year and and represents over 11% of the industry direct premium volume. The E&S market is more heavily focused in commercial lines and accounted for over 21% of total commercial direct written premium for the first time in 2022. For the period of 2012 through 2022 the E&S
sector had a compound annual growth rate of 11% compared to 5% for the overall U.S. P&C sector.
Everspan presently has five admitted carriers, which are wholly-owned except as indicated below: Everspan Insurance Company; Greenwood Insurance Company; Consolidated National Insurance Company; Consolidated Specialty Insurance Company; and Providence Washington Insurance Company (90.1% owned). Everspan Indemnity Insurance Company ("Everspan Indemnity"), an E&S carrier, which is eligible to write business in all U.S. states and territories, is also part of Everspan.
MGA/U Program Market
It is estimated that U.S. MGA/Us generate between $70 to $100 billion of direct premiums in 2023. We believe there are significant advantages to the MGA/U business model when it comes to capturing the opportunity in the E&S market and propelling profitable growth. MGA/Us are specialized types of insurance agents or brokers that are vested with underwriting authority from an insurer, administering programs and negotiating contracts on their behalf. This is a particularly useful vehicle for P&C insurers as MGA/Us tend to participate in the E&S market where specialized expertise is needed to underwrite policies. Additionally, MGA/Us are cost effective means for an insurer or reinsurer to access or grow a particular class of business they find attractive given the MGA/U already possesses product expertise and distribution capabilities.
According to data from AM Best, the MGA/U sector is one of fastest growing segments of the U.S. P&C insurance market with 2022 direct premium written of $68 billion, an increase of 14% over the prior year, and loss ratios consistently lower than the P&C sector overall. In 2022, AM Best identified 654 MGAs in the U.S. market with likely several hundred additional MGAs not counted in that group as their premium production falls below the filing threshold. We believe the growth in the MGA/U and program space is likely to continue as the industry continues its move towards increased specialization.
Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance
Everspan’s strategy is to generate sustainable and profitable, long-term specialty property and casualty program business with a focus on diverse classes of commercial and personal liability risks across an expanding roster of MGA/U partners.
As a specialty property and casualty program group. Everspan may retain a percentage of the business it underwrites. Everspan's management team has significant years of experience in the program insurance and reinsurance sectors and has long-standing and broad relationships with MGA/Us, reinsurers, brokers, producers and third-party claims administrators ("TPAs"). Everspan sources business through program administrators and managing general agents, reinsurers, brokers, producers and others. Subject to Everspan's operational oversight, Everspan engages these third parties to market and administer policies and handle claims within defined authorities on Everspan's behalf.
Everspan is focused on generating strong underwriting results and stable fee income as part of its specialty program business model.
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 5
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
For the year ended December 31, 2023, Everspan generated $273 million of gross written premium, of which Everspan retained approximately 29%, including assumed written premiums. Everspan retained approximately 17% of its direct written premiums, with the balance primarily ceded to quota share reinsurers.
Everspan may retain up to 30% of risk on each direct program and will reinsure the remainder to reinsurers and other providers of risk capital. These reinsurers may be domestic and foreign reinsurers and institutional risk investors (capacity providers).
While underwriting direct business produced by MGA/Us is Everspan's primary means of distribution, Everspan also selectively assumes reinsurance to further its goal of writing a diversified book of specialty P&C business while efficiently managing its exposure limits. For example, the Company would evaluate, and may write certain lines, including those with catastrophe risk or Workers’ Compensation on an assumed basis. Everspan may participate as a reinsurer on up to 30% of a program, which is in line with its strategy to retain up to 30% of risk per program. Participation as a reinsurer will affect the retention ratio as Everspan's portion of assumed premiums is reflected fully in both Gross and Net Written Premiums.
The following table sets forth gross written premiums (direct and assumed) by line of business for the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022:
($ in millions)
Year Ended December 31, 2023 2022
Commercial auto liability $ 122 $ 117
Excess liability 41 5
General liability 27 6
Surety 26 4
Non-standard auto 20 —
Workers Compensation 20 —
Commercial auto physical damage 12 13
Other 6 1
Gross written premiums $ 273 $ 146
Everspan purchases reinsurance to manage its net retention on individual risks and overall exposure to losses, while providing it with the ability to offer policies with sufficient limits to meet producer and policyholder needs. Generally, reinsurance contracts are specific to a program and are renewed annually, at which time they are subject to renegotiation. The key contractual provisions include, but are not limited to, those relating to the scope of business reinsured, ceding commissions, required reports to reinsurers, dispute resolution, any required collateral, and Everspan's termination rights when, among other triggers, a reinsurer defaults (such as by failing to collateralize its obligations when required) or its financial strength falls below an agreed level. Everspan’s ceded reinsurance contracts do not legally discharge Everspan from its primary liability for the full amount of the policies, and Everspan will be required to pay the loss and bear collection risk if a reinsurer fails to meet its obligations under the reinsurance agreement.
Everspan mitigates this credit risk by selecting well capitalized, highly rated, authorized capacity providers, or requiring that the capacity provider post collateral, typically in the form of letters
of credit issued by or trust accounts in the custody of NAIC-qualified financial institutions, to secure the reinsured risks.
The following graph shows our reinsurance carriers' AM Best rating based on share of ceded premium for the year ended December 31, 2023:
(1) NR represents reinsurance carriers not rated by AM Best. Generally, under the terms of reinsurance contracts with such carriers the reinsurer is required to post collateral to Everspan.
See Note 7. Insurance Contracts to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information on reinsurance recoverables, including the evaluation for credit impairments.
Competitive Strengths:
Specialty Property and Casualty Insurance is a competitive industry. Everspan believes that it can successfully operate in this industry in part based upon the following competitive strengths.
• Experience — Everspan has an experienced leadership team across underwriting, pricing, claims, and business development with an average tenure of over 30 years in the insurance industry.
• Underwriting Focused Strategy — Everspan is driven by underwriting performance, which is achieved via comprehensive diligence and monitoring of MGA/U partners from our in-house pricing actuaries, claims executives, and program managers. This underwriting focus also aides in achieving and maintaining support from reinsurance partners.
• Risk Appetite — Everspan may retain up to 30% of the risk it underwrites. This meaningful participation serves to align interests with our reinsurers.
• Commitment to Program Distribution — Everspan does not have any direct distribution capability as it is committed to the program market distributed through MGA/Us. As a result, Everspan does not have channel conflicts which would compete with programs partners in underwriting business.
• Nimble Platform — A simplified organizational structure which allows Everspan to be efficient and quick in responding to the needs of program partners as well as finding customized solutions. We believe this provides a
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 6
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
competitive advantage to the more traditional competitors in the market.
• Aligned Ownership — Everspan has a stable ownership structure which is equally focused on long-term value creation based on strong underwriting performance. This alignment of interest and strategic vision allows Everspan to leverage resources across Ambac and access capital for future initiatives.
Competition:
Everspan faces competition from program business market participants such as Accelerant, Benchmark, Clear Blue, Core Specialty, Falls Lake, Fortegra, Obsidian, Spinnaker, State National, Transverse, and Trisura. Most of these entities have both admitted and E&S carriers. Competition may take the form of lower program fees, broader coverages, greater product flexibility, higher coverage limits, greater customer service or higher financial strength ratings by independent rating agencies. Few barriers exist to prevent existing insurers from entering target markets within the property and casualty industry. Market conditions and capital capacity influence the degree of competition at any point in time.
During periods of excess underwriting capacity, as defined by the availability of capital, competition can result in lower pricing and less favorable policy terms and conditions for insurers. During periods of reduced underwriting capacity, pricing and policy terms and conditions are generally more favorable for insurers. Historically, the performance of the property and casualty insurance industry has tended to fluctuate in cyclical periods of price competition and excess underwriting capacity, followed by periods of high premium rates and shortages of underwriting capacity. At any given time, Everspan's portfolio of insurance products could experience varying combinations of these characteristics. This cyclical market pattern can be more pronounced in the specialty insurance and reinsurance markets in which Everspan competes than in the standard insurance market. For the last several years the property and casualty industry has been in a period of high premium rates with a shortage of underwriting capacity. While not anticipated to end in the short-term, this cyclical period will eventually end, perhaps unexpectedly. The end of this favorable cycle could have negative consequences for Everspan's growth and profitability prospects.
Business Acquisition and Program Partner Selection:
With our focus on generating long-term underwriting profitability, we are selective in adding new program partners. We look for program partners that share our vision of underwriting performance and return expectations and consequently are selective about with whom we partner. As of December 31, 2023, we have 23 programs with 19 MGA/Us. In 2023 we reviewed over 180 submissions and agreed to contract 11 new programs with eight new MGA/Us and two MGA/Us with an existing relationship, while renewing or extending twelve programs with eleven incumbent MGA/Us. Included in 2023 new programs are two executed via assumed reinsurance.
As noted above, most of Everspan’s programs are sourced either from MGA/Us or through other third parties, such as reinsurance brokers, that are seeking to provide customized insurance
solutions that require a carrier with a high rating from AM Best. Everspan works with MGA/Us that leverage both data and technology to streamline or improve the underwriting process.
Everspan may also source programs as a reinsurer. Accessing programs as a reinsurer provides Everspan the ability to diversify its risk profile, efficiently manage its exposure limits and underwrite programs in a cost efficient manner, amongst other benefits.
For each new opportunity that Everspan chooses to evaluate, an initial evaluation of the MGA/U is conducted, including an assessment of its underwriting approach, philosophy, size, quality of management, past performance, future performance targets and, above all, compatibility with Everspan’s operating model, risk appetite, and existing book of business. Everspan conducts substantial due diligence on all program partners led by the Underwriting Risk Committee which is chaired by Everspan’s Chief Underwriting Officer. As part of the diligence process, Everspan works closely with potential MGA/Us to design program underwriting guidelines, ongoing reporting and auditing requirements. Everspan also typically requires the producing partner to retain underwriting risk or otherwise align incentives with program underwriting performance.
Additionally, as part of the diligence process for each program, Everspan will perform a review of the claims management function, typically performed by a TPA, which in some cases are managed by the MGA/U or producing partner. Diligence focuses on claims handling and litigation management, compliance, finance, governance, staff and vendor management, data and IT.
After due diligence is completed and acceptable reinsurers are identified, each program is presented to the Underwriting Risk Committee for final approval. The Underwriting Risk Committee will consider recommendations made by the credit subcommittee regarding the financial strength of the MGA/Us and/or reinsurers.
Ongoing Monitoring:
For active programs, Everspan authorizes MGA/Us to underwrite and bind coverages in accordance with approved underwriting guidelines and delegates authority to the TPA for claims adjustment and payment. Everspan closely monitors each MGA/U and TPA’s adherence to the agreed upon underwriting and claims guidelines. Everspan will conduct periodic reviews of loss experience, rate levels, reserves and the overall financial health of the MGA/U and TPA and hold monthly underwriting meetings with both the MGA/U and TPA. Underwriting and claims data is provided by the MGA/Us and TPAs monthly. Additionally, Everspan conducts underwriting, claims and accounting audits, generally on-site, at least once a year for MGA/U and TPA partners which administer a material amount of Everspan's business. Everspan determines whether it will continue to participate on a program no less than annually, generally at the anniversary date of the program. The renewal process entails an assessment, with Underwriting Risk Committee participation, of the program's operating performance, profitability, and available reinsurance capacity. Everspan maintains the right to terminate relationships with its MGA/Us and TPAs. Reasons to terminate a relationship include
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 7
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
an inability to produce targeted underwriting results, writing exposures outside of agreed upon risk tolerances, delinquency in meeting reporting requirements, a change of strategic direction, or failure to meet collateral or other commitments to Everspan.
Ratings:
Everspan carriers have an AM Best financial strength ratings ("FSR") of 'A-' (Excellent) and Financial Strength Category of Class VIII. Risk is shared among the Everspan carriers via a reinsurance agreement and an intercompany pooling agreement (the "Everspan Pool"). We view this rating and financial size category as a competitive advantage in the marketplace. Ratings are an important factor in assessing Everspan’s competitive position, operation capabilities and risk management in the insurance industry.
Insurance Distribution
Ambac’s Insurance Distribution business, Cirrata Group ("Cirrata"), has a strategy to build a diversified portfolio of MGA/Us and other insurance distributors covering various P&C products. Ambac plans to grow its existing Insurance Distribution business using several strategies, including (i) organic growth, (ii) additional acquisitions and/or partnerships, and (iii) hiring experienced underwriting teams to incubate start-up MGA/Us. Key criteria include a track record of profitability and a seasoned management team. Insurance underwritten through Ambac's MGA/Us may utilize Everspan as an insurance carrier, but are not be required to do so, depending on strategic and operational considerations.
The following table sets forth Cirrata's premiums placed by line of business:
($ in millions)
Year ended December 31, 2023 2022
Employee stop loss $ 76 $ 72
Limited & short-term medical 54 48
Commercial auto 62 11
Marine 19 1
Professional liability 12 —
Other 6 4
Premiums placed $ 231 $ 135
Cirrata's portfolio at December 31, 2023, includes the following entities:
Xchange — Ambac owns an 80% controlling interest in Xchange Benefits, LLC ("Xchange"). Xchange operates through specialty producers in accident and health ("A&H") sectors across the U.S. which are typically not targeted by large direct writers and to whom Xchange can provide customized offerings. Xchange conducts business through approximately ten insurance carriers and dozens of agents and other distributors.
Xchange's main products for which it is delegated underwriting authority by insurance carriers include:
• Employer Stop Loss ("ESL") — provides protection for self-insured employers by serving as a reimbursement mechanism for catastrophic claims, both specific and in aggregate exceeding pre-determined levels.
• Limited Benefit Medical ("LM") — designed as a supplement to traditional Affordable Care Act medical programs and sold primarily through affinity groups, providing a variety of medically related benefits such as inpatient hospital stays, diagnostic services or physician visits.
• Short-term Medical ("STM") — sold primarily through affinity groups, providing non Affordable Care Act comprehensive medical coverage for short durations (i.e. less than one year).
• Xchange Re ("MGA/U") / Distribution Re ("Captive") — in January 2023, Xchange launched two new growth initiatives; Xchange Re an A&H reinsurance MGA/U and Distribution Re a protected cell captive insurance company domiciled in Tennessee which will mainly insure high deductible medical stop loss plans. Xchange does not intend to accept or retain any risk from Distribution Re.
All Trans — Effective November 1, 2022, Ambac acquired an 85% controlling interest in All Trans Risk Solutions, LLC ("All Trans"). All Trans is a full service managing general underwriter with delegated underwriting authority in commercial automobile insurance for specific "for-hire" auto classes; principally private school bus operators. In 2024, AllTrans launched a new program primarily focussed on charter buses. All Trans' track record of performance has allowed the company to maintain a consistent panel of insurance carriers and client relationships, several of which go back over 25 years.
Capacity Marine — Effective November 1, 2022, Ambac acquired an 80% controlling interest in Capacity Marine Corporation ("Capacity Marine"). Capacity Marine is a wholesale and retail brokerage and reinsurance intermediary specializing in more sophisticated marine and international risk in expsoures such as ports, terminals, and stevedores.
Riverton — Effective August 1, 2023, Ambac acquired an 80% controlling interest in Riverton Insurance Agency, Corp. ("Riverton"). Riverton offers professional liability insurance programs to licensed architects, engineers, construction managers and real estate professionals. Riverton's retail agency places professional liability for real estate agents with various markets.
In addition to existing MGA/Us and acquisitions, de novo MGA/U formations will be a core element of the Insurance Distribution segment's growth strategy.
Cirrata's businesses are compensated for their services primarily by commissions paid by insurance carriers for underwriting, structuring and/or administering polices and, in some cases for managing claims under agency agreements. Commission revenues are usually based on a percentage of the premiums placed. The businesses are also eligible to receive profit sharing contingent commissions on certain programs based on the underwriting results of the policies they write, which may cause some variability in revenue and earnings recognition. Commission revenues experience seasonality during the year, primarily from Xchange whose ESL programs are mostly underwritten in January and July resulting in revenue and earnings concentrations in the first and third quarters each calendar year. Given the recent acquisitions and potential de
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 8
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
novo launches, this seasonality is expected to become more muted over time.
Expenses at Cirrata include commissions the businesses pay to their independent agents/producers, compensation for their management and staff and intangible asset amortization from acquisitions. Commission expenses are a variable cost as we pay a percentage of premiums written to the agents/producers.
Insurance Distribution generated gross commission revenue of $51 million and $31 million during the years ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, respectively and net commission revenue (gross commissions less commission expenses) of $22 million and $13 million, respectively.
Commission revenue and expense growth will be driven by the businesses' continued expansion and diversification of its products across regions, products, and carriers.
Competitive Strengths:
• Deep specialty domain knowledge — Our Insurance Distribution businesses are anchored by a deep specialty domain knowledge in their respective classes of business. This knowledge is key to generating the underwriting results necessary to maintain long-standing carrier relationships.
• Long standing carrier relationships — Our MGA/Us strive towards long and durable carrier relationships supported by a focus on underwriting profitability. P&C insurance is a cyclical industry with opportunistic players entering and exiting the business. We believe that growing multi-year carrier relationships are evidence of the value created by our MGA/U, a value which we believe should sustain through routine market cycles.
• Strong distribution relationships — Distribution relationships provide value in several ways. First, carrier partners are looking for both underwriting expertise and distribution access when working with MGA/Us. In addition the quality of distribution relationships helps in allowing our MGA/Us access to higher quality risks from the wholesale and retail agents which we believe over time will help produce better underwriting results..
Competition:
The MGA/U insurance sector is highly competitive, and firms actively compete with Cirrata's businesses for customers and insurance carrier capacity.
• The ESL market is increasing in size as large companies continue to transition from fully insured to self-funded. As the market size increases, capital is flowing into the market, making prices and margins competitive. Blue Cross, UnitedHealth, CIGNA and Aetna are the largest writers. Competition also comes from large direct writers such as Tokio Marine, HCC and Sun Life as well as smaller carriers such as Gerber Life writing through other MGA/U firms.
• For LM and STM, overall market conditions remain stable. The overall market is large as entrepreneurs, the unemployed and others seek options for individual insurance. Competition for Xchange's business comes from
both direct carriers and other intermediaries and, depending on the product, may include Blue Cross, UnitedHealth, CIGNA, Aetna, Tokio Marine, Houston Casualty Company, Sun Life, United Health, Axis, Chubb, and National General.
• In the commercial auto "for-hire" classes All Trans competes with a variety of carriers both national and regional. Overall, carriers have been cutting back on their participation and or capacity in commercial auto due to poor underwriting performance, which has benefited All Trans which is focused on narrower niche classes of risk within the larger commercial auto sector. This competitive environment has allowed All Trans to price properly and provide strong underwriting results. All Trans competes with Lancer insurance, National Interstate, Utica, RLI and various other MGA/U companies.
• In professional liability markets, overall market conditions remain stable. Riverton competes with RLI, CNA, Hartford and various other MGA/U companies.
ENTERPRISE RISK MANAGEMENT
The Company's policies and procedures relating to risk assessment and risk management are overseen by its Board of Directors. The Board of Directors takes an enterprise-wide approach to risk management oversight that is designed to support the Company's business plans at a level of risk considered by the Board to be reasonable. A fundamental part of risk assessment and risk management is not only understanding the risks the Company faces and what steps management is taking to manage those risks, but also understanding what level of risk is appropriate for the Company. The Board of Directors periodically reviews the Company's business plan, factoring risk management into account. It also approves the Company's risk appetite statements, which articulate the Company's tolerance for certain risks and describes the general types of risk that the Company accepts, within certain parameters, or attempts to avoid.
While the Board of Directors has the ultimate oversight responsibility for the risk management process, various committees of the Board also have responsibilities related to risk assessment and risk management, and management has responsibility for managing the risks to which the Company is exposed and reporting on such matters to the Board of Directors and applicable Board committees.
• The Audit Committee oversees the management of risks associated with the integrity of Ambac’s financial statements and its compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. In addition, the Audit Committee discusses policies with respect to risk assessment and risk management, including major financial risk exposures and the steps management has taken to monitor and control such exposures. The Audit Committee reviews with management, internal auditors and independent auditors Ambac's critical accounting policies, Ambac's system of internal controls over financial reporting and the quality and appropriateness of disclosure and content in the financial statements and other external financial communications.
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 9
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
• The Compensation Committee oversees the management of risk primarily associated with our ability to attract, motivate and retain quality talent (particularly executive talent) and with setting financial incentives that do not motivate undue risk-taking.
• The Governance and Nominating Committee oversees the management of risk primarily associated with Ambac’s ability to attract and retain quality directors, Ambac’s corporate governance programs and practices and our compliance therewith, including integration of ESG and sustainability policies, practices and goals into the Company's business strategy and decision making. Additionally, the Governance and Nominating Committee oversees the processes for evaluation of the performance of the Board of Directors and its committees each year and considers risk management effectiveness as part of its evaluation. This committee also reviews succession plans for Ambac's executive officers, including the Chief Executive Officer. The Governance and Nominating Committee also performs oversight of the business ethics and compliance program, and reviews compliance with Ambac’s Code of Business Conduct.
• The Strategy Committee oversees the management of strategic plans and initiatives.
The Board of Directors receives quarterly updates from Board committees and the Board provides guidance to individual committee activities, as appropriate.
In order to assist the Board of Directors in overseeing Ambac’s risk management, Ambac uses enterprise risk management, a company-wide process that involves the Board of Directors, management and other personnel in an integrated effort to identify, assess and manage a broad range of risks (e.g., credit, financial, legal, liquidity, market, model, operational, regulatory, reputational and strategic), that may affect the Company’s ability to execute on its corporate strategy and fulfill its business objectives. The Enterprise Risk Committee (“ERC”), which is a management committee, is comprised of executive and senior level management responsible for assisting in the management of the Company’s risks on an individual and aggregate basis. The ERC produces the relevant risk management information for executive and senior management and the Board of Directors.
Ambac management has established other management committees to assist in managing the risks throughout the enterprise. These committees will meet monthly or as needed on an ad hoc basis.
• The AAC Risk Committee's objective is to provide oversight of the key risk remediation issues impacting AAC. The purview of the committee is to review and approve risk remediation activities for the financial guarantee insured portfolio. Additionally, the Risk Committee will provide oversight and review new risk remediation structures or approaches in connection with risk remediation plans or anticipated transactions. Members of the Risk Committee include the CEO, Head of Risk Management, CFO and senior managers from throughout risk, corporate services, operations, legal and finance.
• The Disclosure Committee's objective is to assist the CEO and CFO in their responsibilities to design, establish, maintain and evaluate the effectiveness of disclosure controls and procedures. Members of the Disclosure Committee include the CEO, CFO, Chief Accounting Officer, General Counsel, Chief Operating Officer, Head of Risk Management and senior managers from finance and legal.
• The AAC Reserve Committee's objective is to provide oversight and review of the reserving process at AAC and Ambac UK. The committee reviews and discusses, on at least a quarterly basis, reserve-related developments and key metrics and assumptions, including, but not limited to, credit, economic, interest rates, legal and regulatory. The committee gives approval to proceed with the development of loss estimates and related projections utilized in developing the consolidated quarterly reserves of the Legacy Financial Guarantee Insurance business. Members of the Reserve Committee include the CEO, Head of Risk Management, CFO, General Counsel and senior managers throughout risk, legal and finance.
• The Everspan Underwriting Risk Committee' s objective is to provide oversight of the active underwriting operations of Everspan, develop underwriting parameters, and assist the Boards of the Everspan companies in overseeing the integrity and effectiveness of Everspan’s underwriting risk management framework. Members of the committee include the CEO, key members of Everspan management and other senior managers or advisors of Ambac. Additionally, a Reinsurance and Program Administrator Credit Risk sub-committee was established at the direction of the Underwriting Risk Committee to assist with the management of credit risk emanating from ceded reinsurance and program administrators.
The Company’s Enterprise Risk Management efforts build upon the foundation of an effective internal control environment. The design of any risk management or control system must reflect the fact that there are resource constraints, and the benefits must be considered relative to their costs. As a result, the possibility of material financial loss remains regardless of the Company’s Enterprise Risk Management efforts. An investor should carefully consider the risks and all of the other information set forth in this annual report, including the discussions included in Item 1A. Risk Factors, Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk, and Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data.
AVAILABLE INFORMATION
Our Internet address is www.ambac.com. We make available through the investor relations section of our web site, annual reports on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on Form 10-Q and current reports on Form 8-K, and any amendments to those reports, filed or furnished pursuant to Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, as well as proxy statements, as soon as reasonably practicable after we electronically file such material with, or furnish it to, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Our Investor Relations Department can be contacted at Ambac Financial Group, Inc., One World Trade Center, 41st Floor, New York, New York 10007, Attn: Investor Relations; telephone: 212-208-3222;
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 10
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
email: ir@ambac.com. The reference to our website address does not constitute inclusion or incorporation by reference of the information contained on our website in this Annual Report on Form 10-K or other filings with the SEC and the information contained on our website is not part of this document.
INSURANCE REGULATORY MATTERS AND OTHER RESTRICTIONS
Regulatory Matters
United States
AAC is domiciled in the state of Wisconsin and is therefore subject to the insurance laws and regulations of the State of Wisconsin and regulated by the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (“OCI”) as a domestic insurer. Everspan Indemnity and its wholly owned subsidiary, Everspan Insurance Company ("Everspan Insurance") are domiciled in the state of Arizona and are therefore subject to the insurance laws and regulations of the State of Arizona and regulated by the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions as domestic insurers. The subsidiaries of Everspan Insurance are domiciled in various States and are therefore subject to the insurance laws and regulations of their respective domiciliary States and regulated by the insurance departments of those States as domestic insurers. AAC, Everspan Insurance and its subsidiaries are also subject to the insurance laws and regulations of the other jurisdictions in which they are licensed and operate as foreign insurers in such jurisdictions. See Note 8. Insurance Regulatory Restrictions to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information on regulatory restrictions.
Pursuant to the terms of the Settlement Agreement and the Stipulation and Order, AAC must seek prior approval by OCI of certain corporate actions. The Settlement Agreement and Stipulation and Order include covenants which restrict the operations of AAC. The Settlement Agreement will remain in force until the surplus notes issued thereunder have been redeemed, repurchased or repaid in full. The Stipulation and Order will remain in force for so long as OCI determines it to be necessary. Certain of the restrictions in the Settlement Agreement may be waived with the approval of the OCI and/or the requisite percentage of holders of AAC's surplus notes. OCI's Runoff Capital Framework will help OCI determine whether to approve AAC making payments on or acquiring its surplus notes and Auction Market Preferred Shares ("AMPS") and distributing capital to AFG.
The Insurance Distribution businesses, like other MGA/Us, program administrators and brokers, may be subject to licensing requirements and regulation by insurance regulators in various states in which they conduct business.
United Kingdom
The Prudential Regulatory Authority ("PRA") and Financial Conduct Authority ("FCA") (and their predecessor regulator the Financial Services Authority (“FSA”)) exercise significant oversight over Ambac UK. In 2009, the FSA limited Ambac UK’s license to undertaking only run-off related activity. As such, Ambac UK is authorized to run-off its insurance portfolio in the United Kingdom. See Note 8. Insurance Regulatory
Restrictions to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information on regulatory restrictions.
Regulation of Change in Control
Under applicable insurance law, any acquisition of control of AFG, or any other direct or indirect acquisition of control of AAC or one or more members of the Everspan group of companies, requires the prior approval (or non-disapproval) of the domiciliary regulator of the acquired company (or, in the case of AFG, the domiciliary regulators of AAC and each member of Everspan). “Control” is generally defined as the direct or indirect power to direct or cause the direction of the management and policies of a person. Any purchaser of 10% or more of the outstanding voting stock of a corporation is presumed to have acquired control of that corporation and its subsidiaries unless the applicable insurance regulator, upon application, determines otherwise. For purposes of this test, AFG believes that a holder of common stock having the right to cast 10% or more of the votes which may be cast by the holders of all shares of common stock of AFG would be presumably deemed to have control of AAC, Everspan Indemnity, Everspan Insurance and its subsidiaries within the meaning of applicable insurance laws and regulations, although insurance regulators may in their discretion deem control not to exist where, for example, control is disclaimed by a passive investor. The United Kingdom has similar requirements applicable in respect of AFG, as the ultimate holding company of Ambac UK.
Dividend Restrictions, Including Contractual Restrictions
AAC:
Due to contractual and regulatory restrictions, AAC has been unable to pay ordinary dividends to AFG since 2008 and will be unable to pay ordinary dividends in 2024. AAC’s ability to pay dividends is restricted by the Settlement Agreement, the Stipulation and Order and the terms of its AMPS. OCI's decisions regarding dividends will be guided by OCI's Runoff Capital Framework. See Note 8. Insurance Regulatory Restrictions to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information on dividends. As a result of these restrictions, substantial uncertainty remains as to AAC's ability to pay dividends to AFG and the timing of any such dividends.
Pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, AAC may not make any “Restricted Payment” (which includes dividends from AAC to AFG) in excess of $5 million in the aggregate per annum, other than Restricted Payments from AAC to AFG in an amount up to $7.5 million per annum solely to pay operating expenses of AFG. Concurrent with making any such Restricted Payment to AFG for the payment of operating expenses, a pro rata amount of AAC's surplus notes would also need to be redeemed at par.
The Stipulation and Order requires OCI approval for the payment of any dividend or distribution on the common stock of AAC.
Under the terms of AAC’s AMPS, dividends may not be paid on the common stock of AAC unless all accrued and unpaid dividends on the AMPS for the then current dividend period
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 11
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
have been paid, provided that dividends on the common stock may be made at all times for the purpose of, and only in such amounts as are necessary for, enabling AFG (i) to service its indebtedness for borrowed money as such payments become due or (ii) to pay its operating expenses. If dividends are paid on the common stock as provided in the prior sentence, dividends on the AMPS become cumulative until the date that all accumulated and unpaid dividends have been paid on the AMPS.
Ambac UK:
The FSA amended Ambac UK’s license in 2010 such that the PRA must specifically approve any transfer of value and/or assets from Ambac UK to AAC or any other Ambac group company (including dividends), other than in respect of certain disclosed contracts between the two parties (such as in respect of a management services agreement between AAC and Ambac UK). While the UK insurance regulatory laws impose no statutory restrictions on an insurer’s ability to declare a dividend, the PRA’s and FCA’s rules governing capital extraction by insurance firms in run off require Ambac UK to consider its future capital requirements over a 3 to 5 year period in both base case and downside stress scenarios before declaring a dividend. Ambac UK annually prepares these forecasts and stress tests as part of its regulatory submissions to the PRA each April. If the stress tests and forecasts show adequate liquidity and regulatory capital buffers then, subject to PRA approval, it may be possible for Ambac UK to pay dividends to AAC in the near future.
Everspan Companies:
Everspan Indemnity, Everspan Insurance and its subsidiaries are also subject to regulatory restrictions on their ability to pay dividends. Everspan Indemnity and Everspan Insurance do not have sufficient earned surplus at this time to pay ordinary dividends under the insurance laws and regulations of Arizona. Furthermore, certain subsidiaries of Everspan Insurance are restricted from paying dividends to Everspan Insurance until 2025 or later, unless otherwise approved by the domestic regulator of the relevant subsidiary, pursuant to the regulatory orders approving the acquisition of those subsidiaries.
Cirrata Companies:
Ambac's MGA/U subsidiaries are not restricted from paying dividends or partner distributions (collectively "Distributions") to their owners or partners, including Cirrata, which is 100% owned by AFG. Ambac's established MGA/Us historically have paid Distributions equating to the majority of their individual EBITDA, subject to working capital and other capital needs, on a quarterly basis. Newly formed de-novo MGA/Us are not expected to make regular distributions to their partners until they become profitable and generate free cash flow on a steady and/or predictable basis.
INVESTMENTS AND INVESTMENT POLICY
As of December 31, 2023, the consolidated non-VIE investments of Ambac had an aggregate fair value of approximately $2,664 million. Investments are primarily managed by third party investment management firms overseen internally. All investments are made in accordance with the
general objectives, policies, and guidelines for investments approved by the Board of Directors of the applicable subsidiary. These policies and guidelines include liquidity, credit quality, diversification and duration objectives and are periodically reviewed and revised as appropriate.
As of December 31, 2023, the AAC and Everspan non-VIE investment portfolios had an aggregate fair value of approximately $1,810 million. The investment objective is to achieve the highest risk-adjusted after-tax return on a diversified investment portfolio consistent with the respective company's risk tolerance while employing active asset/liability management practices to satisfy all operating and strategic liquidity needs. In addition to internal investment policies and guidelines, the investment portfolio of each company is subject to limits on the types and quality of investments imposed by applicable insurance laws and regulations of the jurisdictions in which it is licensed. The Board of Directors of each respective subsidiary approves any changes to the respective investment policies. Within its guidelines, AAC opportunistically purchases and sells AAC and Ambac UK insured securities given their relative risk/reward characteristics. In certain instances, AAC may exceed its established credit rating or concentration limits with appropriate regulatory approval. Changes to AAC’s investment policies are subject to approval by OCI pursuant to covenants made by AAC in the Settlement Agreement and the Stipulation and Order, and may be affected by OCI's Runoff Capital Framework as discussed above in Insurance Regulatory Matters and Other Restrictions . See Note 1. Background and Business Description to the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for more information. Such requirements could adversely impact the performance of the investment portfolio.
As of December 31, 2023, the non-VIE Ambac UK investment portfolio had an aggregate fair value of approximately $663 million. Ambac UK’s investment policy is designed with the primary objectives of ensuring a reasonable risk-adjusted return over the remaining runoff of the insured portfolio and that Ambac UK is able to meet its financial obligations as they fall due, in particular with respect to policy holder claims. Ambac UK’s investment portfolio is primarily diversified fixed maturity securities and pooled investment funds. The portfolio is subject to internal investment guidelines and may be subject to limits on types and quality of investments imposed by its regulator. The Board of Directors of Ambac UK approves any changes or exceptions to Ambac UK’s investment policy.
As of December 31, 2023, the non-VIE AFG (parent company only, excluding investments in subsidiaries) investment portfolio had an aggregate fair value of approximately $188 million. The primary investment objective is to preserve capital for strategic uses while maximizing income. The investment portfolio is subject to internal investment guidelines. Such guidelines set forth minimum credit rating requirements and credit risk concentration limits.
As of December 31, 2023, the non-VIE Insurance Distribution investment portfolio had an aggregate fair value of approximately $4 million, primarily consisting of money market funds.
Ambac Financial Group, Inc 12
2023 Form 10-K
Table of Contents ,
At December 31, 2023 and 2022 Ambac owned $369 and $286, respectively, of distressed AAC and Ambac UK-insured bonds, primarily RMBS and student loan bonds. Refer to Note 4. Investments of the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further discussion of Ambac insured securities held in the investment portfolio. From time to time depending on and in light of prevailing market conditions, our liquidity, internal and regulatory guidelines, contractual restrictions and OCI’s Run-off Capital Framework, Ambac may seek to opportunistically (i) purchase or sell AAC and Ambac UK-insured securities; (ii) reduce, redeem, repurchase or otherwise retire its outstanding indebtedness, surplus notes and other AAC issued securities, including through open market repurchases, tender offers, repayments, redemptions or otherwise; and (iii) consider opportunities to exchange securities issued by AAC for other securities issued by AFG or AAC. Any such opportunistic liability or capital management transactions with respect to surplus notes or AMPS would in all cases be subject to and require OCI approval. OCI’s approval may be granted or denied in OCI’s sole discretion.
The following table provide certain information concerning the consolidated investments of Ambac:
2023 2022
Investment Category
($ in millions)
December 31, Carrying
Value
Weighted
Average
Yield (1)
Carrying
Value
Weighted
Average
Yield (1)
Municipal obligations $ 72 4.8 % $ 43 4.6 %
Corporate securities 745 3.3 % 598 2.6 %
Foreign obligations 100 2.6 % 76 1.5 %
U.S. government obligations 82 3.0 % 65 1.9 %
Residential mortgage-backed securities 250 7.2 % 238 8.3 %
Commercial mortgage-backed securities 19 5.6 % 15 5.5 %
Asset-backed securities 442 8.5 % 361 7.0 %
Short-term investments 452 5.3 % 572 4.0 %
Total fixed maturity-available-for-sale 2,162 5.2 % 1,966 4.4 %
Fixed maturity securities - trading (2)
27 — % 59 — %
Other investments (3)
475 — % 568 — %
Total $ 2,664 5.2 % $ 2,593 4.4 %
(1) Yields are stated on a pre-tax basis, based on average amortized cost for both long and short term fixed-maturity investments.
(2) Fixed maturity securities held for trading are Puerto Rico municipal obligations received in connection with the 2022 restructuring of AAC-insured Puerto Rico obligations.
(3) Other investments consist primarily of interests in pooled investment funds that are either classified as trading securities or are reported under the equity method. Refer to Note 4. Investments of the Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II, Item 8 in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further information about Other investments.
EMPLOYEES
As of December 31, 2023, Ambac had 168 employees in the United States and 10 employees in the United Kingdom. Our 2023 voluntary turnover rate was approximately 8.3%. Ambac considers its employee relations to be satisfactory.
Ambac’s focus has been on identifying and retaining key talent through individual development programs following skills assessments. Ambac’s succession planning has identified internal candidates that could fill executive management and senior management positions as the need arises. The Company has established a senior advisory team to work with, and advise, executive management on key initiatives, and has invested in both personal and professional growth programs to identify and prepare individuals for promotion within the Company. The Company continues to rely on compensation components (such as salary, long-term incentive plan awards, deferred cash awards and short-term incentive plan awards) to support employee retention and discourage excessive risk taking. The Company incorporates performance metrics as part of the annual short-term incentive bonus offering with increased bonus potential for exceptional results. We utilize third-party benchmark data to establish market-based compensation levels. We believe that our current compensation and incentive levels reflect high performance expectations as part of our merit pay philosophy. The targeted use of long-term equity incentive plan awards for key talent is an important element of Ambac’s long-term retention strategy.