Item 1. Business
Item 1. Business
Overview
Founded in 1959, F&G is a leading provider of insurance solutions serving retail annuity and life customers as well as institutional clients. Our mission is to help people turn their aspirations into reality and, as of December 31, 2023, F&G has approximately 677,000 policyholders who count on the safety and protection our fixed annuity and life insurance products provide.
Through our insurance subsidiaries, including Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company (“FGL Insurance”) and Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company of New York (“FGL NY Insurance”), we market a broad portfolio of annuities, including fixed indexed annuities (“FIAs”) and multi-year guarantee annuities (“MYGAs”), pension risk transfer (“PRT”) solutions, as well as indexed universal life (“IUL”) insurance and institutional funding agreements. In February 2024, we entered one of the fastest growing segments of the annuity space by marketing registered index-linked annuities (“RILAs”).
We were acquired on June 1, 2020, by Fidelity National Financial, Inc. (“FNF”). We have benefited from financial strength ratings upgrades since the acquisition; S&P and Fitch upgraded us to A- in June 2020, Moody’s upgraded to A3 in July 2023, and A.M. Best upgraded us to A in January 2024. These upgrades, valued by our distribution partners, positioned us to quickly expand our business in our existing channels and gain access to new markets. Gross sales increased from $4.5 billion for the full year 2020 to $13.2 billion in 2023 and did so profitably. With our success in expanding distribution under FNF’s ownership, we have grown assets under management (“AUM”) from $26.5 billion at the time of acquisition to $49.5 billion as of December 31, 2023. We now operate in and source significant premiums from three distinct retail channels and two institutional markets versus a single channel prior to the acquisition by FNF in June 2020. For a discussion of the five distinct channels, see “ We Play in Large and Growing Markets” and “ Our Retail Distribution Channels” within this section of the Annual Report on Form 10-K.
We believe the strength of our balance sheet provides confidence to our policyholders and business partners and positions us for continued growth. Our invested assets comprise what we believe to be a highly rated and well diversified portfolio. As of December 31, 2023, 95% of our fixed maturity securities were rated under criteria of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (the “NAIC”) as NAIC 1 or NAIC 2, the two highest credit rating designations of the NAIC. These assets are managed against what we believe to be prudently underwritten liabilities. We have in-force liabilities of $47.3 billion at December 31, 2023, with a liability duration of approximately 5 years , well matched to our assets. For the year ended December 31, 2023 , Net losses totaled $58 million, we produced adjusted net earnings (“ANE”) of $335 million, and we had an adjusted return on assets (“ROA”) of 72 basis points. Adjusted net earnings included $405 million of investment income from alternative investments and $51 million of significant expense items. Alternative investments investment income based on management’s long-term expected return of approximately 10% was $558 million.
We are focused on growing our inforce liabilities and AUM, driven by sales of attractively priced liabilities, including fixed indexed annuities, fixed rate annuities, registered indexed-linked annuities, indexed universal life, funding agreements, and pension risk transfer. We have plenty of momentum to continue to deliver sustainable asset growth from our retail and pension risk transfer growth strategies, and ongoing margin expansion from enhanced investment margin opportunities, operational scale benefits and fee-based earnings from accretive flow reinsurance. We are also well positioned to diversify our earnings given the strong growth of our middle market life insurance business and owned distribution strategies over time.
As of December 31, 2023 , we had $3.1 billion of total F&G equity and $5.1 billion of total F&G shareholders’ equity excluding accumulated other comprehensive earnings (loss) (“AOCI”). FGL Insurance’s estimated U.S. RBC ratio was approximately 451% a s of December 31, 2023, as compared to 442% and 451% as of December 31, 2022 and December 31, 2021, respectively. FGL Insurance expects to maintain its U.S. risk-based capital (“RBC”) ratio at
10
or above our target of 400%. Going forward, we intend to fund our continued growth through strong and growing statutory earnings, reinsurance programs, and unused debt capacity.
F&G Dividend Distribution (the “separation and distribution”)
On December 1, 2022, FNF distributed, on a pro rata basis, approximately 15% of the common stock of F&G. The purpose of the separation and distribution was to enhance and more fully recognize the overall market value of each company. FNF retained control of F&G through ownership of approximately 85% of F&G common stock.
For additional information about risks to F&G related to the separation and distribution, please see “Risk Factors - Risks Related to the Separation and Distribution and our Status as a subsidiary of FNF.”
Our Strategy
Through a diversification growth strategy, F&G has demonstrated profitable, compound annual growth rates in gross sales of 50% and AUM of 23% for the four-year period 2019 to 2023 and, more recently, annual increases in gross sales of 17% and AUM of 14% for the year ended December 31, 2023 as compared to the year ended December 31, 2022. We have expanded our business in our traditional channels, and entered new markets. With this strategy, we will continue to deliver stable ROA, excluding short-term mark-to-market effects, driven by asset growth and increasing margins from scale as well as expansion into higher-margin, less capital-intensive products. We are positioned to accomplish our goals through the following areas of strategic focus:
• Targeting large and growing markets . The opportunity for our core annuity products remains significant, as policyholders seek to add safety and certainty to their retirement plans. Our investments in life insurance products allows us to penetrate the underserved middle market, which addresses the needs of many of our cultural communities. And as corporations continue to de-risk their pension funds, our buyout solutions can guarantee pension-holders the lifetime benefits they need and want. Finally, we continue to attract strong institutional annuity buyers with funding agreements. F&G is a national leader in the markets we play in, and demographic trends provide tailwinds and significant room to continue growing.
• Superior ecosystem . Our business model gives us a sustainable competitive advantage. We have strong and long-standing relationships with a diverse network of distributors, a durable investment edge through our Blackstone partnership, a scalable administrative platform, and a track record of attracting and retaining top talent.
• Consistent track record of success. F&G’s deep and experienced management team has successfully diversified products and channels in recent years and demonstrated our ability to deliver consistent top line growth, increase assets under management and generate steady spreads and ROA, excluding short-term mark-to-market effects, across varying market cycles.
• Driving margin expansion and improved returns. We are pursuing strategies to continue to grow earnings, while generating significant positive net cash flow and diversifying into “capital light” flow reinsurance and accretive owned distribution to generate higher return on equity.
Our Competitive Advantages
Our business model is strong and positions us to capitalize on the growth prospects in our addressable markets.
• Trusted by distributors. We have long-standing relationships with a broad range of distributors representing nearly 112,000 independent agents and financial advisors, and built on our reputation for transparency and a consistently competitive product portfolio. We offer fixed annuities and life insurance products through a network of approximately 21 leading banks and broker dealers and approximately 280 Independent Marketing Organizations (“IMO”) that provide back-office support for thousands of independent insurance agents.
• Winning in high-growth markets. The U.S. retirement and middle markets are growing, and we are both well-established and well-positioned for continued growth. Our strategic alignment with our distribution
11
partners allows us to reach a diverse, growing and underserved middle market demographic in both our retail and institutional channels.
• Durable investment management edge. Our strategic partnership with Blackstone provides a sustained competitive advantage for our business. Our liability profile and risk appetite drives our investment strategy. F&G’s investment and risk offices set strategic asset allocation and risk limits. Blackstone is responsible for idea generation and security selection. Blackstone’s capabilities expand our investment universe to new asset classes and their origination capabilities provide incremental spread. Our high quality, diversified investment portfolio is well positioned to withstand macroeconomic headwinds and continues to perform well. We have enhanced the return while improving the credit quality of our portfolio, and credit related impairments remain low, averaging 5 basis points over the past 3 years, below our pricing assumption.
• Clean and profitable in-force book. As a life insurer, we generate spread earnings based on our assets under management and over the lifetime of the liabilities in place. Our disciplined new business underwriting process provides us with stable liabilities, primarily in products that reset annually, which has allowed us to achieve consistently attractive lifetime returns. Approximately 93% of our $33.0 billion fixed indexed and fixed rate annuities account value are surrender-charge protected and our asset and liability cash flows are well matched.
• Track record of attracting top talent. F&G’s management team and nearly 1,200 employees have a record of long-term success and have delivered impressive results in the last few years. Our commitment to our cultural values is the cornerstone of our success, whereby F&G is a company of individuals who believe in the power of partnerships, encourage innovation and creativity, and are transparent about decisions while delivering on their commitments. This is borne out by consistently being recognized as an employer of choice as well as an involuntary turnover rate that is well below that of other financial services companies. We believe our flexible, employee-centric work approach positions us as an employer of choice.
• Clear governance structure. We have a disciplined approach for considering new lines of business to enter, the appropriate product/channel mix for achieving our targeted new business profitability, and the management of our capital and in-force liabilities. Further, we target and pursue opportunities that leverage our strengths.
We Play in Large and Growing Markets
We are in the midst of an age wave, with 10,000 Baby Boomers retiring each day through 2029. Today’s retirees face unique challenges: guaranteed income traditionally provided by pensions is going away, requiring many retirees to rely solely on their personal assets; for many, Social Security income is not enough. Today’s retirees must plan for a retirement that could last 25 to 30 years, weathering the ups and downs of the markets along the way. Insurance solutions can simplify retirement planning through features that generate more accumulation than traditional fixed income vehicles and generate more (and guaranteed) retirement income than traditional strategies.
The U.S. retirement market opportunity is vast and includes the $777 billion U.S. consumer savings market and the $326 billion retail life and annuities market. While insured products are designed to effectively serve the needs of retirees, annuities and life insurance solutions continue to be underutilized. We believe middle market consumers, in particular, lack the guidance they need and want and can benefit greatly from insurance solutions.
Retail. Until recently, F&G distributed our flagship annuity and life insurance products solely through our longstanding IMO relationships. In mid-2020, we expanded into the bank and broker dealer channels to broaden our reach and capture share of the personal savings and CDs markets. Our entry into these channels was successful, resulting in $1 billion in new business within the first ten months. Annuity sales through the bank and broker dealer channels were $4.9 billion and $3.6 billion for the full year ended December 31, 2023 and 2022, respectively. The approximate 21 banks and broker dealers we work with account for 51% of all annuity sales. In these retail markets F&G ranks: (i) 6th and 10th in FIA sales in the IMO and bank channels and 8th in FIA industry sales; (ii) 9th and 4th in MYGA sales in the broker dealer and bank channels and 9th in MYGA industry sales; and (iii) 5th in IUL
12
sales in the IMO channel, 3rd in the number of IUL policies sold and 6th in IUL industry sales, in each case, for the third quarter of 2023, as sourced from Wink’s Sales and Market Report.
We successfully expanded into new retail channels and diversified our annuity distribution, yet not at the expense of our traditional IMO channel. We grew our IMO channel sales by 6% and 11% during the years ended December 31, 2023, and December 31, 2022, respectively.
We continue to invest in our life insurance business, focusing our approach to meet the needs of the underserved middle market which we reach largely through Network Marketing Groups (“NMGs”). The middle market segment was the largest in 2022, at 46% of households. NMGs are unique and growing, recruiting members of diverse communities for careers in insurance and penetrating cultural segments. NMGs have proven to be one of our most cost-efficient distribution channels, in large part because they tend to work with a smaller number of strategic product providers. This has allowed us to build deep and lasting relationships with both the NMGs and the agents. Since 2019, largely due to our NMG strategy, F&G’s IUL sales growth has far outpaced the industry, with a three-year combined annual growth rate of 49.5% compared to the industry’s 4.9%. This makes F&G the fastest growing IUL company of the top 20 IUL sellers in the market. Untapped opportunities remain in this channel, particularly among younger and more diverse demographics. In the United States, 41% of adults reported a need for life insurance or more coverage, which equates to approximately 101 million adults with a life insurance gap. Hispanics, the second largest ethnic group behind Caucasians, have the largest uninsured population among adults at 39% representing significant opportunity for us to serve this market.
Owned Distribution. With industry consolidation of independent agent distribution underway, we believe we are uniquely positioned to partner as a distribution consolidator. In October 2021, we purchased a 30% minority ownership stake in Freedom Equity Group (“FEG”). FEG is a nearly 4,000 agent strong NMG that focuses on cultural markets including Mexican-American, Hmong, Laotian, Filipino, Burmese, Congolese-American, Samoan, African-American, Thai and Vietnamese. We also purchased a 49% minority ownership stake in Syncis Holdings, LLC, an NMG, in January 2023. Syncis is an approximately 1,200 agent NMG that focuses on cultural markets including Korean, African-American, and Persian. We continued to consolidate in the distribution space in 2023 with the purchase of a 30% minority ownership stake in Quility Holdings, LLC (“Quility”), a leading insurtech company that offers a frictionless experience for insurance agents, insurance distribution companies and the clients they serve, and the purchase of a 40% minority ownership stake in DCMT Worldwide, LLC (“DCMT”), who distributes life insurance and annuity products through a network of over 1,000 agents. In January 2024, we purchased a 70% majority ownership stake in Roar Joint Venture, LLC (“Roar”), a wholeseller of annuities and life insurance products to financial institutions and the broker-dealer community.
Institutional . In 2021, F&G entered two institutional business lines to further diversify our sources of revenue. Our competitive asset management advantage through Blackstone allows us to have very competitive offerings in our spread lending products as well as in the PRT market, while still meeting our internal pricing targets.
• In addition to our funding agreement business with the Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta, (“FHLB”), we now offer the proven ability to originate Funding Agreement Backed Notes (“FABN”), a $176 billion market. Our FABN Program (the “FABN Program”) offers funding agreements to institutional clients by means of capital markets transactions through investment banks. Together, this business line has generated $2.3 billion in sales for F&G in 2021, its year of inception of FABN, $1.4 billion in sales for the year ended December 31, 2022, and $1.3 billion in sales for the year ended December 31, 2023.
• We also offer PRT solutions to a $40 billion (of $2 trillion total defined benefit plan assets) market. We launched our PRT business by building an experienced team with access to brokers and institutional consultants for distribution. We expect our opportunity to continue to grow as employers shift away from traditional defined benefit pension plans and seek to de-risk frozen pension plans. This line of business generated $1.1 billion in sales for F&G in 2021, its year of inception, $1.4 billion in sales for the year ended December 31, 2022, and $2.0 billion in sales for the year ended December 31, 2023.
13
We Have Meaningfully Diversified Our Business
With the addition of the retail bank and broker dealer channels and our success in entering the PRT and funding agreement institutional markets, F&G has diversified our product and distribution capabilities from one primary channel to now five, and from one primary product to now six with our recent entrance into the RILA markets. We completed this expansion over a four -year period and, combined with organic growth in our core IMO channel, increased gross sales by 238%, from $3.9 billion in 2019 to $13.2 billion in 2023.
We have reinforced our earnings engine in addition to driving top-line growth. We have acquired and retained customers through the years, growing AUM from $26.5 billion at the time of FNF’s acquisition to $49.5 billion as of December 31, 2023. Profitable growth in AUM is the most important driver of F&G’s earnings and our ability to return capital to shareholders.
Our Financial Goals
Our competitive advantages – product and channel diversification, as well as our strategic partnership with Blackstone – enable us to address a greater share of the markets in which we play. Further, the strength of our distribution partner relationships and pension risk transfer growth strategy has allowed the Company to achieve profitable double digit sales growth. The launch of our RILA product in early 2024 will further boost our sales growth as we enter a large and fast-growing market. We also expect to deliver ongoing margin expansion from enhanced investment margin opportunities, effectively managing our operating expenses while scaling our organization over time and driving fee-based earnings from accretive flow reinsurance. Lastly, we continue to diversify and enhance our earnings power as we execute on our own distribution strategy. Our ownership stakes generate a higher margin earnings stream at a lower cost of capital, which we expect to be accretive to our returns over time.
The Products We Offer
F&G’s expertise in annuities, life insurance, pension risk transfer solutions and funding agreements will allow us to continue to introduce innovative products and solutions designed to meet customers’ changing needs. We work hand-in-hand with our distributors and institutional advisors to devise the most suitable solutions for the ever-changing market. Our retail annuities serve as a retirement and savings tool on which our customers rely for principal protection and predictable income streams. In addition, our life insurance products provide our customers with a complementary product that allows them to build on their savings and provide a payment to their designated beneficiaries upon the policyholder’s death. Our most popular products are FIAs that tie contractual returns to specific market indices, such as the S&P 500 Index. Our customers value our FIAs, which provide a portion of the gains of an underlying market index, while also providing principal protection. We believe this principal protection fills the need for middle-income Americans who must save for retirement but who want to limit the risk of decline in their savings. As noted above, in 2021, we launched into two institutional markets to originate FABN and PRT transactions. These markets leverage our existing team's spread-based capabilities as well as our strategic partnership with Blackstone.
For the year ended December 31, 2023, FIAs generated approximately 36% of our gross sales. The remaining 64% of sales were primarily generated from fixed rate annuities (39%), funding agreements (9%), PRT sales (15%) and IUL (1%). We invest the proceeds primarily in fixed income securities. We also use options and futures that hedge the index credit of our FIA and IUL liabilities by replicating the market index returns to our policyholders. We invest predominantly in options on the S&P 500 Index. The majority of our products allow for active management to achieve targeted lifetime returns. In addition, our annuity contracts generally either cannot be surrendered or include surrender charges that discourage early redemptions.
Annuities. Through F&G’s insurance subsidiaries, we issue a broad portfolio of deferred annuities (FIA and fixed rate annuities), immediate annuities, and PRT solutions. A deferred annuity is a type of contract that accumulates value on a tax deferred basis and typically begins making specified periodic or lump sum payments a certain number of years after the contract has been issued. An immediate annuity is a type of contract that begins making specified payments within one annuity period (e.g., one month or one year) and typically pays principal and earnings in equal payments over some period of time.
14
Deferred Annuities – FIAs . Our FIAs allow contract owners the possibility of earning returns linked to the performance of a specified market index, predominantly the S&P 500 Index, while providing principal protection. The contract owners typically make a single deposit into our deferred annuities. The contracts include a provision for a minimum guaranteed surrender value calculated in accordance with applicable law. A market index tracks the performance of a specific group of stocks representing a particular segment of the market, or in some cases an entire market. For example, the S&P 500 Composite Stock Price Index is an index of 500 stocks intended to be representative of a broad segment of the market. All FIA products allow policyholders to allocate funds once a year among several different crediting strategies, including one or more index-based strategies and a traditional fixed rate strategy. Surrender charges apply for early withdrawal, typically for seven to fourteen years after purchase.
We purchase derivatives consisting predominantly of over-the-counter options and, to a lesser degree, futures contracts (specifically for FIA contracts) on the equity indices underlying the applicable policy such as the S&P 500. These derivatives are used to fund the index credits due to policyholders under the FIA and IUL contracts based upon policyholders’ contract elections. The down-side risk to F&G is limited to the cost of the options because if the value of the options decreases there is no index credit. The cost of the hedge is included in the pricing of the product and can be reset on an annual basis for each policy based on market conditions. The majority of all such call options are one-year options purchased to match the funding requirements underlying the FIA/IUL contracts. On the anniversary dates of the FIA/IUL contracts, the market index used to compute the annual index credit under the contracts is reset. At such time, we purchase new call options to fund the next index credit. We manage the cost of these purchases through the terms of our FIA/IUL contracts, which permit us to change caps or participation rates, subject to certain guaranteed minimums on each contract’s anniversary date. The change in the fair value of the options and futures contracts is generally designed to offset the equity market related change in the fair value of the FIA/IUL contract’s related reserve liability. The options and futures contracts are marked to fair value with the change in fair value included as a component of “Recognized gains and (losses), net” in our Consolidated Statements of Operations. The change in fair value of the options and futures contracts includes the gains and losses recognized at the expiration of the instrument’s term or upon early termination and the changes in fair value of open positions. Generally accepted accounting principles (“GAAP”) accounting of the reserve liability for products with embedded derivatives such as FIA creates additional volatility beyond the accounting for the options and the futures.
The contract holder account value of a FIA contract is equal to the sum of deposits paid, premium bonuses, if any, (described below), and index credits based on the change in the relevant market index (subject to a cap, spread and/or a participation rate) less any fees for riders and any withdrawals taken to-date. Caps (a maximum rate that may be credited) generally range from 1% to 5% when measured annually and 1% to 3% when measured monthly, spreads (a credited rate determined by deducting a specific rate from the index return) generally range from 0% to 3% when measured annually, and participation rates (a credited rate equal to a percentage of index return) generally range from 100% to 180% of the performance of the applicable market index. The cap, spread and participation rate can typically be reset annually and in some instances every two to five years. Certain riders provide a variety of benefits, such as the ability to increase their cap, lifetime income or additional liquidity for a set fee. As this fee is fixed, the contract holder may lose principal if the index credits received do not exceed the amount of such fee.
Approximately 39% of the FIA sales for the year ended December 31, 2023, involved “premium bonuses” or vesting bonuses. Premium bonuses increase the initial annuity deposit by a specified rate of 2%. The vesting bonuses, which range from 1% to 15%, increase the initial annuity deposit liability but are subject to adjustment for unvested amounts in the event of surrender by the policyholder prior to the end of the vesting period. We made compensating adjustments in the commission paid to the agent or the surrender charges on the policy to offset the premium bonus.
Approximately 48% of our FIA contracts were issued with a guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (“GMWB”) rider for the year ended December 31, 2023. With this rider, a contract owner can elect to receive guaranteed payments for life from the FIA contract without requiring the owner to annuitize the FIA contract value. The amount of the income benefit available is determined by the growth in the policy’s benefit base value as defined in the FIA contract rider. Typically, this accumulates for 10 years based on a guaranteed rate of 3% to 8%. Guaranteed withdrawal payments may be stopped and restarted at the election of the contract owner. Some of the FIA contract riders that we offer include an additional death benefit or an increase in benefit amounts under chronic
15
health conditions. Rider fees range from 0% to 1%. Unlike a variable annuity, policyholder values do not decline with market movements.
Deferred Annuities – Fixed Rate Annuities . Fixed rate annuities are typically single deposit contracts and include annual reset and multi-year rate guaranteed policies. Fixed rate annual reset annuities issued by us have an annual interest rate (the “crediting rate”) that is guaranteed for the first policy year. After the first policy year, we have the discretionary ability to change the crediting rate once annually to any rate at or above a guaranteed minimum rate. MYGAs are similar to fixed rate annual reset annuities except that the initial crediting rate is guaranteed for a specified number of years before it may be changed at our discretion. As of December 31, 2023, crediting rates on outstanding (i) single-year guaranteed annuities generally ranged from 1% to 6% and (ii) MYGA ranged from 1% to 5%. The average crediting rate on all outstanding fixed rate annuities at December 31, 2023 was 5%.
Deferred Annuities - Registered Index-Linked Annuities (“RILA”) – In early 2024, we entered into the RILA markets. RILAs are similar to FIAs in offering the policyholder the opportunity for tax-deferred growth based in part on the performance of a market index. Compared to an FIA, RILAs have the potential for higher returns but also have the potential for risk of loss to principal and related earnings. RILAs provide the ability for the policyholder to participate in the positive performance of certain market indices during a term, limited by a cap or adjusted for a participation rate. Negative performance of the market indices during a term can result in negative policyholder returns, with downside protection typically provided in the form of either a “buffer” or a “floor” to limit the policyholder’s exposure to market loss. A “buffer” is protection from negative exposure up to a certain percentage, typically 10 or 20 percent. A “floor” is protection from negative exposure less than a stated percentage (i.e., the policyholder risks exposure of loss up to the “floor,” but is protected against any loss in excess of this amount).
Withdrawal Options for Deferred Annuities. After the first year following the issuance of a deferred annuity policy holders of deferred annuities are typically permitted penalty-free withdrawals up to a contractually specified amount. The penalty-free withdrawal amount is typically 10% of the prior year account value for FIAs and is typically up to accumulated interest for fixed rate annuities, subject to certain restrictions. Withdrawals in excess of allowable penalty-free amounts are assessed a surrender charge if such withdrawals are made during the penalty period of the deferred annuity policy. The penalty period typically ranges from seven to fourteen years for FIAs and three to ten years for fixed rate annuities. This surrender charge initially ranges from 9% to 15% of the contract value for FIAs and is 9% of the contract value for fixed rate annuities and generally decreases by approximately one to two percentage points per year during the penalty period. The average surrender charge was 7% for our FIAs and 7% for our fixed rate annuities as of December 31, 2023. A market value adjustment (“MVA”) will also apply in most states to any withdrawal that incurs a surrender charge, subject to certain exceptions. The MVA is based on a formula that accounts for changes in interest rates since contract issuance. Generally, if interest rates have risen, the MVA will decrease surrender value, whereas if rates have fallen, it will increase surrender value. MVAs are included on all policies, if allowed (for FIAs since 2015 and for a longer time for fixed rate annuities). At December 31, 2023, approximately 78% of our business included an MVA feature.
The following table summarizes our deferred annuity account values and surrender charge protection as of December 31, 2023 (dollars in millions):
SURRENDER CHARGE EXPIRATION BY YEAR Fixed Rate and Fixed Indexed Annuities Account Value Percent of Total Weighted Average Surrender Charge
Out of surrender charge $ 2,346 7 % — %
2024 1,573 5 % 4 %
2025-2027 7,579 23 % 6 %
2028-2029 6,075 18 % 7 %
2030-2031 6,784 21 % 8 %
Thereafter 8,610 26 % 11 %
Total $ 32,967 100 % 7.31 %
16
Subsequent to the penalty period, the policyholder may elect to take the proceeds of the surrender either in a single payment or in a series of payments over the life of the policyholder or for a fixed number of years (or a combination of these payment options). In addition to the foregoing withdrawal rights, policyholders may also elect to have additional withdrawal benefits by purchasing a GMWB.
Single Premium Immediate Annuities . We have previously sold single premium immediate annuities (“SPIA”), which provide a series of periodic payments for a fixed period of time or for the life of the policyholder, according to the policyholder’s choice at the time of issue. The amounts, frequency and length of time of the payments are fixed at the outset of the annuity contract. SPIAs are often purchased by persons at or near retirement age who desire a steady stream of payments over a future period of years. Existing policyholders may elect to surrender their contract and use the proceeds to purchase a supplementary contract which functions as a SPIA.
Life Insurance. We currently offer IUL insurance policies and have previously sold universal life, term and whole life insurance products. Holders of universal life insurance policies may make periodic payments over the life of the contract and earn returns on their policies, which are credited to the policyholder’s cash value account. The insurer periodically deducts its expenses and the cost of life insurance protection from the cash value account. The balance of the cash value account is credited interest at a fixed rate or returns based on the performance of a market index, or both, at the option of the policyholder, using a method similar to that described above for FIAs.
Funding Agreements. As defined by the Iowa Insurance Division (“IID”), a funding agreement is an agreement for an insurer to accept and accumulate funds and to make one or more payments at future dates in amounts that are not based on mortality or morbidity contingencies of the person to whom the funding agreement is issued. In essence, funding agreement providers are agreeing to a defined stream of future payments in exchange for a single upfront premium. This type of business is sometimes referred to as spread lending, as funding agreement providers invest upfront premiums with the intent to earn an investment spread on the funds prior to making agreed upon maturity and interest payments. The structure of the payments can take several forms but are commonly a fixed or variable interest payment with a single maturity principal re-payment.
F&G currently utilizes two forms of funding agreement offerings. The first is through the issuance of collateralized funding agreements with the FHLB. This enables spread-based income without longevity or mortality exposure given the certainty in liability profile. Funding agreements through the FHLB are flexible in their format and the ability to issue during broad windows, as long as sufficient eligible collateral has been deposited with the bank. F&G and it’s predecessors have been entering into funding agreements with the FHLB since at least 2004.
In June 2021, we established a FABN Program, which is a medium term note program under which funding agreements are issued to a special-purpose trust that issues marketable notes. The notes are underwritten and marketed by major investment banks’ broker-dealer operations and are sold to institutional investors. These FABN offerings are more limited regarding timing of issuance, but do not require collateralization as with the FHLB. The maximum aggregate principal amount permitted to be outstanding at any one time under the FABN Program is currently $5.0 billion. As of December 31, 2023, we had approximately $2.6 billion outstanding under the FABN Program.
Pension Risk Transfer. In July 2021, we entered the PRT market. A PRT occurs when a defined-benefit pension provider seeks to remove some or all of its obligation to pay guaranteed retirement income or post-retirement benefits to plan participants. There are four major types of PRT strategies: longevity reinsurance, buy-in, buy-out, and paying in lump sums. We are currently active in plan buy-outs, where we have a direct, irrevocable commitment to each covered participant to make the specified annuity payments based upon the terms of the pension plan. Plan buy-out transactions fully and permanently transfer all investment, mortality, and administrative risk, associated with covered benefits, from the pension plan sponsor to the insurance provider.
Our PRT products are comparable to income annuities, as we generally receive a single, upfront premium in exchange for paying a guaranteed stream of future income payments which are typically fixed in nature but may vary in duration based on participant mortality experience. These products primarily create earnings through spread income. In each transaction FGL Insurance and/or FGL NY Insurance issues a group annuity contract to discharge pension plan liabilities from a pension plan sponsor, either through a separate account or through a general account
17
guarantee. Certificate holders covered under a group annuity contract have a guaranteed benefit from the insurance company.
We entered the PRT solutions business by building a team of experienced professionals, then working with brokers and institutional consultants for distribution. As of December 31, 2023, we had completed PRT transactions that represented pension obligations of $4.5 billion.
Reinsurance philosophy/arrangements. Our insurance subsidiaries cede insurance to other insurance companies. We use reinsurance to diversify risks and earnings, to manage loss exposures, to enhance our capital position, and to manage new business volume. The effects of certain reinsurance agreements are not accounted for as reinsurance as they do not reinsure insurance contracts, or they do not transfer the risks of the reinsured policies.
In instances where we are the ceding company, we pay a premium to a reinsurer in exchange for the reinsurer assuming a portion of our liabilities under the policies we issued and collect expense allowances in return for our administration of the ceded policies. Use of reinsurance does not discharge our liability as the ceding company because we remain directly liable to our policyholders and are required to pay the full amount of our policy obligations in the event that our reinsurers fail to satisfy their obligations. We collect reimbursement from our reinsurers when we pay claims on policies that are reinsured.
We monitor the credit risk related to the ability of our reinsurers to honor their obligations under various agreements. To minimize the risk of credit loss on such contracts, we generally diversify our exposures among many reinsurers and limit the amount of exposure to each based on financial strength ratings, which are reviewed annually. We are able to further manage risk with various forms of collateral or collateral arrangements, including secured trusts, funds withheld arrangements and irrevocable letters of credit.
Please refer to Note E - Reinsurance to our Consolidated Financial Statements included in Part II - Item 8 of this Annual Report on Form 10-K for further discussion on reinsurance, reinsurance recoverables for our largest reinsurers and credit risk and counterparty risk.
Please refer to “ Risk Factors ” for additional details regarding credit risk related to reinsurance agreements. A description of significant ceded reinsurance transactions appears below.
Wilton Reinsurance Transaction . Almost all of the life insurance policies in force issued before March 1, 2010, except for the return of premium benefits on term life insurance products, are subject to a reinsurance arrangement with Wilton Reassurance Company (“Wilton Re”). Pursuant to the agreed upon terms, Wilton Re purchased through a 100% quota share reinsurance agreement certain FGL Insurance life insurance policies that are subject to redundant reserves, reported on a statutory basis, under Regulation XXX and Guideline AXXX, as well as another block of FGL Insurance’s in-force traditional, universal life and IUL insurance policies. The effects of this agreement are accounted for as reinsurance as the ceded policies qualify as insurance products and because the agreement satisfies the risk transfer requirements for GAAP.
Hannover Reinsurance Transaction. Originally effective January 1, 2017, FGL Insurance has a reinsurance agreement with Hannover Life Reassurance Company of America (“Hannover Re”), an unaffiliated reinsurer, to reinsure an in-force block of FGL Insurance’s FIA and fixed rate deferred annuity contracts with GMWB and Guaranteed Minimum Death Benefit (“GMDB”) guarantees. In accordance with the terms of this agreement, FGL Insurance cedes 70% net retention of secondary guarantee payments in excess of account value for GMWB and death benefits in excess of account value for GMDB guarantees. The effects of this agreement are not accounted for as reinsurance as it does not satisfy the risk transfer requirements for GAAP; therefore, deposit accounting is applied and FGL insurance applies the right of offset in the reinsurance agreement.
Kubera Reinsurance Transaction. FGL Insurance has a reinsurance agreement with Kubera Insurance (SAC) Ltd. (“Kubera”), an unaffiliated reinsurer, to cede a quota share of certain FIA statutory reserves on a coinsurance funds withheld basis, net of applicable existing reinsurance. The effects of this agreement are not accounted for as reinsurance as it does not satisfy the risk transfer requirements for GAAP; therefore, deposit accounting is applied and FGL Insurance applies the right of offset in the reinsurance agreement.
18
To enhance Kubera's ability to pay its obligations under the amended reinsurance agreement, F&G entered into a Variable Note Purchase Agreement (the “NPA”), whereby F&G agreed to fund a note to Kubera to be used to ultimately settle with F&G, with principal increases up to a maximum amount of $300 million, to the extent a potential funding shortfall (treaty assets are less than the total funding requirement) is projected relative to the business ceded to Kubera from F&G as part of the amended reinsurance agreement. The potential funding shortfall will be determined quarterly and, among other items, is impacted by the market value of the assets in the funds withheld account related to the reinsurance agreement and Kubera's capital as calculated on a Bermuda regulatory basis. The NPA matures on November 30, 2071. Based on the current level of the treaty assets and projections that these policies will be profitable over the lifetime of the agreement, we do not expect significant fundings to occur under the NPA. As of December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022, the amount funded under the NPA was insignificant.
Kubera & Somerset Reinsurance Transactions. FGL Insurance entered into a reinsurance agreement with Kubera, effective December 31, 2018, to cede certain fixed rate annuity (including MYGA) GAAP and statutory reserves on a coinsurance funds withheld basis, net of applicable existing reinsurance. Effective October 31, 2021, this agreement was novated from Kubera to Somerset Reinsurance Ltd. (“Somerset”), a certified third-party reinsurer. Effective December 1, 2023, FGL Insurance executed an additional coinsurance funds withheld agreement with Somerset to cede certain flow MYGA business written effective on or after December 1, 2023. As the policies ceded to Somerset are investment contracts, there is no significant insurance risk present and the reinsurance agreements are accounted for as separate investment contracts.
Everlake Reinsurance Transaction. Effective September 1, 2023, FGL Insurance executed a coinsurance agreement with Everlake Life Insurance Company (“Everlake”), an unaffiliated reinsurer to cede, on a quota share basis, certain flow MYGA business written effective on or after September 1, 2023. As the policies ceded to Everlake are investment contracts, there is no significant insurance risk present and the effects of this agreement are accounted for as a separate investment contract.
Aspida Reinsurance Transaction. FGL Insurance has a reinsurance agreement with ASPIDA Life Re Ltd. (“Aspida Re”), an unaffiliated reinsurer, to cede certain flow MYGA business, on a funds withheld coinsurance basis, net of applicable existing reinsurance, written effective on or after January 15, 2021. As the policies ceded to Aspida Re are investment contracts, there is no significant insurance risk present and therefore the reinsurance agreement is accounted for as a separate investment contract.
New Re Reinsurance Transaction. Effective December 31, 2022, FGL Insurance entered into an indemnity reinsurance agreement with New Reinsurance Company Ltd., an unaffiliated reinsurer and wholly owned subsidiary of Münchener Rückversicherungs-Gesellschaft Aktiengesellschaft in München (d/b/a Munich Re), to cede certain FIA policies. Effective July 1, 2023, this agreement was amended to reinsure additional FIA products. The coinsurance quota share is only applicable to the base contract benefits under the FIA policies. The yearly renewable term is applicable to the waiver of surrender charges and return of premium. The effects of this agreement are not accounted for as reinsurance as it does not satisfy the risk transfer requirements for GAAP; therefore, deposit accounting is applied and FGL Insurance applies the right of offset in the reinsurance agreement.
The CARVM Facility. Life insurance companies operating in the United States must calculate required reserves for life and annuity policies based on statutory principles. The insurance divisions have adopted the methodology contained in the NAIC Valuation Manual as the prescribed methodology for the insurance industry. The industry has reduced or eliminated redundancies thereby increasing capital using a variety of techniques including reserve facilities.
F&G has a reinsurance treaty with Raven Reinsurance Company (“Raven Re”), its wholly owned captive reinsurance company, to cede the Commissioners Annuity Reserve Valuation Method (“CARVM”) liability for annuity benefits where surrender charges are waived related to certain FIA, DA and MYGA policies. In connection with the CARVM reinsurance agreement, FGL Insurance and Raven Re entered into an agreement with Nomura Bank International plc (“NBI”) to establish a reserve financing facility in the form of a letter of credit issued by NBI. The financing facility has $200 million available to draw on as of December 31, 2023. The amended facility may terminate earlier than the current termination date of October 1, 2027, in accordance with the terms of the
19
reimbursement agreement. Under the terms of the reimbursement agreement, in the event the letter of credit is drawn upon, Raven Re is required to repay the amounts utilized, and FGAL is obligated to repay the amounts utilized if Raven Re fails to make the required reimbursement. Under the terms of the agreement, FGAL is also required to make a capital contribution to Raven Re in certain circumstances, including in the event that Raven Re’s statutory capital and surplus falls below defined levels. As of December 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022, no capital contributions were required to be made due to these conditions. As this letter of credit is provided by an unaffiliated financial institution, Raven Re is permitted to carry the letter of credit as an admitted asset on the Raven Re statutory balance sheet.
GMWB/GWP Reinsurance Transaction . Effective December 31, 2023, FGL Insurance recaptured its reinsurance arrangement with Canada Life Assurance Company (“Canada Life”) United States Branch covering FIA policies with GMWB and guaranteed withdrawal payment (“GWP”) features and entered into a reinsurance treaty with Corbeau Re, Inc. (“Corbeau Re”), its wholly owned captive reinsurance company, to cede certain FIA policies with GMWB and GWP. In accordance with the terms of this agreement, FGL Insurance cedes a 100% quota share of GMWB and GWP paid in excess of account value. In connection with the reinsurance agreement between FGL Insurance and Corbeau Re, Corbeau Re entered into an excess of loss reinsurance agreement (“XOL”) with Canada Life Barbados Branch to finance the portion of statutory reserves considered to be non-economic. The XOL matures on December 31, 2043, and provides for coverage on losses up to $1,500 million as of December 31, 2023. With Corbeau Re, non-economic reserves were financed through the maturity date of the XOL and statutory reserves are recorded for all risks expected to be incurred after the maturity date of the XOL. The XOL is not accounted for as reinsurance as it does not satisfy the risk transfer requirements for GAAP; therefore, deposit accounting is applied. Under the terms of the agreement, FGAL is required to make a capital contribution to Corbeau Re in certain circumstances, including in the event that Corbeau Re’s statutory capital and surplus falls below defined levels. As of December 31, 2023, no capital contributions were required to be made due to these conditions. Corbeau Re is permitted to account for the excess of loss reinsurance agreement from Canada Life as an admitted asset on the Corbeau Re statutory balance sheet.
PRT Reinsurance Transaction . Effective October 1, 2023, FGL Insurance recaptured a reinsurance agreement with its affiliate F&G Life Re Ltd. (“F&G Life Re”), a Bermuda reinsurer, covering a quota share of certain pension risk transfer group annuity contracts and entered into an agreement with its affiliate F&G Cayman Re Ltd. (“F&G Cayman Re”), a Cayman Islands reinsurer, to reinsure a quota share of certain pension risk transfer group annuity contracts (previously ceded to F&G Life Re) in addition to flow pension risk transfer group annuity contracts. Some of the contracts reinsured are held by FGL Insurance’s general account and others are held by a FGL Insurance separate account (which does not meet the GAAP definition of a separate account). Reinsurance of the general account contracts are maintained on a coinsurance funds withheld basis for the general account statutory reserves. Reinsurance of the separate account contracts are maintained on a modified coinsurance basis for the separate account statutory reserves and coinsurance basis for the general account statutory reserves supporting the separate account. In connection with the agreement, F&G Cayman Re entered into a financing agreement with Deutsche Bank AG (“DB”), operating out of its New York branch, whereby DB issued a letter of credit used to support the coinsured general account statutory reserves (generally considered to be the non-economic reserves).
Our Retail Distribution Channels
We distribute our annuity and life insurance products through three main retail channels of distribution: independent agents, banks, and broker dealers.
In our independent agent channel, the sale of our products typically occurs as part of a four party, three stage sales process between FGL Insurance, an IMO, the agent and the customer. FGL Insurance designs, manufactures, issues, and services the product. The IMOs will typically sign contracts with multiple insurance carriers to provide their agents with a broad and competitive product portfolio. The IMO provides training and discusses product options with agents in preparation for meetings with clients. The IMO staff also provide assistance to the agent during the selling and application process. The agent may get customer leads from the IMOs. The agent conducts a fact finding and presents suitable product choices to the customers. We monitor the business issued by each distribution partner for pricing metrics, mortality, persistency, as well as market conduct and suitability.
20
We offer our products through a network of approximately 280 IMOs, representing nearly 102,000 agents. We believe that our relationships with these IMOs are strong. The average tenure of the Power Partners is approximately 20 years. We identify Power Partners as those who have demonstrated the ability to generate significant production for our business. We currently have 41 Power Partners, comprised of 19 annuity IMOs and 22 life insurance IMOs.
We took a similar approach in launching products as a new entrant into the bank and broker dealer channels by partnering with one of the largest broker dealers in the industry. In 2020, F&G launched a set of fixed rate annuity and FIA products to banks and broker dealers and gained selling agreements with some of the largest banks and broker dealers in the United States. We offer our products through a network of approximately 21 banks and broker dealers, representing approximately 10,000 financial advisers. The financial advisers at our bank and broker dealer partners are able to offer their clients guaranteed rates of return, protected growth, and income for life through our Secure series of annuity products. We employ a hybrid distribution model in this channel, whereby some financial institutions partner directly with F&G and our sales team, and others work with an intermediary. As such, we partner with a select number of financial institution intermediaries who have expertise in the channel and maintain the appropriate field wholesaling forces to be successful in this channel. In 2023, the top 5 firms represented 78% of channel sales. Bank and broker dealers represented 51% of annuity sales for the year ended December 31, 2023.
The top five states for the distribution of F&G’s retail products in the year ended December 31, 2023 were Florida, California, Pennsylvania, Ohio and Texas, which together accounted for 38.5% of F&G’s retail sales.
Our Investment Management Governance and Approach
We embrace a long-term conservative investment philosophy, investing nearly all the insurance premiums we receive in a wide range of high-quality debt securities. Our investment strategy is designed to (i) preserve capital, (ii) provide consistent yield and investment income, and (iii) achieve attractive absolute returns. We base all of our decisions on fundamental, bottom-up research, coupled with a top-down view that respects the cyclicality of certain asset classes. The types of assets in which we may invest are influenced by various state laws, which prescribe qualified investment assets applicable to insurance companies.
FGL Insurance and certain other subsidiaries of F&G (other than FGL NY Insurance) are party to investment management agreements (“IMAs”) with Blackstone ISG-I Advisors LLC (“BIS”) pursuant to which BIS is appointed as investment manager of substantially all assets in the general and separate accounts of those entities (the “F&G Accounts”). MVB Management, LLC, (“MVB Management”), an entity that is 50% owned by BilCar, LLC (an affiliate of William Foley, the Executive Chairman and a director of the Company) (“BilCar”), receives a participation fee from BIS in connection with assets of F&G and its subsidiaries that are managed by BIS. BIS also receives services from MVB Management. Pursuant to the investment management agreements with BIS, BIS pays MVB Management a fee of approximately 7.5% of certain fees paid to BIS and its affiliates for AUM relating to new business generated after March 31, 2023 (“New AUM”) (15% prior to that date). In March 2023 BilCar waived its right to receive any portion of payments made by BIS to MVB in respect of such New AUM. Additionally, in March 2023 the Company entered into an agreement with BilCar to pay BilCar the fees that it would have received through MVB Management from BIS over the 10-year period ending March 31, 2033. BIS, in accordance with our IMAs, has delegated certain investment services to its affiliates, including Blackstone’s Credit, Real Estate Debt and Asset-Based Finance businesses, in each case, pursuant to separate sub-management agreements executed between BIS and each such affiliate. There are no specified minimum amounts of assets that we have agreed that BIS will manage; however, BIS has the right to manage (and receive fees based on) all assets in the F&G Accounts with limited exceptions. For certain asset classes, we continue to utilize specialized third-party investment managers. As of December 31, 2023, approximately 85% of our $52 billion investment portfolio was managed by BIS, with 14% managed by other third parties, and the remaining 1% internally managed. BIS, in accordance with our IMAs, has delegated certain investment services to its affiliates, including Blackstone’s Credit, Real Estate Debt and Asset-Based Finance businesses, in each case, pursuant to separate sub-management agreements executed between BIS and each such affiliate.
21
On March 10, 2023, the IMAs were amended such that, for assets under management as of March 31, 2023, BIS’s per annum management fees are as follows:
• for aggregate assets under management in the F&G Accounts up to $25 billion, 0.26% of such aggregate assets under management;
• for aggregate assets under management in the F&G Accounts above $25 billion and up to $34 billion, 0.24% of such aggregate assets under management; and
• for aggregate assets under management in the F&G Accounts above $34 billion, .12% of such aggregate assets under management.
In addition, the Sub-Manager Fee Agreement has been amended to provide for certain updates thereto, including, among other things, to reflect certain additional asset classes, certain revisions to the applicable sub-manager fee rates in respect of certain existing asset classes and certain revisions to the applicable sub-manager fee rates in respect of assets under management relating to new business of the Company and its subsidiaries generated after March 31, 2023. For the avoidance of doubt, there will be no management fee payable under the IMAs with respect to New AUM.
Aggregate fees paid to BIS were $194 million, $155 million and $132 million for the years ended December 31, 2023, 2022 and 2021, respectively.
F&G has a robust governance process and framework to manage the investment portfolio. While BIS is primarily responsible for security selection, F&G makes all investment strategy decisions and sets risk parameters. All major decisions need to be reviewed and approved by the F&G Investment Committee, and new investment asset classes go through an internal risk assessment process at F&G to ensure the investments are suitable for an insurance company balance sheet. We define risk tolerance across a wide range of factors, including credit risk, liquidity risk, concentration (issuer and sector) risk, and caps on specific asset classes, which in turn establish conservative risk thresholds. Also, F&G has flexibility to use other asset management partners through our flow reinsurance platform over time.
F&G, along with BIS, continually monitors portfolio allocations and holdings to optimize the portfolio profile. F&G has undertaken several programs to take advantage of the credit cycle and market conditions or to undertake prudent risk management in anticipation of an unfavorable economic environment. We have also added several new asset classes to the investment portfolio to further enhance diversification.
Each of our subsidiaries that is party to an investment management agreement with BIS may terminate such agreement upon 30 days’ notice. BIS may also terminate any investment management agreement upon 30 days’ notice. However, F&G and FNF are party to an omnibus termination side letter under which they are required to cause our insurance subsidiaries to engage BIS as an investment manager and to generally not engage any other person as an investment manager. See also “ Risk Factors—Risks Relating to Our Business—We rely on our investment management or advisory agreements with BIS and other investment managers and sub-managers for the management of portions of certain of our life insurance companies’ investment portfolios.”
The initial term of the side letter expires in 2029 and will automatically renew for successive two-year terms unless F&G terminates the side letter. Prior to June 1, 2029, we and FNF may only terminate the side letter for cause. Cause is generally limited to circumstances where BIS is legally unable to manage our assets, if BIS fails to offer us “most favored nations” rights with respect to certain products it may issue to third parties, or where BIS has acted with gross negligence, willful misconduct or reckless disregard of its obligations under the investment management agreements. In addition, at the expiration of the initial term of the side letter in 2029, or at the end of any renewal term, we may with prior notice terminate the side letter for unsatisfactory long-term performance by BIS based on underperformance. If we provide any such notice, the termination would not become effective for one year from the date of termination given in the notice, during which time BIS may seek to cure the events giving arise to the termination notice.
Because our subsidiaries can terminate an investment management agreement at any time upon 30 days' notice, it is possible that such a termination by one of our subsidiaries could cause us to be in breach of our obligations
22
under the side letter. BIS’s contractual remedies under the side letter include specific performance and the right to seek damages including, in the event of a non-permitted termination of an investment management agreement by one of our subsidiaries, as compensation for the costs incurred in performing services under, and the failure to receive the benefits reasonably anticipated by, an IMA, the full amount of damages available at law in the same manner and to the same extent as if such IMA had been terminated by us our at our direction in violation of the terms of the side letter.
Our investment portfolio consists of fixed-rate high-quality fixed maturities, including publicly and privately issued corporate bonds, municipal and other government bonds, asset-backed securities (“ABS”), residential mortgage-backed securities (“RMBS”), commercial mortgage-backed securities (“CMBS”), commercial mortgage loans (“CMLs”), residential mortgage loans (“RMLs”), limited partnership investments, and other investments. We also maintain holdings in floating rate, and less rate-sensitive investments, including collateralized loan obligations (“CLO”), non-agency RMBS, and various types of ABS. It is our expectation that our investment portfolio will broaden in scope and diversity to include other asset classes held by life and annuity insurance writers. We also have a small amount of equity holdings required as part of our funding arrangements with the FHLB.
Over the year, we have hedged a portion of the existing floating rate asset exposure in the portfolio. In addition to hedging the existing floating-rate assets, subject to the broader macro and interest rate environment, we will also look to hedge a significant share of new purchases of floating-rate assets.
The portfolio also has exposure to U.S. dollar denominated emerging market bonds, highly rated preferred stocks and hybrids. We currently maintain a well-matched asset/liability profile (asset duration, including cash and cash equivalents, of 5.2 years vs. liability duration of 4.7 years).
Please refer to Note C - Investments in the Consolidated Financial Statements and the “ Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations — Investment Portfolio” in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for additional information about our investment portfolio.
Mature Risk Management Framework and Governance
Risk management is a critical part of our business to manage our financial strength and meet or exceed regulatory requirements. We seek to assess risk to our business through a comprehensive, formal process involving:
a. identifying short-term and long-term strategic and operational objectives;
b. development of risk appetite statements that establish what the Company is willing to accept in terms of risks to achieving its goals and objectives;
c. identifying the levers that control the risk appetite of the Company;
d. establishing the overall limits of risk acceptable for a given risk driver;
e. establishing operational risk limits that are aligned with the tolerances;
f. assigning risk limit quantification and mitigation responsibilities to individual team members within functional groups;
g. analyzing the potential qualitative and quantitative impact of individual risks, including but not limited to stress and scenario testing covering over eight economic and insurance related risks;
h. mitigating risks by appropriate actions; and
i. identifying, documenting and communicating key business risks in a timely fashion.
Our most significant risks are governed through holding company governance committees and overall by the Enterprise Risk Management Committee (“ERMC”). Our most significant risks such as credit risk, liquidity risk, and policyholder behavior associated with interest rate risk have established risk limits associated with our risk appetite statements. These include investment limits by asset class, ratings and issuer. Liquidity risk is managed
23
through frequent forecasting of sources and uses of cash and managed to our Liquidity Policy. Asset liability management procedures and limits protect the Company, within limits, against significant changes in interest rates. In addition, the risks are stressed as part of our scenario testing process to identify areas requiring mitigation plans based on the macroeconomic environment. Risk limits, risk appetite and scenario testing results of the stresses are discussed with stakeholders such as the F&G ERMC, the Board of Directors (“Board”) and Audit Committee (“AC”) of F&G, regulators and rating agencies.
The responsibility for monitoring, evaluating and responding to risk embedded across the organization: first assigned to our management and employees, second to those occupying specialist functions, such as legal compliance and risk teams, and third to those occupying supervisory functions, such as internal audit and the board of directors.
Operations/Outsourcing
We believe we have designed an efficient corporate platform which enables us to be highly scalable with volume over time and allows us to onboard incremental business with low incremental fixed operating cost. As a result, we believe we should be able to convert a significant portion of incremental net investment income from additional invested assets and liabilities into operating income.
We outsource the following functions to third-party service providers:
• new business administration (data entry and policy issue only);
• service of existing policies;
• underwriting administration of life insurance applications;
• call centers;
• information technology development and maintenance;
• certain investment accounting and custody; and
• co-located data centers and hosting of financial systems.
We closely manage our outsourcing partners and integrate their services into our operations. We believe that outsourcing such functions allows us to focus capital and our employees on our core business operations and perform differentiating functions, such as finance, actuarial, product development and risk management functions. In addition, we believe an outsourcing model provides predictable pricing, service levels and volume capabilities and allows us to benefit from technological developments that enhance our customer self-service and sales processes. We believe that we have a good relationship with our principal outsource service providers.
Our Financial Strength/Ratings
Our access to funding and our related cost of borrowing, the attractiveness of certain of our products to customers and requirements for derivatives collateral posting are affected by our credit ratings and insurance financial strength ratings, which are periodically reviewed by the rating agencies. Financial strength ratings and credit ratings are important factors affecting public confidence in an insurer and its competitive position in marketing products.
As of the date of this Annual Report on Form 10-K, A.M. Best, Fitch, Moody’s, and S&P had issued credit ratings, financial strength ratings and/or outlook statements regarding us, as listed below. Credit ratings represent the opinions of rating agencies regarding an entity’s ability to repay its indebtedness. Financial strength ratings represent the opinions of rating agencies regarding the ability of an insurance company to meet its financial obligations under an insurance policy and generally involve quantitative and qualitative evaluations by rating agencies of a company’s financial condition and operating performance. Generally, rating agencies base their financial strength ratings upon information furnished to them by the insurer and upon their own investigations, studies and assumptions. Financial
24
strength ratings are based upon factors of concern to policyholders, agents and intermediaries and are not directed toward the protection of investors. Credit and financial strength ratings are not recommendations to buy, sell or hold securities and they may be revised or revoked at any time at the sole discretion of the rating organization.
In addition to the financial strength ratings, rating agencies use an “outlook statement” to indicate a medium- or long-term trend that, if continued, may lead to a rating change. A positive outlook indicates a rating may be raised and a negative outlook indicates a rating may be lowered. A stable outlook is assigned when ratings are not likely to be changed. A developing outlook is assigned when a rating may be raised, lowered, or affirmed. Outlooks should not be confused with expected stability of the issuer’s financial or economic performance. A rating may have a “stable” outlook to indicate that the rating is not expected to change, but a “stable” outlook does not preclude a rating agency from changing a rating at any time without notice.
The rating organizations may take various actions, positive or negative. Such actions are beyond our control, and we cannot predict what these actions may be and the timing thereof.
A.M. Best S&P Fitch Moody’s
Holding Company & Security Ratings
F&G Annuities & Life, Inc.
Issuer Credit / Default Rating Not Rated BBB- BBB Ba1
Outlook Stable Stable Stable
Senior Unsecured Notes Not Rated BBB- BBB- Not Rated
CF Bermuda Holdings Limited
Issuer Credit / Default Rating Not Rated BBB- BBB Baa3
Outlook Stable Stable Stable
Fidelity & Guaranty Life Holdings, Inc.
Issuer Credit / Default Rating BBB BBB- BBB Not Rated
Outlook Stable Stable Stable
Senior Unsecured Notes (2025 maturity) (a)
BBB BBB BBB Baa2
Outlook Stable Stable
Operating Subsidiary Ratings
Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company
Financial Strength Rating A A- A- A3
Outlook Stable Stable Stable Stable
Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company of New York
Financial Strength Rating A A- A- Not Rated
Outlook Stable Stable Stable
F&G Life Re Ltd
Financial Strength Rating Not Rated A- A- A3
Outlook Stable Stable Stable
F&G Cayman Re Ltd
Financial Strength Rating Not Rated Not Rated A- Not Rated
Outlook Stable
(a) Explicitly guaranteed by parent Fidelity National Financial, Inc. upon acquisition of F&G on June 1, 2020
A.M. Best, S&P, Fitch and Moody’s review their ratings of insurance companies from time to time. There can be no assurance that any particular rating will continue for any given period of time or that it will not be changed or withdrawn entirely if, in their judgment, circumstances so warrant. While the degree to which ratings adjustments will affect sales and persistency is unknown, we believe if our ratings were to be negatively adjusted for any reason, we could experience a material decline in the sales of our products and the persistency of our existing business. See “ Risk Factors ” in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Potential Impact of a Ratings Downgrade. We are required to maintain minimum ratings as a matter of routine practice as part of our over-the-counter derivatives agreements on International Swap and Derivative Association
25
(“ISDA”) forms. Under some ISDA agreements, we have agreed to maintain certain financial strength ratings. Please refer to Note D - Derivative Financial Instruments to the Consolidated Financial Statements in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for disclosure around our requirement to maintain minimum ratings.
If the insurance subsidiaries held net short positions against a counterparty, and the subsidiaries’ financial strength ratings were below the levels required in the ISDA agreement with the counterparty, the counterparty would demand immediate further collateralization, which could negatively impact overall liquidity. Based on the fair value of our derivatives as of December 31, 2023, we hold no net short positions against a counterparty; therefore, there is currently no potential exposure for us to post collateral.
A downgrade of the financial strength rating of one of our principal insurance subsidiaries could affect our competitive position in the insurance industry and make it more difficult for us to market our products, as potential customers may select companies with higher financial strength ratings. A downgrade of the financial strength rating could also impact our borrowing costs.
Regulation of F&G
U.S. Regulatory Overview
FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re are subject to comprehensive regulation and supervision in their domiciles, Iowa, New York, Vermont and Vermont, respectively, and in each state in which they do business. FGL Insurance does business throughout the United States and Puerto Rico, except for New York. FGL NY Insurance only does business in New York. Raven Re is a special purpose captive reinsurance company that only provides reinsurance to FGL Insurance under the CARVM Treaty. Corbeau Re, a wholly owned captive reinsurance company, reinsures certain of FGL Insurance’s FIA policies with GMWB and GWP. FGL Insurance’s principal insurance regulatory authority is the IID; however, state insurance departments throughout the United States also monitor FGL Insurance’s insurance operations as a licensed insurer. The New York State Department of Financial Services (“NYDFS”) regulates the operations of FGL NY Insurance. The purpose of these regulations is primarily to protect insurers’ policyholders and beneficiaries and not their general creditors and shareholders of those insurers or of their holding companies. Many of the laws and regulations to which FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance are subject are regularly re-examined and existing or future laws and regulations may become more restrictive or otherwise adversely affect their operations.
Generally, insurance products underwritten by, and rates used by, FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance must be approved by the insurance regulators in each state or territory in which they are sold. In addition, insurance products may also be subject to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”).
State insurance authorities have broad administrative powers over FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance with respect to all aspects of the insurance business, including:
• licensing to transact business;
• licensing agents;
• prescribing which assets and liabilities are to be considered in determining statutory surplus;
• regulating premium rates for certain insurance products;
• approving policy forms and certain related materials;
• requiring insurers and agents to act in the best interests of consumers when making recommendations to purchase annuities, or to determine whether a reasonable basis exists as to the suitability of such investments for consumers;
• regulating unfair trade and claims practices;
• establishing reserve requirements and solvency standards;
26
• regulating the amount of dividends that may be paid in any year by insurance companies;
• regulating the availability of reinsurance or other substitute financing solutions, the terms thereof and the ability of an insurer to take credit on its financial statements for insurance ceded to reinsurers or other substitute financing solutions;
• fixing maximum interest rates on life insurance policy loans and minimum accumulation or surrender values; and
• regulating the type, amounts, and valuations of investments permitted, transactions with affiliates and other matters.
Financial Regulation
State insurance laws and regulations require FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re to file reports, including financial statements, with state insurance departments in each state in which they do business, and their operations and accounts are subject to examination by those departments at any time. FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re prepare statutory financial statements in accordance with accounting practices and procedures prescribed or permitted by these departments.
The NAIC has approved a series of statutory accounting principles and various model regulations that have been adopted, in some cases with certain modifications, by all state insurance departments. These statutory principles are subject to ongoing change and modification. Moreover, compliance with any particular regulator’s interpretation of a legal or accounting issue may not result in compliance with another regulator’s interpretation of the same issue, particularly when compliance is judged in hindsight. Any particular regulator’s interpretation of a legal or accounting issue may change over time to FGL Insurance’s, FGL NY Insurance’s, Raven Re’s or Corbeau Re’s detriment, or changes to the overall legal or market environment, even absent any change of interpretation by a particular regulator, may cause FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re to change their views regarding the actions they need to take from a legal risk management perspective, which could necessitate changes to FGL Insurance’s, FGL NY Insurance’s, Raven Re’s or Corbeau Re’s practices that may, in some cases, limit their ability to grow and improve profitability.
State insurance departments conduct periodic examinations of the books and records, financial reporting, policy and rate filings, market conduct and business practices of insurance companies domiciled in their states, generally once every three to five years. Examinations are generally carried out in cooperation with the insurance departments of other states under guidelines promulgated by the NAIC. State insurance departments also have the authority to conduct examinations of non-domiciliary insurers that are licensed in their states.
The IID last completed a routine examination of FGL Insurance for the five year period ending 2017 and found no material deficiencies and proposed no adjustments to the financial statements as filed. The IID is currently in the process of executing an exam for the five year period ending 2022. Results of the most recent examination have not been finalized.
The NYDFS last completed a routine financial examination of FGL NY Insurance for the five year period ended December 31, 2017, and found no material deficiencies and proposed no adjustments to the financial statements as filed. The NYDFS is currently in the process of executing an exam for the five year period ending 2022. Results of the most recent examination have not been finalized.
The Vermont Department of Financial Regulation completed a routine financial examination of Raven Re for the five year period ending December 31, 2017, and found no material deficiencies and proposed no adjustments to the financial statements as filed. An examination for the five year period ending 2022 will be executed during the 2024 calendar year.
Dividend and Other Distribution Payment Limitations
The insurance laws of Iowa and New York regulate the amount of dividends that may be paid in any year by FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance, respectively.
27
Pursuant to Iowa insurance law, ordinary dividends are payments, together with all other such payments within the preceding twelve months, that do not exceed the greater of (i) 10% of FGL Insurance’s statutory surplus as regards policyholders as of December 31 of the preceding year; or (ii) the net gain from operations of FGL Insurance (excluding realized capital gains) for the 12-month period ending December 31 of the preceding year.
Dividends in excess of FGL Insurance’s ordinary dividend capacity are referred to as extraordinary and require prior approval of the Iowa Insurance Commissioner. In deciding whether to approve a request to pay an extraordinary dividend, Iowa insurance law requires the Iowa Insurance Commissioner to consider the effect of the dividend payment on FGL Insurance’s surplus and financial condition generally and whether the payment of the dividend will cause FGL Insurance to fail to meet its required U.S. RBC ratio. FGL Insurance may only pay dividends out of statutory earned surplus.
In 2023, FGL Insurance did not pay extraordinary dividends to FGLH. FGL Insurance’s maximum ordinary dividend capacity for 2024 is $0.
Any payment of dividends by FGL Insurance is subject to the regulatory restrictions described above and the approval of such payment by the board of directors of FGL Insurance, which must consider various factors, including general economic and business conditions, tax considerations, FGL Insurance’s strategic plans, financial results and condition, FGL Insurance’s expansion plans, any contractual, legal or regulatory restrictions on the payment of dividends and its effect on RBC and such other factors the board of directors of FGL Insurance considers relevant. For example, payments of dividends could reduce FGL Insurance’s RBC and financial condition and lead to a reduction in FGL Insurance’s financial strength rating. See "Risk Factors—Risks Relating to Our Business—A financial strength ratings downgrade, potential downgrade, or any other negative action by a rating agency could increase our cost of capital, making it challenging to grow our business, and could hinder our ability to participate in certain market segments, thereby adversely affecting our results of operations and our financial condition” in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Each year, FGL NY Insurance may pay a certain limited amount of ordinary dividends or other distributions as calculated under New York insurance laws without being required to obtain the prior consent of the NYDFS. However, to pay any dividends or distributions (including the payment of any dividends or distributions for which prior consent is not required), FGL NY Insurance must provide advance written notice to the NYDFS.
FGL NY Insurance has historically not paid dividends.
Surplus and Capital
FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance are subject to the supervision of the regulators in states where they are licensed to transact business. Regulators have discretionary authority in connection with the continued licensing of these entities to limit or prohibit sales to policyholders if, in their judgment, the regulators determine that such entities have not maintained the minimum surplus or capital or that the further transaction of business would be hazardous to policyholders.
Risk-Based Capital
In order to enhance the regulation of insurers’ solvency, the NAIC adopted a model law to implement RBC requirements for life, health and property and casualty insurance companies. All states have adopted the NAIC’s model law or a substantially similar law. RBC is used to evaluate the adequacy of capital and surplus maintained by an insurance company in relation to risks associated with: (i) asset risk, (ii) insurance risk, (iii) interest rate risk, and (iv) business risk. In general, RBC is calculated by applying factors to various asset, premium and reserve items, taking into account the risk characteristics of the insurer. Within a given risk category, these factors are higher for those items with greater underlying risk and lower for items with lower underlying risk. The RBC formula is used as an early warning regulatory tool to identify possible inadequately capitalized insurers for purposes of initiating regulatory action, and not as a means to rank insurers generally. Insurers that have less statutory capital than the RBC calculation requires are considered to have inadequate capital and are subject to varying degrees of regulatory action depending upon the level of capital inadequacy. As of the most recent annual statutory financial statements
28
filed with insurance regulators, the RBC ratios for FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance each exceeded the minimum RBC requirements.
It is desirable to maintain an RBC ratio in excess of the minimum requirements in order to maintain or improve financial strength ratings. FGL Insurance’s estimated U.S. RBC ratio was approximately 451% as of December 31, 2023. See “Risk Factors — Risks Related to Our Business — A financial strength ratings downgrade, potential downgrade, or any other negative action by a rating agency could increase our cost of capital, making it challenging to grow our business, and could hinder our ability to participate in certain market segments, thereby adversely affecting our results of operations and our financial condition” in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
See “ Bermuda Regulatory Overview — ECR and Bermuda Solvency Capital Requirements ” for a discussion of Bermuda regulatory requirements that impact F&G Life Re.
Insurance Regulatory Information System Tests
The NAIC has developed a set of financial relationships or tests known as the Insurance Regulatory Information System (“IRIS”) to assist state regulators in monitoring the financial condition of U.S. insurance companies and identifying companies that require special attention or action by insurance regulatory authorities. A ratio falling outside the prescribed “usual range” is not considered a failing result. Rather, unusual values are viewed as part of the regulatory early monitoring system. In many cases, it is not unusual for financially sound companies to have one or more ratios that fall outside the usual range. Insurance companies generally submit data annually to the NAIC, which in turn analyzes the data using prescribed financial data ratios, each with defined “usual ranges”. Generally, regulators will begin to investigate or monitor an insurance company if its ratios fall outside the usual ranges for four or more of the ratios. IRIS consists of a statistical phase and an analytical phase whereby financial examiners review insurers’ annual statements and financial ratios. The statistical phase consists of 12 key financial ratios based on year-end data that are generated from the NAIC database annually; each ratio has a “usual range” of results.
As of December 31, 2023, FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re had four , one, two and three ratios outside the usual range, respectively. The IRIS ratios for net income to total income (including realized capital gains and losses), total affiliated investments to capital and surplus, change in premium and change in product mix for FGL Insurance were outside the usual range. The IRIS ratio for change in reserving ratio for FGL NY Insurance was outside the usual range. The IRIS ratios for adequacy of investment income and change in premium for Raven Re were outside the usual range. The IRIS ratios for net income to total income (including realized capital gains and losses), adequacy of investment income and surplus relief - Over $5 million capital and surplus for Corbeau Re were outside the usual range.
In all instances in prior years, regulators have been satisfied upon follow-up that no regulatory action was required. FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re are not currently subject to regulatory restrictions based on these ratios.
Group Capital Calculation
The NAIC developed a group capital calculation tool using an RBC methodology for all entities within the insurance holding company system, including non-U.S. entities. In December 2020, the NAIC adopted the Group Capital Calculation Template and Instructions, as well as amendments to the Model Holding Company Act and Regulation. The amendments implement the annual filing requirement for the group capital calculation but will not become effective until adopted by state legislatures or regulatory agencies. Legislation was introduced in New York in May 2022 that would require a group capital calculation. FNF’s lead regulator, which is also the Company’s lead regulator for this purpose, has not yet adopted a requirement for group capital.
Insurance Reserves
State insurance laws require insurers to analyze the adequacy of reserves. Following the implementation of principle-based reserving for life insurance products, the NAIC is now developing a principle-based reserving framework for fixed annuity products. The respective appointed actuaries for FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re must each submit an opinion on an annual basis that their respective reserves, when
29
considered in light of the respective assets FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re hold with respect to those reserves, make adequate provision for the contractual obligations and related expenses of FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re. FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re have filed all of the required opinions with the insurance departments in the states in which they do business.
Credit for Reinsurance Regulation
States regulate the extent to which insurers are permitted to take credit on their financial statements for the financial obligations that the insurers cede to reinsurers. Where an insurer cedes obligations to a reinsurer that is neither licensed nor accredited by the state insurance department, the ceding insurer is not permitted to take such financial statement credit unless the unlicensed or unaccredited reinsurer secures the liabilities it will owe under the reinsurance contract.
Under the laws regulating credit for reinsurance issued by such unlicensed or unaccredited reinsurers, the permissible means of securing such liabilities are (i) the establishment of a trust account by the reinsurer to hold certain qualifying assets in a qualified U.S. financial institution, such as a member of the Federal Reserve, with the ceding insurer as the exclusive beneficiary of such trust account with the unconditional right to demand, without notice to the reinsurer, that the trustee pay over to it the assets in the trust account equal to the liabilities owed by the reinsurer; (ii) the posting of an unconditional and irrevocable letter of credit by a qualified U.S. financial institution in favor of the ceding company allowing the ceding company to draw upon the letter of credit up to the amount of the unpaid liabilities of the reinsurer and (iii) a “funds withheld” arrangement by which the ceding company withholds transfer to the reinsurer of the assets, which support the liabilities to be owed by the reinsurer, with the ceding insurer retaining title to and exclusive control over such assets.
In addition, all U.S. states, including Iowa and New York, permit an insurer to take credit for reinsurance ceded to a non-U.S. reinsurer that posts collateral in amounts less than 100% of the reinsurer’s obligations if the reinsurer has been designated as a “certified reinsurer” and is domiciled in a country recognized by the state and the NAIC as a “Qualified Jurisdiction.” The reduced percentage of full collateral applied to a certified reinsurer is based upon an assessment of the reinsurer and its financial ratings. Iowa and New York both also recognize certain qualified non-U.S. insurers as reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers such that ceding domestic insurers may receive credit for reinsurance ceded to such unauthorized reinsurers without the requirement for the reinsurer to provide collateral.
FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance are subject to the credit for reinsurance rules described above in Iowa and New York, respectively, insofar as they enter into any reinsurance contracts with reinsurers that are neither licensed, accredited nor certified in Iowa and New York, respectively, or recognized as a reciprocal reinsurer in such jurisdictions.
Insurance Holding Company Regulation
F&G, as the indirect parent company of FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance, is subject to the insurance holding company laws in Iowa and New York. These laws generally require each insurance company directly or indirectly owned by the holding company to register with the insurance department in the insurance company’s state of domicile and to furnish annually financial and other information about the operations of companies within the holding company system. Generally, all transactions between insurers and affiliates within the holding company system are subject to regulation and must be fair and reasonable, and may require prior notice and approval or non-disapproval by its domiciliary insurance regulator.
Most states, including Iowa and New York, have insurance laws that require regulatory approval of a direct or indirect change of control of an insurer or an insurer’s holding company. Such laws prevent any person from acquiring control, directly or indirectly, of F&G, FGL US Holdings Inc. (“FGL US Holdings”), CF Bermuda Holdings Limited (“CF Bermuda”), FGLH, FGL Insurance or FGL NY Insurance or certain of their affiliates unless that person has filed a statement with specified information with the insurance regulators and has obtained their prior approval. In addition, investors deemed to have a direct or indirect controlling interest are required to make regulatory filings and respond to regulatory inquiries. Under most states’ statutes, including those of Iowa and New York, acquiring 10% or more of the voting stock of an insurance company or its parent company is presumptively
30
considered a change of control, although such presumption may be rebutted. In addition, the insurance laws of Iowa and New York permit a determination of control in circumstances where the thresholds for the presumption of control have not been crossed. Similar laws apply to a direct or indirect change of ownership of Raven Re and Corbeau Re. Any person who is deemed to acquire control over F&G, FNF, FGL US Holdings, CF Bermuda, FGLH, FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re, Corbeau Re or certain of their affiliates including any person who acquires 10% or more of our or FNF’s voting securities of FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance or certain of their affiliates, without the prior approval of the insurance regulators of Iowa and New York, will be in violation of those states’ laws and may be subject to injunctive action requiring the disposition or seizure of those securities by the relevant insurance regulator or prohibiting the voting of those securities and to other actions determined by the relevant insurance regulator.
Insurance Guaranty Association Assessments
Each state has insurance guaranty association laws under which insurers doing business in the state may be assessed by state insurance guaranty associations for certain obligations of insolvent insurance companies to policyholders and claimants. Typically, states assess each member insurer in an amount related to the member insurer’s proportionate share of the business written by all member insurers in the state. Although no prediction can be made as to the amount and timing of any future assessments under these laws, FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance have established reserves that they believe are adequate for assessments relating to insurance companies that are currently subject to insolvency proceedings.
Market Conduct Regulation
State insurance laws and regulations include numerous provisions governing the marketplace activities of insurers, including provisions governing the form and content of disclosure to consumers, illustrations, advertising, sales and complaint process practices. State regulatory authorities generally enforce these provisions through periodic market conduct examinations. In addition, FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance must file, and in many jurisdictions and for some lines of business obtain regulatory approval for, rates and forms relating to the insurance written in the jurisdictions in which they operate. FGL Insurance is currently the subject of two ongoing market conduct examinations in various states. Market conduct examinations can result in monetary fines or remediation and generally require FGL Insurance to devote significant resources to the management of such examinations. FGL Insurance does not believe that any of the current market conduct examinations it is subject to will result in any fines or remediation orders that will be material to its business.
Regulation of Investments
FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re are subject to state laws and regulations that require diversification of their investment portfolios and limit the amount of investments in certain asset categories, such as below investment grade fixed income securities, equity, real estate, other equity investments and derivatives. Failure to comply with these laws and regulations would cause investments exceeding regulatory limitations to be treated as either non-admitted assets for purposes of measuring surplus or as not qualified as an asset held for reserve purposes and, in some instances, would require divestiture or replacement of such non-qualifying investments. We believe that the investment portfolios of FGL Insurance, FGL NY Insurance, Raven Re and Corbeau Re as of December 31, 2023, complied in all material respects with such regulations.
In 2023, the NAIC released new regulations the define a residual interest. All the Company’s impacted insurance subsidiaries have complied with the new regulations. Beginning January 1, 2025, these investments will be subject to a new accounting model, which the Company is currently in the process of implementing. Also in 2023, the NAIC released new regulations that define the criteria for investments that can be classified as a bond, which the Company is currently in the process of implementing for all of its impacted insurance subsidiaries. See “Risk Factors — Risks Related to Our Business — Increased regulation or scrutiny of alternative investment advisers, arrangements with such investment advisers and investment activities may affect BIS’s or, if engaged, any other asset manager’s ability to manage our investment portfolio or impact of the reputation of our business” in this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
31
On December 7, 2021, the NAIC assigned to its Macroprudential Working Group, the evaluation of a list of “Regulatory Considerations Applicable (But Not Exclusive) to Private Equity (PE) Owned Insurers.” Included within this list is the consideration of material increases in privately structured securities (both by affiliated and non-affiliated asset managers), which the NAIC says introduces other sources of risk or increases traditional credit risk, such as complexity risk and illiquidity risk. As a result, the NAIC has issued several clarifying revisions to the guidance and disclosure requirements for related party and affiliated securities and continues to consider additional proposals and disclosure requirements.
In addition, the NAIC continues to refine its application of RBC factors for certain investments.
Privacy Regulation
Our operations are subject to certain federal and state laws and regulations that require financial institutions and other businesses to protect the security and confidentiality of personal information, including health-related and customer information, and to notify customers and other individuals about their policies and practices relating to their collection and disclosure of health-related and customer information and their practices relating to protecting the security and confidentiality of such information. These laws and regulations require notice to affected individuals, law enforcement agencies, regulators and others if there is a breach of the security of certain personal information, including social security numbers, and require holders of certain personal information to protect the security of the data. Our operations are also subject to certain federal regulations that require financial institutions and creditors to implement effective programs to detect, prevent and mitigate identity theft. In addition, our ability to make telemarketing calls and to send unsolicited email or fax messages to consumers and customers and our uses of certain personal information, including consumer report information, are regulated. Federal and state governments and regulatory bodies may be expected to consider additional or more detailed regulation regarding these subjects and the privacy and security of personal information.
The Dodd-Frank Act
The Dodd-Frank Act made sweeping changes to the regulation of financial services entities, products and markets. Certain provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act are applicable to us, our competitors or those entities with which we do business. These provisions may impact us in many ways, including, but not limited to, having an effect on the overall business climate, requiring the allocation of certain resources to government affairs, and increasing our legal and compliance related activities and the costs associated therewith.
Under the Dodd-Frank Act, annuities that meet specific requirements, including requirements relating to certain state suitability rules, are specifically exempted from being treated as securities by the SEC. We believe that the types of FIAs that FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance sell will meet these requirements and, therefore, are exempt from being treated as securities by the SEC and state securities regulators. However, there can be no assurance that federal or state securities laws or state insurance laws and regulations will not be amended or interpreted to impose further requirements on FIAs. If FIAs were to be treated as securities, federal and state securities laws would require additional registration and licensing of these products and the agents selling them, and FGL Insurance and FGL NY Insurance would be required to seek additional marketing relationships for these products, any of which could impose significant restrictions on its ability to conduct operations as currently operated.
ERISA and Fiduciary Standards
We may offer certain insurance and annuity products to employee benefit plans governed by ERISA and/or the Code, including group annuity contracts designated to fund tax-qualified retirement plans. ERISA and the Code provide (among other requirements) standards of conduct for employee benefit plan fiduciaries, including investment managers and investment advisers with respect to the assets of such plans, and hold fiduciaries liable if they fail to satisfy fiduciary standards of conduct.
State and federal regulators have been adopting stronger consumer protection regulations that may materially impact our company, business, distribution, and products. The NAIC adopted an amended Suitability in Annuity Transactions Model Regulation in February 2020 incorporating a requirement that agents act in the best interest of
32
consumers without putting their own financial interests or insurer’s interests ahead of consumer interests. The best interest requirement is satisfied by complying with four regulatory obligations relating to care, disclosure, conflict of interest, and documentation. The amended model regulation also requires agents to provide certain disclosures to consumers, obligates insurers to supervise agent compliance with the new requirements, and prohibits sales contests or other incentives based on sales of specific annuities within a limited period of time.
Several states have adopted the revised NAIC model regulation, including FGL Insurance’s domiciliary state of Iowa. Management has instituted business procedures to comply with these revised requirements where required. FGL NY Insurance separately instituted new business procedures in response to the NYDFS best interest rule adopted in August 2019 which survived a legal challenge and deviates from the NAIC model regulation and is considered more onerous in certain respects including its broader application to life insurance sales.
In December 2020, the Department of Labor (“DOL”) issued its final version of an investment advice rule replacing the previous “Fiduciary Rule” that had been challenged by industry participants and vacated in March 2018 by the United States Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The new investment advice rule reinstates the five-part test for determining whether a person is considered a fiduciary for purposes of ERISA and the Code and sets forth a new prohibited transaction exemption (“PTE”) referred to as PTE 2020-02. The rule’s preamble also contains the DOL’s reinterpretation of elements of the five-part test that appears to encompass more insurance agents selling individual retirement account (“IRA”) products and withdraws the agency’s longstanding position that rollover recommendations out of employer plans are not subject to ERISA. The new rule took effect on February 16, 2021.
The DOL investment advice rule leaves in place PTE 84-24, which is a longstanding class exemption providing prohibited transaction relief for insurance agents selling annuity products, provided certain disclosures are made to the plan fiduciary, which is the policyholder in the case of an IRA, and certain other conditions are met. Among other things, these disclosures include the agent’s relationship to the insurer and commissions received in connection with the annuity sale. FGL Insurance along with FGL NY Insurance, designed and launched a compliance program in January 2022 requiring all agents selling IRA products to submit an acknowledgment with each IRA application indicating the agent has satisfied PTE 84-24 requirements on a precautionary basis in case the agent acted or is found to have acted as a fiduciary. Meanwhile, the DOL has publicly announced its intention to consider future rulemaking that may revoke or modify PTE 84-24.
On November 2, 2023, following previous attempts to expand fiduciary regulation for advisers, the DOL released a proposed rule (the “New Fiduciary Rule”) to significantly broaden the definition of “fiduciary” under ERISA. Among other requirements, if finalized in its proposed form, the New Fiduciary Rule provides that any person will be an investment advice fiduciary if they provide investment advice or make an investment recommendation to a retirement investor ( i.e., a plan, plan fiduciary, plan participant or beneficiary, IRA, IRA owner or beneficiary, or IRA fiduciary) for a fee or other compensation, and the person provides the advice or makes the recommendation on a regular basis as part of their business and the recommendation is provided under circumstances indicating that the recommendation is based on the particular needs or individual investor circumstances of the retirement investor. Unlike the current ERISA standard, the New Fiduciary Rule would subject non-discretionary investment advice to retirement plans and accounts to the prudent-person “best interest” standard that has historically been reserved for investment advisors with discretionary authority or control over ERISA plan assets. If the New Fiduciary Rule is adopted in its present form, certain of the Company’s agents would likely be considered fiduciaries for purposes of ERISA and the Internal Revenue Code—subjecting the Company, and the insurance industry on the whole, to greater regulatory risk.
Management believes these current and emerging developments relating to market conduct standards for the financial services industry may over time materially affect the way in which our agents do business, the role of IMOs, sale of IRA products including IRA-to-IRA and employer plan rollovers, how the company supervises its distribution force, compensation practices, and liability exposure and costs. In addition to implementing the compliance procedures described above, management is monitoring further developments closely and will be working with IMOs and distributors to adapt to evolving regulatory requirements and risks.
33
The SECURE 2.0 Act
New and recently passed legislation may also impact the industry in which F&G competes. For example, the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, which went into effect as early as January 1, 2023, in certain respects, creates an opportunity for F&G and its competitors to pursue sales to employer retirement plan sponsors as well as its traditional customers. In addition, F&G and its competitors may implement operational changes to adapt to the effect of the new legislation. See “Risk Factors— Legal, Regulatory and Tax Risks—The SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 may impact our business and the markets in which we compete .”
Corporate Alternative Minimum Tax
The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (the “Inflation Reduction Act”) was signed into law on August 16, 2022. Among other changes, the Inflation Reduction Act introduced a 15% corporate alternative minimum tax (“CAMT”) on adjusted financial statement income and a 1% excise tax on treasury stock repurchases. These provisions were effective January 1, 2023. For purposes of calculating the adjusted financial statement income, the Company is included in the controlled group of FNF, its parent company. Though the Company is subject to the minimum tax, the Company does not expect to be in a perpetual CAMT position. The life companies will join the consolidated tax return group with FNF and file a life/non-life consolidated return once the five-year waiting period has completed in 2026, which should strengthen that position as FNF is not anticipating owing CAMT on its future returns. For the year ended December 31, 2023, the Company was subject to CAMT, but there is no impact to total tax. A CAMT credit carryforward was created and is expected to be able to be utilized in future years.
Climate Risk
On November 15, 2021, NYDFS issued final Guidance for New York Domestic Insurers on Managing the Financial Risks from Climate Change, detailing NYDFS’s expectations related to domestic insurers' management of the financial risks from climate change. These guidelines are applicable to FGL NY Insurance and became effective in 2022. Under the guidelines, climate change risk must be specifically included in an insurance group's enterprise risk management function.
Diversity and Corporate Governance
The NAIC and certain state insurance regulators are focused on the issue of diversity within the insurance industry, such as the diversity of an insurer’s board of directors and management. The NAIC is developing a framework for approaching issues related to race and insurance. On March 16, 2021, the NYDFS issued a circular letter that states that the NYDFS expects the insurers it regulates to make diversity of their leadership a business priority and key element of their corporate governance. This guidance is applicable to FGL NY Insurance.
Bermuda Regulatory Overview
F&G Life Re is a Bermuda exempted company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1981, as amended (the “Bermuda Companies Act”) and registered as a Class E insurer under the Insurance Act 1978, as amended, and its related regulations (the “Bermuda Insurance Act”). F&G Life Re is regulated by the Bermuda Monetary Authority (“BMA”).
The Bermuda Insurance Act provides that no person may carry on an insurance business in or from within Bermuda unless registered as an insurer under the Bermuda Insurance Act by the BMA. In deciding whether to grant registration, the BMA has broad discretion to act as it thinks fit in the public interest. The BMA is required by the Bermuda Insurance Act to determine whether the applicant is a fit and proper body to be engaged in the insurance business and, in particular, whether it has, or has available to it, adequate knowledge and expertise. The registration of an applicant as an insurer is subject to the insurer complying with the terms of its registration and such other conditions as the BMA may impose at any time. In addition, the Bermuda Insurance Act requires BMA approval of increases in control or dispositions of control of an insurance company.
Effective January 1, 2015, Bermuda was placed on the NAIC’s List of Qualified Jurisdictions, which makes Bermuda-domiciled reinsurers that meet certain criteria to qualify as a certified reinsurer eligible for reduced
34
reinsurance collateral requirements under the NAIC’s Credit for Reinsurance Model Law and Regulations as adopted by various states. F&G Life Re has not applied for a determination to be designated as a certified reinsurer in any state.
Bermuda has been awarded full equivalence for commercial insurers under Europe’s Solvency II regime applicable to insurance companies, which regime came into effect on January 1, 2016.
Effective January 1, 2020, Bermuda was granted NAIC Reciprocal Jurisdiction status, which makes Bermuda domiciled reinsurers that satisfy certain conditions eligible to be designated as a reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurer. Under the NAIC’s Credit for Reinsurance Model Law and Regulations which has been adopted by all states, a ceding insurer may take credit for reinsurance ceded to a reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurer without posting collateral. F&G Life Re has not applied for a determination to be designated a reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurer in any state.
All insurers are required to implement corporate governance policies and processes as the BMA considers appropriate given the nature, size, complexity and risk profile of the insurer and all insurers, on an annual basis, are required to deliver a declaration to the BMA confirming whether or not they meet the minimum criteria for registration under the Bermuda Insurance Act.
All insurers are required to comply with the Bermuda Insurance Code of Conduct, which is a codification of best practices for insurers provided by the BMA, and to submit annually to the BMA with its statutory financial return a declaration of compliance confirming it complies with the Bermuda Insurance Code of Conduct.
The BMA utilizes a risk-based approach when it comes to licensing and supervising insurance and reinsurance companies. As part of the BMA’s risk-based system, an assessment of the inherent risks within each particular class of insurer or reinsurer is used to determine the limitations and specific requirements that may be imposed. Thereafter the BMA keeps its analysis of relative risk within individual institutions under review on an ongoing basis, including through the scrutiny of audited financial statements, and, as appropriate, meeting with senior management during onsite visits.
The Bermuda Insurance Act imposes solvency and liquidity standards on Bermuda insurance companies, as well as auditing and reporting requirements. Certain significant aspects of the Bermuda insurance regulatory framework are set forth below.
Minimum Solvency Margin. The Bermuda Insurance Act provides that the value of the assets of an insurer must exceed the value of its liabilities by an amount greater than its prescribed minimum solvency margin.
The minimum solvency margin that must be maintained by a Class E insurer is the greater of: (i) $8,000,000; (ii) 2% of first $500,000,000 of assets plus 1.5% of assets above $500,000,000; and (iii) 25% of that insurer’s enhanced capital requirement (“ECR”). An insurer may file an application under the Bermuda Insurance Act to waive the aforementioned requirements.
ECR and Bermuda Solvency Capital Requirements (“BSCR”). Class E insurers are required to maintain available capital and surplus at a level equal to or in excess of the applicable ECR, which is established by reference to either the applicable BSCR model or an approved internal capital model. Furthermore, to enable the BMA to better assess the quality of the insurer’s capital resources, a Class E insurer is required to disclose the makeup of its capital in accordance with its 3-tiered capital system. An insurer may file an application under the Bermuda Insurance Act to have the aforementioned ECR requirements waived.
Restrictions on Dividends and Distributions. In addition to the requirements under the Bermuda Companies Act (as discussed below), the Bermuda Insurance Act limits the maximum amount of annual dividends and distributions that may be paid or distributed by F&G Life Re without prior regulatory approval.
F&G Life Re is prohibited from declaring or paying a dividend if it fails to meet its minimum solvency margin, or ECR, or if the declaration or payment of such dividend would cause such breach. If F&G Life Re were to fail to meet its minimum solvency margin on the last day of any financial year, it would be prohibited from declaring or paying any dividends during the next financial year without the approval of the BMA.
35
In addition, as a Class E insurer, F&G Life Re must not declare or pay a dividend to any person other than a policyholder unless the value of the assets of such insurer, as certified by the insurer’s approved actuary, exceeds its liabilities (as so certified) by the greater of its margin of solvency or ECR. In the event a dividend complies with the above, F&G Life Re must ensure the amount of any such dividend does not exceed that excess.
Furthermore, as a Class E insurer, F&G Life Re must not declare or pay a dividend in any financial year which would exceed 25% of its total capital and statutory surplus, as set out in its previous year’s financial statements, unless at least seven days before payment of such dividend F&G Life Re files with the BMA an affidavit signed by at least two directors of F&G Life Re and its principal representative under the Bermuda Insurance Act stating that, in the opinion of those signing, declaration of such dividend has not caused the insurer to fail to meet its relevant margins.
The Bermuda Companies Act also limits F&G Life Re’s ability to pay dividends and make distributions to its shareholders. F&G Life Re is not permitted to declare or pay a dividend, or make a distribution out of its contributed surplus, if it is, or would after the payment be, unable to pay its liabilities as they become due or if the realizable value of its assets would be less than its liabilities.
Reduction of Capital. F&G Life Re may not reduce its total statutory capital by 15% or more, as set out in its previous year’s financial statements, unless it has received the prior approval of the BMA. Total statutory capital consists of the insurer’s paid in share capital, its contributed surplus (sometimes called additional paid in capital) and any other fixed capital designated by the BMA as statutory capital.
Bermuda Corporate Income Tax
The Corporate Income Tax (“CIT”) Act of 2023 was passed in Bermuda on December 27, 2023. The CIT Act will commence on January 1, 2025 and will apply a statutory rate of 15% to the taxable income or loss of Bermuda tax resident entities and permanent establishments. F&G Life Re, a 953(d) company with no or minimal US permanent tax differences, is not expected to owe any Bermuda CIT due to the foreign tax credit. The deferred tax asset recorded for the year ended December 31, 2023 of $24 million has a full valuation allowance. As a result, there is no material impact to the financial statements.
Cayman Islands Regulatory Overview
F&G Cayman Re Ltd. (“F&G Cayman Re”) is a Cayman Islands exempted company incorporated under the Companies Act, (2023 Revision) as amended, (the “Cayman Islands Companies Act”) and licensed as a Class D insurer in the Cayman Islands under the Insurance Act, 2010 as amended and its related regulations (the “Cayman Islands Insurance Act”). F&G Cayman Re is regulated by the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (“CIMA”).
The Cayman Islands Insurance Act provides that no person may carry on an insurance business in or from within the Cayman Islands unless licensed under the Cayman Islands Insurance Act. CIMA has broad discretion in its consideration of whether to grant a license and must act in the public interest. CIMA is required by the Cayman Islands Insurance Act to determine whether an applicant is a fit and proper body to be engaged in insurance business. A licensed insurer must comply with the terms of its license and such other conditions as CIMA may impose at any time. In addition, the Cayman Islands Insurance Act requires CIMA approval of increases in control or dispositions of control of an insurance company.
All insurers are required to implement corporate governance policies as CIMA considers appropriate given the nature, size, complexity and risk profile of the insurer. All insurers are also required to comply with the CIMA's Rules and Statements of Guidance as applicable to insurers which is a codification of best practices provided by CIMA, and to submit annually to CIMA audited financial statements and a declaration of compliance confirming it complies with the Cayman Islands Insurance Act.
Capital Requirements. The Cayman Islands Insurance Act provides that an insurer must maintain a minimum capital requirement based on its license class. For a Class D insurer, the minimum capital requirement is $50,000,000. In addition, an insurer must maintain a minimum margin of solvency at a level equal to or in excess of the total prescribed capital requirement which is established by reference to either the applicable prescribed capital
36
requirements based on license class or an internal capital model approved by CIMA. Notwithstanding the minimum capital requirements, CIMA may set an enhanced prescribed capital requirement in respect of any insurer. CIMA may also, for class B, C and D insurers, exclude from the calculations assets that it deems inappropriate.
CIMA utilizes a risk-based approach to licensing and supervising insurers and to determining limitations and/or specific requirements. CIMA reviews on an ongoing basis, an insurer’s audited financial statements, actuarial valuation report and, as appropriate, meeting with senior management during onsite visits.
The Cayman Islands Insurance Act and regulations promulgated thereunder impose solvency and liquidity standards on Cayman Islands insurance companies, as well as auditing and reporting requirements.
As a regulated insurance company, F&G Cayman Re is subject to the supervision of CIMA and CIMA may at any time direct F&G Cayman Re, in relation to a policy, a line of business or the entire business, to cease or refrain from committing an act or pursing a course of conduct and to perform such acts as in the opinion of CIMA are necessary to remedy or ameliorate the situation.
The laws and regulations of the Cayman Islands require that, among other things, F&G Cayman Re maintain minimum levels of statutory capital, surplus and liquidity, meet solvency standards, submit to periodic examinations of its financial condition and restrict payments of dividends and reductions of capital. Statutes, regulations and policies that F&G Cayman Re is subject to may also restrict the ability of F&G Cayman Re to write insurance and reinsurance policies, make certain investments and distribute funds. Any failure to meet the applicable requirements or minimum statutory capital requirements could subject it to further examination or corrective action by CIMA, including restrictions on dividend payments, limitations on our writing of additional business or engaging in finance activities, supervision or liquidation.
Human Capital Resources
As of December 31, 2023, we had 1,165 full-time equivalent employees. None of our employees are subject to collective bargaining agreements. We believe that our relations with employees are generally good.
Talent Management
F&G embeds diversity, equity and inclusion into our culture and is embraced within our core values - Collaborative, Authentic, Dynamic and Empowered. These core values coupled with our competitive total rewards philosophy and flexible work environment provide an attractive employee value proposition. We recruit top talent to join our team and provide opportunities for personal and professional growth.
Our development programs are designed to provide opportunities for all employees to grow and develop. Development programs are aligned to the skills and behaviors defined in our F&G Competencies - Think Enterprise Wide, Leverage Data, Center Equity, Communicate with Courage, Be Accountable- and ensure our employees are developing skills that are critical to achieve business goals now and in the future.
Leadership Academy is our premiere leadership development program designed to develop the next level of leaders at F&G and enables cross-functional leaders to hone their leadership capability and network with colleagues from across the enterprise.
Employee engagement is measured annually through two surveys. Our strong engagement scores on the Energage Engagement Survey were rewarded with several “Top Places to Work” designations including Leadership, Innovation, Compensation & Benefits, Work-Life Flexibility and Financial Services Industry. We are honored to be a recipient of the “Top Workplaces USA” designation in 2023 and 2022 and a recipient of the “Top Workplaces Iowa” designation since 2018.
The Gallup Employee Engagement survey data is our key metric to support strategic decisions on engaging and retaining our talent. Initiatives such as our Employee Resource Groups and our Connection Week program are a few examples of programs that were identified based on our employee engagement data.
37
At F&G, we provide comprehensive benefits designed to meet the needs of our employees and demonstrate the value they bring to the organization. Employees are eligible to participate in our 401(k) savings plan, to which we make matching and annual nondiscretionary contributions. Employees are also eligible to participate in our Employee Stock Purchase Plan with a competitive match feature. We offer competitive health care benefit options for medical, dental and vision coverage, as well as a health savings account with an employer contribution. Other benefits offerings include health care and dependent care flexible spending accounts, employee assistance program, wellness reimbursements, charitable matching donations, and adoption assistance. To support a healthy work-life balance, all employees receive paid time off, holidays, volunteer time off and paid parental leave for new parents.
Employee retention is critical to the success of our business. Turnover is monitored and analyzed to ensure we are protecting our most valuable asset, our team members. Our turnover rates have been consistently below national and industry-specific benchmarks.
Our Approach to Environmental, Social, and Governance (“ESG”)
F&G’s products and services inherently provide a social good, and that sentiment of service also provides the foundation for F&G’s culture and guides business operations as well as interactions within our communities.
Governance - Board oversight
Our Company and our Board seek to address ESG issues to better serve our employees, business partners, and the communities impacted by our business. The F&G AC is responsible for overseeing the Company’s ESG risks. The AC Charter states that “The Committee shall review with management the Company’s policies and practices with respect to risk assessment and risk management, including with respect to … environmental, social, and governance risk, except with respect to those risks for which oversight has been assigned to other committees of the Board or retained by the Board.” The AC meets at least four times per year. Climate expertise resides on the Board and the AC. The AC receives updates from the Company’s Chief Risk Officer (“CRO”) on a quarterly basis regarding enterprise risk management (“ERM”) including an overview of current and emerging risks. Such risks may include climate risks as a subset of investment risks and an update on overall ESG-related matters. The CRO will continue to update the AC on F&G’s climate risk profile as risks and opportunities arise.
Management’s role in assessing and managing ESG-related risks and opportunities.
F&G’s management team leads ESG efforts with oversight from the AC, who reports the Company’s ESG progress and efforts to the Board.
F&G’s Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) has the ultimate responsibility within management for governance-related matters at F&G. The CEO, CRO, General Counsel (“GC”), SVP Chief People Officer (“SVP-PO”), Deputy Chief Investment Officer (“D-CIO”), and Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”), SVP Investor & External Relations comprise the ESG Executive Steering Committee, which is responsible for making key enterprise decisions around strategy, capital and asset allocation, planning and budgeting, and developing human capital. The CRO chairs the ESG Executive Steering Committee. The D-CIO, GC and SVP-PO are responsible for assessing the recommendations made to the ESG Executive Steering Committee and providing effective input prior to agreeing on strategy, initiatives, or other courses of action. The Senior Vice President of Investor & External Relations and the CFO are consulted for input prior to final approval of actions. The ultimate decision rests with the CEO.
F&G has an ESG working group that is comprised of functional and business-level management responsible for performing any underlying analysis, research, documentation, and implementation supporting the ESG Executive Steering Committee efforts. This group may spin up sub-working groups or task forces to address specific activities. For example, a targeted group was formed to assist with a pilot climate stress scenario analysis performed in 2023.
38
Additional governance committees
The AC and ESG Executive Steering Committee utilize and rely on other groups and committees within F&G beyond the ESG working group to ensure all risks and opportunities related to ESG are addressed appropriately.
The ERMC is an enterprise committee, consisting of C-suite level executives including the CEO, CFO, CRO, and Chief Investment Officer, who are responsible for reviewing risks and associated strategy across the business. The ESG risks are included in the overall F&G Risk Register that is the basis for quarterly risk assessments. The overall risk posture of the organization is updated in the quarterly ERM dashboard report. The development of an enterprise-ESG program, including climate-risks, is included in F&G’s 2023 Own Risk and Solvency Assessment (“ORSA”) summary report, and articulates the responsibility for actively monitoring and focusing resources on ESG-related activities.
The Investment Committee provides oversight of investments held, approves new asset classes, and reviews investment managers and mandates. The Investment Committee also oversees the relationships with F&G’s Asset Management companies, which includes assessing their ESG policies and practices for consistency with F&G’s missions and vision.
The Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (“DEI”) Advisory Council (“Council”) is an ongoing cross functional group that includes the CEO & President. The Council was established to help create a comprehensive DEI strategy, objectives, and success metrics for DEI. The Council provides advice, guidance, and championship for the DEI strategy execution, and helps to ensure a high-functioning interaction model for the Council, Employee Resource Groups (“ERG”), Human Resources, Communications, and the business lines. The Council reports initiatives and progress up through the Management Committee as needed.
Strategy
F&G’s product solutions provide social good by supporting clients to achieve their retirement goals and to improve their financial lives, while protecting against unforeseen events through life insurance policies. This sentiment of service provides the foundation for F&G’s culture and guides business operations as well as interactions within our communities.
Through the underlying ESG investment policies of F&G’s asset management partners, the investment portfolio supporting the current range of products offered by F&G considers climate-related risks and the transition to a low carbon economy. As long-term investors, F&G understands the energy transition will be gradual, and the focus should be on investment outcomes that will support our fiduciary duty to our clients and the investment goals of our clients.
F&G completed a qualitative assessment of climate risks and opportunities in 2023 with input from the ESG Executive Steering Committee and ESG working group. The assessment identified potential impacts of climate change on the F&G businesses and financial plans over short-, medium-, and long-term time horizons. Generally, short term is defined as present and 1 – 5 years in the future, medium-term is 5- 10 years in the future, and long-term is 10-30 years in the future.
The assessment also identified the risks applicable to F&G based on physical presence, products sold, and credit/counterparty risk. The identified risks were added to the enterprise risk register for inclusion in the quarterly self-assessment and annual risk assessment processes. Most risks can be addressed more acutely in the short and medium term, as well as integrated into long-term planning.
Impact of pending and passed legislation
Developments in national, state, and international regulations related to climate risk are increasing. Business emissions are categorized into Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions and account for both direct and indirect emitted gases (“GHG”). Scope 1 emissions are GHGs released directly from the business. Scope 2 emissions are indirect GHGs
39
released from the energy purchased by an organization. Scope 3 emissions are also indirect GHG emissions, accounting for upstream and downstream emissions of a product or service and emissions across a business value chain. Additional compilation of data is required for disclosure requirements of scope 1 & 2 emissions, which impacts operational processes, although not material in cost. Moreover, F&G is diligently working to identify and gather the appropriate data for Scope 3 emissions.
F&G provides information on ESG efforts to its investor, client, and employee stakeholders through the State Climate Survey, client and investor surveys, and internal communications. While there is interest in F&G’s efforts, demand for changes to F&G products has not changed as a result of information provided.
Capital expenditures related to climate change
Current expenditures related specifically to climate change have been minimal. F&G added an ESG module to the Governance, Risk, and Compliance application to maintain risk information and metrics related to ESG efforts. Future expenditures will likely increase as F&G moves forward with plans for ongoing scenario analysis and data stores to facilitate the calculation of Scope 3 emissions.
Operational sustainability and workforce flexibility
F&G aims to reduce the company’s environmental footprint through a variety of sustainable and environmentally sound programs within its LEED-certified headquarters building in Des Moines, Iowa. F&G also promotes flexible work from home arrangements which reduce commute time, greenhouse gas emissions, and paper usage.
F&G is committed to providing employees with the opportunities and flexibility they need to succeed, as well as ensuring a culture of belonging and inclusion by:
• Providing well rounded benefits that support employees diverse needs such as, domestic partner medical coverage, gender dysphoria services, $50k lifetime maximum for infertility services ($35k is United Health Care standard), travel & lodging reimbursement for services rendered out-of-state due to state law, Employee Assistance Program including 6 free counseling sessions per person per incident per year, in addition to other emotional health solutions, $10k in adoption assistance benefit, parental leave benefits, flexible PTO and wellness reimbursements.
• Supporting employee training, developing and educating through LinkedIn learning with a wide array of topics (e.g., Using Gender inclusive language, Fueling your Company Culture, Inclusive Leadership, Unconscious Bias, etc.), tuition reimbursement, and manager and leadership training.
• Hosting educational and developmental events such as, a Mental Awareness and Racial Equity Master Class, a Mental Health panel, and a panel on Neurodiversity.
• Growing the share of people of color in leadership roles (VP+) from 2022 to 2023; F&G’s management committee (C-suite) is comprised of 40% female leadership.
• Recognized for several Cultural Excellence Awards in 2022 and 2023 through Energage, for excellence in 1) Compensation and Benefits, 2) Leadership, 3) Work-Life Flexibility, 4) Innovation, 5) Appreciation, and 6) Employee Wellbeing.
40
Diversity and inclusion
Specific diversity and inclusion programs and organizations supported by F&G include:
• The International Association of Black Actuaries and The Organization of Latino Actuaries, both of which F&G employees are members of and serve as a network for potential new hires.
• Women Lead Change, an organization dedicated to the development, advancement and promotion of women, their organizations, and impact on the economy and future workforce.
• Capitol City Pride, which brings together members of Iowa’s LGBTQ+ community, allies and businesses.
• Enabling our employee-led Council’s work in creating awareness and support around important topics such as mental health awareness, including the launch of ERGs. ERGs are a safe space for employees of similar identity/affinity to network, grow, voice, engage, and help the organization build a culture of inclusion and belonging. They are forums that deliver intentional, impactful and powerful programming for the benefit of members. Our ERGs launched in 2023 include Women’s Empowerment, Wellness, PRIDE, F&G Ultimate Network (“F.U.N”), and Community Impact, and in early 2024, we launched two new ERGs, Black Originators, Leaders and Doers (“BOLD”) and Asian Pacific Islander Alliance (“APIA”).
Community engagement
F&G focuses its community engagement and charitable giving to support essential needs such as food insecurity and housing. In recent years, F&G has won multiple awards for its corporate support and employee involvement with United Way, including Outstanding Corporate/Foundation Philanthropist for 2023 from the Association of Fundraising Professionals Central Iowa Chapter. Other community investments include:
• Serving as founding partner of the American Council of Life Insurer’s Impact Investments Initiative to make housing affordable and sustainable in underserved communities.
• Fostering partnerships in the Des Moines community with the Iowa Food Bank and Polk County Housing Trust.
• Offering company-wide volunteer events for employees to make an impact locally with organizations such as Rebuilding Together.
• Providing employees with 32 hours of paid time off per year for volunteering.
• Supporting dozens of other community organizations identified by F&G employees in support of essential needs within the community where they live and work.
Investment Portfolio climate scenario analysis
F&G conducted a one-time pilot scenario analysis exercise with the advisory support of Baringa using BlackRock’s Aladdin Climate technology (incorporating Baringa’s industry-leading Climate Change Scenario Model). This analysis included an overall scenario analysis on the investment portfolio and assessed the transition risks by asset class and sector for the portfolio using different climate scenarios. The overall scenario analysis covered multiple industry-recognized scenarios, including a 2°C or lower scenario. The pilot run scenario included nine sectors of the global economy in three countries, representing a cross-section of F&G’s physical and transition risk exposures across 21 securities. These securities were a high-level representation of F&G’s public asset ownership and real estate assets. The selection captured high-carbon positions to better understand those risks.
Three scenarios (orderly, disorderly, and hot house) were used in the assessment to evaluate expected risk under forward-looking climate scenarios. Orderly and Disorderly scenarios include transition and physical risk while Hot House captured physical risk only. Network for Greening the Financial System scenarios were leveraged for transition risk and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change scenarios were used for physical risk.
41
The Orderly scenario reflects an aggressive introduction of carbon pricing from 2030, which directly and negatively impacts the financials of those companies and sectors which are more carbon intensive. After the initial value decline, there is stabilization from 2030 onwards as the grid decarbonizes rapidly (reducing Scope 2 emissions for most companies).
The Disorderly scenario follows a similar profile to the Orderly scenario but there is little movement until 2030 when the delayed transition starts. At this point the value decline is very steep but flattens from 2035 onwards. Both Order and Disorderly arrive at a similar impact in 2050 by reaching net zero. In contrast, there is no transition risk in the Hot House scenario. In this scenario the only driver of value change is the impact of physical risks disrupting operations and/or causing damage to physical assets owned by individual companies. The impact is lower than the transition risk scenarios as physical risk becomes more significant in the modeling only after 2050, past the end point of the current scenario analysis.
For the pilot portfolio temperature alignment was calculated, aligning F&G’s pilot portfolio with a warming trajectory through 2050. The analysis also included an assessment of physical risk of three commercial properties held in the F&G portfolio. The evaluation included electricity and gas expenditures, outdoor labor costs, vulnerability to rising sea levels, and weather-related catastrophes.
The overall results of the pilot scenario analysis indicated larger impacts under the Orderly and Disorderly scenarios by 2050, as expected, highlighting energy-intensive industries. Utilities saw larger variability between the issuers, while energy and airlines saw more uniform impacts. Automobile manufacturers saw the largest impact and variability, while financials and structured products had smaller impacts.
F&G plans to use climate scenario analysis with the intention of expanding its assessments and looking for opportunities to better incorporate its investment and enterprise risk process over the next few years. The pilot results will aid in developing a comprehensive strategy related to climate risk, which includes a plan to conduct an overall scenario analysis on the investment portfolio and to assess transition risk by asset class and sector for the portfolio using different climate scenarios.
Risk Management
F&G’s ERM policy defines the approach to risk identification, risk assessment, and risk response. The ERMC owns the ERM Policy and is responsible for reviewing and approving the policy on an annual basis. Updates to the policy are determined by the ERM leadership team.
The ERM process includes a risk appetite statement which outlines the level of acceptable risk in the pursuit of overall financial and strategic objectives. Risk appetite statements and risk tolerances are linked to the strategic objectives set out in the corporate plan and are stressed using a variety of multifactor scenarios. Qualitative and quantitative approaches are used to manage risk appetite and are monitored as part of the strategy and planning process.
Risks are defined in the risk taxonomy, based on International Organization for Standardization (“ISO”) 31000, and captured in a risk library. The taxonomy includes four parent categories: Operational, Governance/Strategy, Product/Distribution, and Investments. These four parent categories are broken down further into 31 sub-categories (IMO/Agent Servicing, Business Continuity/Disaster Recovery, Third-Party Administration/Outsourcing, Fraud, Human Resources/People, Policy Administration, IT Systems, Information Security, Accounting and Financial Reporting, Actuarial and Governance Operations, Project Management, Model Risk, Compliance, Capital Management, Risk Management, Business Strategy, Corporate Governance, Marketing/Communications, ESG, Legal/Litigation, Regulatory Environment, Reputation, Pricing and Product Design, Product Governance, In-force Performance Management, Distribution, Asset Liability Management (“ALM”), Investment Guidelines and Compliance, Credit, Foreign Exchange, and Liquidity Risk). The library identifies risk ownership, corresponding risk limits, and high-level controls for monitoring, reporting, and mitigating material risks.
42
Risks are identified via ongoing discussions between ERM and the business partners, as well as through monitoring of industry groups and publications. New and emerging risks are reviewed at the ERMC and added to the risk register. Each quarter, ERM works with the risk owners to assess the impact and likelihood of each risk in the register to determine the inherent risk rating, and then apply a control assurance rating to identify the residual risk rating. The rating scales are three by three (low, medium, high). The quarterly self-assessment results are reported in the ERM dashboard to the ERMC. The dashboard reflects the residual risk ratings at the sub-category level for the Enterprise, and the direction the risk is trending (increasing, decreasing, stable).
F&G monitors risks via an annual risk assessment, the quarterly risk self-assessments, quarterly ERMC meetings, monthly Investment Committee meetings, monthly Capital Committee meetings, and ad hoc analysis. The overall risk posture of the organization is updated in the ERMC meeting report that includes a CRO assessment, emerging risks, ERM dashboard, market risk discussion, stress testing results, and risk appetite measures.
The development of an enterprise ESG program, including climate risks, is included in F&G’s 2023 ORSA summary report, and articulates the Management Committee’s responsibility for actively monitoring and focusing resources on ESG-related activities. Overall climate risk was deemed to be minimal by the ESG Steering Committee during a qualitative review of risks and opportunities based on the insurance-related products sold by F&G. As a life insurance and annuities company, physical climate risks that are material risks for property and casualty insurers are less impactful. Climate-related underwriting risk (mortality/morbidity) is monitored within the overall risk framework, although it is not considered material to F&G’s overall business.
F&G recognizes the rapidly evolving regulatory environment on climate-related risks and opportunities and has a regulatory monitoring process. The ongoing monitoring of ESG-related regulations is included in the overall regulatory monitoring process overseen by the Legal Department. Any new regulation passed related to ESG is entered into the Comply On Demand Enterprise system and assigned to subject matter experts for review. If policy or procedure changes are required, the implementation of those changes is monitored through this system.
Climate risks will be identified and assessed in accordance with the ERM Policy and managed through the ERM framework. The framework utilizes the three lines of defense model: Business/Operational Management, the ERM function (Risk Management), and Internal Audit.
The 1st line of defense develops and implements mitigation activities for risks in business activities and provides monitoring and reporting of such risks on an ongoing basis; the 2nd line of defense challenges and supports the 1st line of defense, while helping to identify activities to mitigate risks and advise on risk management activities. The 3rd line of defense provides management with independent, objective assurance of the overall effectiveness, and efficiency of the design and operation of internal controls.
The framework and process alignment includes utilization of committee structure to identify, assess, and prioritize risk to ensure both senior management and the board of directors understand and can manage the risk profile. Any changes in business trends as a result of climate change would be identified through Risk Management interaction with the 1st line of defense discussions and risk assessments. No material or significant changes due to climate change have been identified to date.
Investment risk is one of the largest sources of risk to the company, and the Deputy CRO - Investments with the Deputy Chief Investment Officer are responsible for integrating ESG, including understanding and managing climate-related risks, into F&G’s investment process. Our primary asset manager generally considers material ESG factors a key part of evaluating new investments. By considering applicable ESG factors in the investment process, they aim to identify and address material investment risks and opportunities. They also continuously monitor ESG related risks throughout the investment holding period and engage on certain focus areas such as Climate Risk, Diversity & Inclusion and good Corporate Governance.
43
Metrics and Targets
F&G is evaluating how climate-related metrics can be leveraged to better understand the potential risks and opportunities to our business. F&G anticipates conducting an expanded quantitative analysis of the investment portfolio, as well as considering other metrics and proactive contributions to reduce uncertainty, filling data gaps, and working with investment managers and other stakeholders to collect additional data about climate risks.
F&G anticipates gathering Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions in the coming year for additional office locations in New York, Bermuda and Cayman. F&G is also evaluating industry developments related to the available frameworks and methodologies to quantify and collect emissions to better understand our scope 3 emissions footprint.
F&G’s existing risk management framework includes various metrics to manage risks across the investment portfolio. F&G is currently assessing the development of climate-related targets to improve the existing risk management framework. Efforts will continue to develop and enhance key policies and statements to reflect our ongoing commitment to mitigating climate-related risk, including climate scenario analysis, and F&G will continue to monitor risks and opportunities related to our climate risk assessment.
Available Information
Our web address is www.fglife.com. Our electronic filings with the SEC (including all Annual Reports on Form 10-K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, Current Reports on Form 8-K, and if applicable, amendments to those reports) will be available free of charge on the website as soon as reasonably practicable after they are electronically filed with, or furnished to, the SEC. The information posted on our website is not incorporated into this document.
The SEC maintains a website that contains reports, proxy statements and other information about issuers, like us, that file electronically with the SEC. The address of that site is www.sec.gov.
44