−Removed: Various forms of data localization requirements or data transfer restrictions are also under consideration in other countries and jurisdictions, including the European Union.
−Removed: Anti-Money Laundering, Counter Financing of Terrorism, Economic Sanctions and Anti-Corruption.
−Removed: We are subject to anti-money laundering (“AML”) and counter-financing of terrorism (“CFT”) laws and regulations globally, including the U.S.
+Added: Anti-Money Laundering, Countering the Financing of Terrorism, Economic Sanctions and Anti-Corruption.
+Added: We are subject to anti-money laundering (“AML”) and countering the financing of terrorism (“CFT”) laws and regulations globally, including the U.S.
Bank Secrecy Act and the USA PATRIOT Act, as well as the various economic sanctions programs, including those imposed and administered by the U.S.
3 unchanged sentences
We take measures to prevent transactions that do not comply with OFAC and other applicable sanctions, including establishing a risk-based compliance program that has policies, procedures and controls designed to prevent us from having unlawful business dealings with prohibited countries, regions, individuals or entities.
−Removed: As part of this program, we obligate issuers and acquirers to comply with their local sanctions obligations and the U.S.
−Removed: sanctions programs, including requiring the screening of account holders and merchants, respectively, against OFAC sanctions lists (including the SDN List).
+Added: As part of this program, we obligate issuers and acquirers to comply with their local sanctions obligations and U.S.
+Added: and EU sanctions programs.
+Added: In the U.S., these obligations include requiring the screening of account holders and merchants, respectively, against OFAC sanctions lists (including the SDN List).
Iran and Syria have been identified by the U.S.
4 unchanged sentences
We have implemented policies, procedures and internal controls to proactively manage corruption risk.
−Removed: Financial Sector Oversight.
−Removed: We are or may be subject to regulations related to our role in the financial industry and our relationship with our financial institution customers.
−Removed: In addition, we are or may be subject to regulation by a number of agencies charged with oversight of, among other things, consumer protection, cybersecurity, financial and banking matters.
−Removed: The regulators have supervisory and independent examination authority as well as enforcement authority that we may be subject to because of the services we provide to financial institutions that issue and acquire our products.
Issuer and Acquirer Practices Legislation and Regulation.
4 unchanged sentences
Regulation of Internet, Digital Transactions and High-Risk Merchant Categories.
−Removed: Various jurisdictions have enacted or have proposed regulation related to internet transactions.
−Removed: The legislation applies to payments system participants, including us and our customers, and is implemented through a federal regulation.
+Added: Various jurisdictions have enacted or have proposed regulation related to internet transactions which applies to payments system participants, including us and our customers.
We may also be impacted by evolving laws surrounding gambling, including fantasy sports, as well as certain legally permissible but high-risk merchant categories, such as adult content, firearms, alcohol and tobacco.
−Removed: Privacy, Data and Information Security.
−Removed: Aspects of our operations or business are subject to increasingly complex privacy and data protection laws in the United States, the European Union and elsewhere around the world.
−Removed: For example, in the United States, we and our customers are respectively subject to Federal Trade Commission and federal banking agency information safeguarding requirements under the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act that require the maintenance of a written, comprehensive information security program.
−Removed: In the European Union, we are subject to the General Data Protection Regulation (the “GDPR”), which requires a comprehensive privacy and data protection program to protect the personal and sensitive data of EEA residents.
−Removed: A number of regulators and policymakers around the globe are using the GDPR as a reference to adopt new or updated privacy and data protection laws.
−Removed: Due to increasing data collection and data flows, numerous data breaches and security incidents as well as the use of emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, regulations in this area are constantly evolving with regulatory and legislative authorities in numerous parts of the world adopting proposals to regulate data and protect information.
−Removed: In addition, the interpretation and application of these privacy and data protection laws are often uncertain and in a state of flux, thus requiring constant monitoring for compliance.
+Added: Privacy, Data Protection, AI and Information Security.
+Added: Aspects of our operations or business are subject to increasingly complex and fragmented privacy, data and information security laws and regulations in the U.S., the EU and elsewhere around the world.
+Added: For example, in the U.S., we and our customers are respectively subject to, among other laws and regulations, Federal Trade Commission and federal banking agency information safeguarding requirements under the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (“GLBA”) that require, among other things, the maintenance of a written, comprehensive information security program and, increasingly, a number of state data and privacy laws.
+Added: With respect to information security, the U.S.
+Added: Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) adopted new disclosure rules that require, among other things, disclosing material cybersecurity incidents in a Current Report on Form 8-K, generally within four business days of determining an incident is material.
+Added: In the EU, we are subject to the General Data Protection Regulation (the “GDPR”) and its equivalent in the U.K., which requires, among other things, a comprehensive privacy, data protection and information security program to protect the personal and sensitive data of EEA residents.
+Added: Several regulators and policymakers around the globe use the GDPR as a reference to adopt new or updated privacy, data protection and information security laws and regulations, although divergences have occurred.
+Added: Laws and regulations in this area are constantly evolving due to several factors, including increasing data collection and data flows, numerous data breaches and security incidents, more sensitive data categories, and emerging technologies such as AI.
+Added: In addition, the interpretation and application of these privacy, data protection and information security laws and regulations are often uncertain and in a state of flux, thus requiring constant monitoring for compliance.
MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K 25
−Removed: Various jurisdictions have adopted or are increasingly considering adopting laws and regulations impacting our reporting on ESG governance, strategy, risk management and metrics and targets.
+Added: Various jurisdictions have adopted or are increasingly considering adopting laws and regulations impacting our reporting on ESG governance, strategy, risk management, metrics and targets, and results.
Regulations already adopted or being considered include required corporate reporting and disclosures on specific topics as well as broader ESG matters.
Specific topics include climate (such as the U.K.
−Removed: Streamlined Energy and Carbon Reporting, the European Union Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, or “EU CSRD”, and the SEC proposed rules related to climate change) and human rights (such as the European Union Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive).
−Removed: Broader ESG matters include other environmental matters, treatment of employees and diversity of workforce (such as the EU CSRD).
+Added: Streamlined Energy and Carbon Reporting, the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, or “EU CSRD”, and the SEC proposed rules related to climate change) and human rights (such as the EU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive).
+Added: Broader ESG matters include other environmental matters, treatment of employees and diversity of workforce (such as in the EU CSRD).
Additional Regulatory Developments.
−Removed: Various regulatory agencies also continue to examine a wide variety of issues that could impact us, including evolving laws surrounding buy-now-pay-later, digital currencies, marijuana, prepaid payroll cards, identity theft, account management guidelines, disclosure rules, security and marketing that would impact our customers directly.
+Added: Various regulatory agencies also continue to examine a wide variety of issues that could impact us, including evolving laws surrounding buy-now-pay-later, open banking, digital currencies, marijuana, prepaid payroll cards, identity theft, account management guidelines, disclosure rules and marketing.
Additional Information
7 unchanged sentences
You can also visit “Investor Alerts” in the investor relations section to enroll your email address to automatically receive email alerts and other information about Mastercard.
−Removed: Our annual report on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, current reports on Form 8-K and amendments to those reports are available for review, without charge, on the investor relations section of our corporate website as soon as reasonably practicable after they are filed with, or furnished to, the U.S.
−Removed: Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”).
−Removed: The information contained on our corporate website, including, but not limited to, our Corporate Sustainability Report, our Global Inclusion Report and our U.S.
+Added: Our annual report on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, current reports on Form 8-K and amendments to those reports are available for review, without charge, on the investor relations section of our corporate website as soon as reasonably practicable after they are filed with, or furnished to, the SEC.
+Added: The information contained on our corporate website, including, but not limited to, our Environmental, Social and Governance Report and our U.S.
Consolidated EEO-1 Report, is not incorporated by reference into this Report.
Our filings are also available electronically from the SEC at www.sec.gov.
+Added: 26 MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K
RISK HIGHLIGHTS
2 unchanged sentences
Preferential or Protective Government Actions Information Security and Operational Resilience Talent and Culture
−Removed: Privacy, Data and Security Stakeholder Relationships Acquisitions
+Added: Privacy, Data Protection, AI and Information Security
+Added: Stakeholder Relationships Acquisitions and Strategic Investments
Other Regulation Global Economic and Political Environment Settlement and Third-Party Obligations
Class A Common Stock and Governance Structure
−Removed: MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K 25
Legal and Regulatory
Payments Industry Regulation
−Removed: Global regulatory and legislative activity directly related to the payments industry may have a material adverse impact on our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: Jurisdictions increasingly have regulated or established and expanded authority over certain aspects of payments systems such as ours, or have sought to do so.
−Removed: These efforts established, and potentially further expand, obligations or restrictions with respect to the types of products and services that we may offer, the countries in which our integrated products and services may be used, the way we structure and operate our business and the types of consumers and merchants who can obtain or accept our products or services.
−Removed: New regulations and oversight could also relate to our clearing and settlement activities (including policies, procedures and requirements related to risk management, collateral, participant default, timely switching of financial transactions, and capital and financial resource).
−Removed: Several jurisdictions have also inquired about the network fees we charge to our customers (in some cases as part of broader market reviews of retail payments).
−Removed: Several central banks or similar regulatory bodies around the world have also increased, or are seeking to increase, their formal oversight of the electronic payments industry.
+Added: Global regulatory and legislative activity related to the payments industry may have a material adverse impact on our overall business and results of operations.
+Added: Central banks and similar regulatory bodies have increasingly established or further expanded their authority over certain aspects of payments systems such as ours, including obligations or restrictions with respect to the types of products and services that we may offer, the countries in which our products and services may be used, the way we structure and operate our business and the types of consumers and merchants who can obtain or accept our products or services.
+Added: Similarly, jurisdictions that regulate a particular product may consider extending their jurisdiction to other products.
+Added: For example, debit regulations could lead to regulation of credit products.
+Added: Moreover, several jurisdictions are demonstrating increased interest about the network fees we charge to our customers (in some cases as part of broader market reviews of retail payments), which could in the future lead to regulation of our network fees.
In several jurisdictions, we have been designated as a “systemically important payment system”, with other regulators considering similar designations.
−Removed: Parts of our business have also been deemed as a “specified service provider” and considered critical national infrastructure.
−Removed: These obligations, designations and restrictions result in heightened regulatory oversight and scrutiny.
−Removed: They may further expand and could conflict with each other as more jurisdictions impose oversight of payments systems.
−Removed: Moreover, these efforts may influence the approaches of other regulators around the world that are increasingly looking to replicate similar regulation of payments and other industries.
−Removed: Similarly, jurisdictions that regulate a particular product may extend their regulation to similar products (for example, debit regulations could lead to regulation of credit products or network fees).
−Removed: As a result, the risks to our business created by any one new law or regulation are magnified by the potential it has to be replicated in other jurisdictions or involve other products within any particular jurisdiction.
−Removed: The expansion of our products and services as part of our multi-rail strategy have also created the need for us to obtain new types and increasing numbers of regulatory licenses, resulting in increased supervision and additional compliance burdens distinct from those imposed on our core payment network activities.
+Added: This type of regulation and oversight is related to switching activities (authorization, clearing and settlement), and includes policies, procedures and requirements related to risk management, collateral, participant default, timely switching of financial transactions, and capital and financial resources.
+Added: Parts of our business have also been deemed as a “specified service provider” or considered “critical infrastructure”.
+Added: The impact to our business created by any new law, regulation or designation is magnified by the potential it has to be replicated in, or conflict with, other jurisdictions, or involve other products within any particular jurisdiction.
+Added: The expansion of our products and services as part of our multi-rail strategy has also created the need for us to obtain new types and increasing numbers of regulatory licenses, resulting in increased supervision and additional compliance burdens distinct from those imposed on our core payment network activities.
For example, certain of our subsidiaries maintain money transfer licenses to support certain activities.
2 unchanged sentences
As a result, customers could be less willing to participate in our payments system and/or use our other products or services, reduce the benefits offered in connection with the use of our products (making our products less desirable to consumers), reduce the volume of domestic and cross-border transactions or other operational metrics, disintermediate us, impact our profitability and/or limit our ability to innovate or offer differentiated products and services, all of which could materially and adversely impact our financial performance.
−Removed: In addition, any regulation that is enacted related to the type and level of network fees we charge our customers could also materially and adversely impact our results of operations.
+Added: In addition, any regulation that is enacted related to the type and level of network fees
+Added: MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K 27
+Added: we charge our customers could also materially and adversely impact our results of operations.
Regulators could also require us to obtain prior approval for changes to our system rules, procedures or operations, or could require customization with regard to such changes, which could negatively impact us.
−Removed: Such changes could lead to new or different criteria for participation in and access to our payments system by financial institutions or other customers.
Moreover, failure to comply with the laws and regulations to which we are subject could result in fines, sanctions, civil damages or other penalties, which could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations, as well as have an impact on our brand and reputation.
3 unchanged sentences
If interchange rates are too high, merchants may stop accepting our products or route transactions away from our network.
−Removed: If interchange rates are too low, issuers may stop promoting our integrated products and services, eliminate or reduce loyalty rewards programs or other account holder benefits (e.g., free checking or low interest rates on balances), or charge fees to account holders (e.g., annual fees or late payment fees).
−Removed: Governments and merchant groups in a number of countries have implemented or are seeking interchange rate reductions through legislation, competition law, central bank regulation and litigation.
+Added: If interchange rates are too low, issuers may stop promoting our products and services, eliminate or reduce loyalty rewards programs or other account holder benefits (e.g., free checking or low interest rates on balances), or charge fees to account holders (e.g., annual fees or late payment fees).
+Added: Governments and merchant groups in a number of countries have implemented or are seeking interchange rate reductions through legislation, regulation and litigation.
See “Business - Government Regulation” in Part I, Item 1 and Note 21 (Legal and Regulatory Proceedings) to the consolidated financial statements included in Part II, Item 8 for more details.
−Removed: 26 MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K
−Removed: If issuers cannot collect or we are required to reduce interchange rates, issuers may be less willing to participate in our four-party payments system, or may reduce the benefits offered in connection with the use of our products, reducing the attractiveness of our products to consumers.
−Removed: These and other impacts could lower transaction volumes, and/or make proprietary three-party networks or other forms of payment more attractive.
−Removed: Issuers could reduce the benefits associated with our products or choose to charge higher fees to consumers to attempt to recoup a portion of the costs incurred for their services.
−Removed: In addition, issuers could seek a fee reduction from us to decrease the expense of their payment programs, particularly if regulation has a disproportionate impact on us as compared to our competitors in terms of the fees we can charge.
−Removed: This could make our products less desirable to consumers, reduce the volume of transactions and our profitability, and limit our ability to innovate or offer differentiated products.
+Added: If issuers cannot collect or we are required to reduce interchange rates, issuers may be less willing to participate in our four-party payments system.
+Added: Alternatively, they may reduce the benefits associated with our products, choose to charge higher fees to consumers to attempt to recoup a portion of the costs incurred for their services, or seek a fee reduction from us to decrease the expense of their payment programs (particularly if regulation has a disproportionate impact on us as compared to our competitors in terms of the fees we can charge).
+Added: These and other impacts could make our products less desirable to consumers, limit our ability to innovate or offer differentiated products, and/or make proprietary three-party networks or other forms of payment more attractive, ultimately reducing the volume of transactions over our network and our profitability.
We are devoting substantial resources to defending our right to establish interchange rates in regulatory proceedings, litigation and legislative activity.
3 unchanged sentences
Limitations on our ability to restrict merchant surcharging could materially and adversely impact our results of operations.
−Removed: We have historically implemented policies, referred to as no-surcharge rules, in certain jurisdictions, including the United States and Canada, that prohibit merchants from charging higher prices to consumers who pay using our products instead of other means.
+Added: We have historically implemented policies, referred to as no-surcharge rules, in certain jurisdictions, including the U.S.
+Added: and Canada, that prohibit merchants from charging higher prices to consumers who pay using our products instead of other means.
Authorities in several jurisdictions have acted to end or limit the application of these no-surcharge rules (or indicated interest in doing so).
−Removed: Additionally, we have modified our no-surcharge rules to permit U.S.
−Removed: and Canadian merchants to surcharge credit cards, subject to certain limitations.
−Removed: It is possible that over time merchants in some or all merchant categories in these jurisdictions may choose to surcharge as permitted by the rule change.
+Added: Additionally, our no-surcharge rules now permit U.S.
+Added: and Canadian merchants to surcharge credit cards (subject to certain limitations), which over time could lead merchants in some or all merchant categories in these jurisdictions to choose to surcharge as permitted.
This could result in consumers viewing our products less favorably and/or using alternative means of payment instead of electronic products, which could result in a decrease in our overall transaction volumes, and which in turn could materially and adversely impact our results of operations.
4 unchanged sentences
• Governments in some countries have implemented, or may implement, regulatory requirements that mandate switching of domestic payments either entirely in that country or by only domestic companies.
−Removed: • Some jurisdictions have implemented, or are considering, requirements to collect, process and/or store data within their borders, as well as prohibitions on the transfer of data abroad, leading to technological and operational implications as well as increased compliance burdens and other costs.
+Added: • Some jurisdictions have implemented, or are considering, requirements to collect, store and/or process data within their borders, as well as prohibitions on the transfer of data abroad, leading to technological and operational implications as well as increased compliance burdens and other costs.
+Added: 28 MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K
• Geopolitical events (such as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine) and resulting OFAC sanctions, adverse trade policies, enforcement of U.S.
−Removed: laws related to counter financing of terrorism, economic sanctions and anti-corruption, or other types of government actions could lead affected or other jurisdictions to take actions in response that could adversely affect our business.
−Removed: Moreover, given our decision to suspend business operations in Russia, other separate jurisdictions may decide to increase their focus on growing local payment networks and other solutions.
−Removed: • Regional groups of countries are considering, or may consider, efforts to restrict our participation in the switching of regional transactions.
+Added: laws related to countering the financing of terrorism, economic sanctions and anti-corruption, or other types of government actions could lead affected or other jurisdictions to take actions in response that could adversely affect our business.
+Added: Moreover, given our decision to suspend business operations in Russia, other separate jurisdictions may decide to begin to or increase their focus on growing local payment networks and other solutions.
+Added: • Regional groups of countries are considering, or may consider, efforts to restrict our switching of regional transactions.
+Added: • Governments have been increasingly creating and expanding local payments structures (such as the Brazilian Instant Payment System-PIX, FedNow in the U.S.
+Added: and UPI in India), which are increasingly being considered as alternatives to traditional domestic payment solutions and schemes such as ours.
Such developments prevent us from utilizing our global switching capabilities for domestic or regional customers.
−Removed: In addition, to the extent a jurisdiction determines us not to be in compliance with regulatory requirements (including those related to data localization), we have, and may continue to be, subject to resource and time pressures in order to come back into compliance.
+Added: In addition, to the extent a jurisdiction determines us not to be in compliance with regulatory requirements (including those related to data localization), we have been, and may again in the future be, subject to resource and time pressures in order to come back into compliance.
Our inability to effect change in, or work with, these jurisdictions could adversely affect our ability to maintain or increase our revenues and extend our global brand.
1 unchanged sentence
Such restrictions could adversely impact our ability to compete in these markets.
−Removed: MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K 27
−Removed: Privacy, Data and Security
−Removed: Regulation of privacy, data, security and the digital economy could increase our costs, as well as negatively impact our growth.
−Removed: We are subject to increasingly complex regulations related to privacy, data and information security in the jurisdictions in which we do business.
−Removed: These regulations could result in negative impacts to our business.
−Removed: As we continue to develop integrated and personalized products and services to meet the needs of a changing marketplace (as well as acquire new companies), we have expanded our information profile through the collection of additional data from additional sources and across multiple channels.
−Removed: This expansion has amplified the impact of these regulations on our business.
−Removed: This regulation requires monitoring of and changes to our data practices in regard to the collection, use, disclosure, storage, transfer and/or protection of personal and sensitive information, as well as increased care in our data management, governance and quality practices.
−Removed: We are also subject to enhanced compliance and operational requirements in the European Union, and policymakers around the globe are or are considering adopting new or updated privacy laws that have resulted or could result in similar or stricter requirements in other jurisdictions.
−Removed: For example, some jurisdictions have implemented or are otherwise considering requirements to collect, process and/or store data within their borders, as well as prohibitions on the transfer of data abroad, leading to technological and operational implications.
−Removed: Other jurisdictions have adopted or are otherwise considering adopting sector-specific regulations for the payments industry, including forced data sharing requirements or additional verification requirements, as well as regulations on artificial intelligence and data governance, that overlap or conflict with, or diverge from, general privacy rules.
−Removed: Failure to comply with these laws, regulations and requirements could result in fines, sanctions or other penalties, which could materially and adversely affect our results of operations and overall business, as well as have an impact on our reputation.
−Removed: New requirements or changing interpretations of existing requirements in these areas, or the development of new regulatory schemes related to the digital economy in general, may also increase our costs and/or restrict our ability to leverage data for innovation.
+Added: Privacy, Data Protection, AI and Information Security
+Added: Regulation and enforcement of privacy, data, AI, information security and the digital economy could increase our costs and lead to legal claims and fines, as well as negatively impact our growth and reputation.
+Added: We are subject to increasingly complex, fragmented and divergent laws and regulations related to privacy and data protection, data use and governance, AI and information security in the jurisdictions in which we do business.
+Added: While policymakers around the globe look to the EU and the GDPR when adopting new or updated privacy and data protection laws, divergences have occurred and continue to occur.
+Added: As a result, new or updated privacy and data protection and information security laws and regulations have led, and may continue to lead, to similar, stricter or at times conflicting requirements, creating an uncertain regulatory environment.
+Added: For example, some jurisdictions have implemented or are otherwise considering requirements to collect, store and/or process data within their borders, as well as prohibitions on the transfer of data abroad, leading to technological and operational implications.
+Added: Other jurisdictions have adopted or are otherwise considering adopting sector-specific regulations for the payments industry and other industries in which we participate, including forced data sharing requirements or additional verification requirements.
+Added: In addition, laws and regulations on AI, data governance and credit decisioning may overlap or conflict with, or diverge from, general privacy rules.
+Added: Overall, these myriad laws and regulations may require us to modify our data processing practices and policies, incur substantial compliance-related costs and expenses, and otherwise suffer adverse impacts on our business.
+Added: Failure to comply with any of these laws, regulations and requirements could result in fines, sanctions or other enforcement actions or penalties, which could materially and adversely affect our results of operations and overall business, as well as have an impact on our reputation.
+Added: As a user and deployer of AI technology, we are also subject to increasing and evolving laws and regulations related to AI governance and new applications of existing laws and regulations to AI.
+Added: How our use and deployment of AI will be regulated remains uncertain given the uncertainty that exists as to how AI technology will develop.
+Added: In addition, the use of AI creates or amplifies risks that are challenging to fully prevent or mitigate.
+Added: In particular, AI algorithms may generate inaccurate, unintended, unfair or discriminatory outcomes, which may not be easily detectable or explainable, and may inadvertently breach intellectual property, privacy or other rights, as well as confidential information.
+Added: Our implementation of robust AI governance and risk management frameworks aimed at complying with emerging laws and regulations may not be sufficient protection against these emerging risks.
+Added: Further, as we acquire new companies and develop integrated and personalized products and services to meet the needs of a changing marketplace, we have expanded our data profile through additional data types and sources, across multiple channels, and involving new partners.
+Added: This expansion has amplified the impact of these various laws and regulations on our business.
+Added: As a result, we are required to constantly monitor our data practices and potentially change them when necessary or appropriate.
+Added: We also need to provide increased care in our data management, governance and quality practices, particularly as it relates to the use of data in products leveraging AI.
+Added: New requirements or changing interpretations of existing requirements in these areas, or the development of new regulatory schemes related to the digital economy in general, may also increase our costs and/or restrict our ability to leverage data or use AI for innovation.
This could impact the products and services we offer and other aspects of our business, such as fraud monitoring, the need for improved data management, governance and quality practices, the development of information-based products and solutions, and technology operations.
−Removed: In addition, these requirements may increase the costs to our customers of issuing payment products, which may, in turn, decrease the number of our payment products that they issue.
−Removed: Moreover, due to account data compromise events and privacy abuses by other companies, as well as the disclosure of monitoring activities by certain governmental agencies in combination with the use of artificial intelligence and new technologies, there has been heightened legislative and regulatory scrutiny around the world that could lead to further regulation and requirements and/or future enforcement.
−Removed: Those developments have also raised public attention on companies’ data practices and have changed consumer and societal expectations for enhanced privacy and data protection.
−Removed: While we make every effort to comply with all regulatory requirements and we deploy a Privacy by Design and Data by Design approach to all of our product development, the speed and pace of changes in laws (as well as stakeholder interests) may not allow us to meet rapidly evolving regulatory and stakeholder expectations.
+Added: In addition, these requirements may increase the costs to our customers of issuing payment
+Added: MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K 29
+Added: products or using information products, which may, in turn, decrease the number of our products that they offer.
+Added: While we intend to comply with all regulatory requirements, innovate responsibly and deploy Privacy by Design, Data by Design and AI Governance approaches to all of our product development, the speed and pace of changes in laws (as well as stakeholder interests) may not allow us to meet rapidly evolving regulatory and stakeholder expectations.
Any of these developments could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: In addition, fraudulent activity and increasing cyberattacks have encouraged legislative and regulatory intervention, and could damage our reputation and reduce the use and acceptance of our integrated products and services or increase our compliance costs.
−Removed: Criminals are using increasingly sophisticated methods to capture consumer personal information to engage in illegal activities such as counterfeiting or other fraud.
−Removed: As outsourcing and specialization become common in the payments industry, there are more third parties involved in processing transactions using our payment products.
−Removed: While we are taking measures to make card and digital payments more secure, increased fraud levels involving our integrated products and services, or misconduct or negligence by third parties switching or otherwise servicing our integrated products and services, could lead to legislative or regulatory intervention, such as enhanced security requirements and liabilities, as well as damage to our reputation.
Other Regulation
Regulations that directly or indirectly apply to Mastercard as a result of our participation in the global payments industry may materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: We are subject to regulations that affect the payments industry in the many jurisdictions in which our integrated products and services are used.
+Added: We are subject to regulations that affect the payments industry in the many jurisdictions in which our products and services are used.
Many of our customers are also subject to regulations applicable to banks and other financial institutions that, at times, consequently affect us.
1 unchanged sentence
Examples include:
−Removed: • Anti-Money Laundering, Counter Financing of Terrorism, Economic Sanctions and Anti-Corruption - We are subject to AML and CFT laws and regulations globally.
+Added: • Anti-Money Laundering, Countering the Financing of Terrorism, Economic Sanctions and Anti-Corruption - We are subject to AML and CFT laws and regulations globally.
Economic sanctions programs administered by OFAC restrict financial transactions and other dealings with certain countries and geographies, and persons and entities.
We are also subject to anti-corruption laws and regulations globally, which, among other things, generally prohibit giving or offering payments or anything of value for the purpose of improperly influencing a business decision or to gain an unfair business advantage.
−Removed: 28 MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K
• Account-based Payments Systems - In the U.K., aspects of our Vocalink business are subject to the U.K.
7 unchanged sentences
Additionally, our compliance with new economic sanctions and related laws with respect to particular jurisdictions or customers could result in a loss of business, which could be significant.
−Removed: Moreover, while our risk-based compliance program obligates issuers and acquirers to comply with their local sanctions programs (among other obligations), the failure of those issuers and acquirers to identify potential non-compliance issues either during or after their customer onboarding processes could ultimately impact our compliance with economic sanctions and related laws.
+Added: Moreover, while our risk-based compliance program obligates issuers and acquirers to comply with U.S., EU and local sanctions programs (among other obligations), the failure of those issuers and acquirers to identify potential non-compliance issues either during or after their customer onboarding processes could ultimately impact our compliance with economic sanctions and related laws.
Finally, failure to comply with the laws and regulations discussed above to which we are subject could result in fines, sanctions or other penalties.
5 unchanged sentences
jurisdictions.
−Removed: Current and potential future changes in existing tax laws, including regulatory guidance, are continuously being considered and have been or may be enacted (such as new guidelines issued by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) which could impact how multinational enterprises are taxed on their global profits).
−Removed: These changes have or may in the future impact our effective income tax rate and tax payments.
−Removed: Similarly, changes in tax laws and regulations that impact our customers and counterparties, or the economy generally, have and can continue to impact us as well.
+Added: Current and potential future changes in existing tax laws, including regulatory guidance, are continuously being considered and have been or may be enacted (such as guidelines issued by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) which impact how multinational enterprises are taxed on their global profits).
+Added: These changes have and in the future may continue to have an impact on our effective income tax rate and tax payments.
+Added: Similarly, changes in tax laws and regulations that impact our customers and counterparties, or the economy generally, have impacted and may continue to impact us as well.
In addition, tax laws and regulations are complex and subject to varying interpretations, and any significant failure to comply with applicable tax laws and regulations in all relevant jurisdictions could give rise to substantial penalties and liabilities.
Jurisdictions around the globe have also increased tax-related audits, which require time and resources to resolve.
−Removed: Any changes in enacted tax laws, rules or regulatory or judicial interpretations or guidance;
+Added: Any changes in enacted tax laws, rules, regulatory or judicial interpretations or guidance;
any adverse outcome in connection with tax audits in any jurisdiction;
or any changes in the pronouncements relating to accounting for income taxes could materially and adversely impact our effective income tax rate, tax payments, financial condition and results of operations.
+Added: 30 MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K
Liabilities we may incur or limitations on our business related to any litigation or litigation settlements could materially and adversely affect our results of operations.
1 unchanged sentence
In the event we are found liable in any material litigations or proceedings (particularly in a large class-action lawsuit or on the basis of an antitrust claim entitling the plaintiff to treble damages or under which we were jointly and severally liable), we could be subject to significant damages, which could have a material adverse impact on our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: Certain limitations have been placed on our business in recent years because of litigation and litigation settlements, such as changes to our no-surcharge rule in the United States and Canada.
+Added: Certain limitations have been placed on our business in recent years because of litigation and litigation settlements, such as changes to our no-surcharge rule in the U.S.
Any future limitations on our business resulting from the outcomes of any litigation or regulatory proceeding, including any changes to our rules or business practices, could impact our relationships with our customers, including reducing the volume of business that we do with them, which may materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K 29
Business and Operations
3 unchanged sentences
Our payment programs compete against competitors both within and outside of the global payments industry and compete in all payment categories, including paper-based payments and all forms of electronic payments.
−Removed: We compete against general purpose payments networks, debit and local networks, ACH and real-time account-based payments systems, alternative payments systems and new entrants (focused on online activity across various channels and processing payments using in-house capabilities), government-backed networks and digital currencies.
+Added: We compete against general purpose payments networks, debit and local networks, ACH and real-time account-based payments systems, digital wallets and other fintechs (focused on online activity across various channels and processing payments using in-house capabilities), government-backed networks and digital currencies.
We also face competition from companies that provide alternatives to our value-added services and new adjacent network capabilities (including open banking and digital identity).
1 unchanged sentence
They may also introduce their own innovative programs, value-added services and capabilities that adversely impact our growth.
−Removed: Certain of our competitors to our core payment network operate three-party payments systems with direct connections to both merchants and consumers and these competitors may derive competitive advantages from their business models.
+Added: Certain of our competitors to our core payment network operate three-party payments systems with direct connections to both merchants and consumers, potentially providing competitive advantages.
If we continue to attract more regulatory scrutiny than these competitors because we operate a four-party system, or we are regulated because of the system we operate in a way in which our competitors are not, we could lose business to these competitors.
See “Business - Competition” in Part I, Item 1.
−Removed: New entrants against whom we compete have developed alternative payments systems, e-commerce payments systems and payments systems for mobile devices, as well as physical store locations.
−Removed: A number of these new entrants rely principally on technology to support their services that provides cost advantages, and as a result may enjoy lower costs than we do, which could put us at a competitive disadvantage.
−Removed: Our ability to compete may also be affected by regulatory and legislative initiatives, as well as the outcomes of litigation, competition-related regulatory proceedings and central bank activity and legislative activity.
−Removed: Moreover, the suspension of our business operations in Russia may provide the opportunity for competitors to grow their business and increase their market share and relative competitive position in other jurisdictions.
+Added: Certain of our competitors have developed alternative payments systems, e-commerce payments systems and payments systems for mobile devices, as well as physical store locations.
+Added: A number of these competitors rely principally on technology to support their services that provides cost advantages, and as a result may enjoy lower costs than we do.
+Added: Many of these competitors are also able to use existing payment networks without being subject to many of the associated costs.
+Added: Moreover, these competitors also occupy various roles in the payments ecosystem that enable them to influence payment choice of other participants.
+Added: Any of these factors could put us at a competitive disadvantage.
+Added: Our ability to compete may also be affected by regulatory and legislative initiatives, as well as the outcomes of litigation, competition-related regulatory proceedings and both central bank and legislative activity.
If we are not able to differentiate ourselves from our competitors, drive value for our customers and/or effectively align our resources with our goals and objectives, we may not be able to compete effectively against these threats.
−Removed: Our failure to compete effectively against any of the foregoing competitive threats could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
+Added: Our failure to compete effectively against any of the foregoing threats could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
+Added: MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K 31
Disintermediation from stakeholders both within and outside of the payments value chain could harm our business.
4 unchanged sentences
Large scale consolidation within processors could result in these processors developing bilateral agreements or in some cases switching the entire transaction on their own network, thereby disintermediating us.
−Removed: • Industry participants continue to invest in and develop alternative capabilities, such as account-to-account payments, which could facilitate P2M transactions that compete with both our core payments network and our additional payment capabilities.
+Added: • Industry participants continue to invest in and develop alternative capabilities, such as account-based payments, which could facilitate P2M transactions that compete with both our core payment network and our additional payment capabilities.
• Regulation (such as PSD2 in the EEA) may disintermediate issuers by enabling third-party providers opportunities to route payment transactions away from our network and products and towards other forms of payment by offering account information or payment initiation services directly to those who currently use our products.
Such regulation may also provide these processors with the opportunity to commoditize the data that are included in the transactions they are servicing.
−Removed: If our customers are disintermediated in their business, we could face diminished demand for our integrated products and services.
+Added: If our customers are disintermediated in their business, we could face diminished demand for our products and services.
• Although we partner with fintechs and technology companies (such as digital players and mobile providers) that leverage our technology, platforms and networks to deliver their products, they could develop platforms or networks that disintermediate us from digital payments and impact our ability to compete in the digital economy.
−Removed: These companies may also develop products or
−Removed: 30 MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K
−Removed: services that compete with our customers within the payments ecosystem and, as a result, could diminish demand for our products and services.
+Added: These companies may also develop products or services that compete with our customers within the payments ecosystem and, as a result, could diminish demand for our products and services.
When we do partner with fintechs and technology companies, we face a heightened risk when we share data as part of those relationships.
While we share this data in a controlled manner subject to applicable anonymization and privacy and data standards, sharing this data without proper oversight could provide partners with a competitive advantage.
−Removed: • Competitors, customers, fintechs, technology companies, governments and other industry participants may develop products that compete with or replace value-added products and services we currently provide to support our switched transaction and payments offerings.
+Added: • Competitors, customers, fintechs, technology companies, governments and other industry participants may develop products that compete with or replace products and services we currently provide to support our switched transaction and payments offerings.
These products could either replace, or force us to change our pricing or practices, for these offerings.
4 unchanged sentences
In order to increase transaction volumes, enter new markets and expand our products and services, we seek to enter into business agreements with customers through which we offer incentives, pricing discounts and other support that promote our products.
−Removed: In order to stay competitive, we may have to increase the amount of these incentives and pricing discounts.
−Removed: We continue to experience pricing pressure.
−Removed: The demand from our customers for better pricing arrangements and greater rebates and incentives moderates our growth.
−Removed: We may not be able to continue our expansion strategy to switch additional transaction volumes or to provide additional services to our customers at levels sufficient to compensate for such lower fees or increased costs in the future, which could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
+Added: In order to stay competitive, we may have to increase the amount of these incentives and pricing discounts so as to meet customer demand for better pricing arrangements and greater rebates and incentives, which moderates our growth.
+Added: Our inability to switch additional transaction volumes or to provide additional services to our customers at levels sufficient to compensate for such lower fees or increased costs in the future could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations.
In addition, increased pressure on prices increases the importance of cost containment and productivity initiatives in areas other than those relating to customer incentives.
1 unchanged sentence
Some of our competitors are larger with greater financial resources and accordingly may be able to charge lower prices to our customers.
−Removed: In addition, to the extent that we offer discounts or incentives under such agreements, we will need to further increase transaction volumes or the amount of services provided thereunder in order to benefit incrementally from such agreements and to increase revenue and profit, and we may not be successful in doing so, particularly in the current regulatory environment.
+Added: In addition, to the extent that we offer discounts or incentives under such agreements, we will need to further increase transaction volumes or the amount of services provided in order to benefit from such agreements and to increase revenue and profit, and we may not be successful in doing so, particularly in the current regulatory environment.
Our customers also may implement cost reduction initiatives that reduce or eliminate payment product marketing or increase requests for greater incentives or greater cost stability.
These factors could have a material adverse impact on our overall business and results of operations.
−Removed: Additionally, we face pricing pressure related to real-time account-based payment schemes and cross-border payments.
−Removed: These pressures include the increased use of domestic real-time account-based payment schemes offering increasingly lower or subsidized pricing for P2M transactions as well as continued downward pressure on pricing for cross-border payments resulting from competition from real-time account-based payment schemes and from initiatives to lower the cost of cross-border payments to end users (such as the G20 Roadmap for Enhancing Cross-border Payments).
+Added: Additionally, we face pricing pressure related to real-time account-based payment schemes and cross-border payments (including the increased use of domestic real-time account-based payment schemes offering increasingly lower or subsidized pricing for P2M transactions as well as continued downward pressure on pricing for cross-border payments resulting from competition from real-time account-based payment schemes and from initiatives to lower the cost of cross-border payments to end users (such as the G20
+Added: 32 MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K
+Added: Roadmap for Enhancing Cross-border Payments)).
These factors could have a material adverse impact on our overall business and results of operations.
1 unchanged sentence
The payments industry is subject to rapid and significant technological changes, which can impact our business in several ways:
−Removed: • Technological changes, including continuing developments of technologies in the areas of smart cards and devices, contactless and mobile payments, e-commerce, cryptocurrency and blockchain technology, machine learning and AI, could result in new technologies that may be superior to, or render obsolete, the technologies we currently use in our programs and services.
−Removed: Moreover, these changes could result in new and innovative payment methods and products that could place us at a competitive disadvantage and that could reduce the use of our products.
+Added: • Technological changes (including continuing developments of technologies in the areas of smart cards and devices, contactless and mobile payments, e-commerce, cryptocurrency and blockchain, AI, machine learning, privacy enhancement and cybersecurity) could result in new technologies that may be superior to, or render obsolete, the technologies we currently use in our programs and services.
+Added: Moreover, these changes could result in new and innovative payment methods, products and services that could place us at a competitive disadvantage and that could reduce the use of our products and services.
• We rely in part on third parties (including some of our competitors and potential competitors) for the development of and access to new technologies.
The inability of these companies to keep pace with technological developments, or the acquisition of these companies by competitors, could negatively impact our offerings.
−Removed: MASTERCARD 2022 FORM 10-K 31
• Our ability to develop and adopt new services and technologies may be inhibited by industry-wide solutions and standards (such as those related to EMV, tokenization or other safety and security technologies), and by resistance from customers or merchants to such changes.
1 unchanged sentence
• Our ability to adopt these technologies can also be inhibited by intellectual property rights of third parties.
−Removed: We have received, and we may in the future receive, notices or inquiries from patent holders (for example, other operating companies or non-practicing entities) suggesting that we may be infringing certain patents or that we need to license the use of their patents to avoid infringement.
+Added: We have received, and we may in the future receive, notices or inquiries from patent holders (including operating companies or non-practicing entities) suggesting that we may be infringing patents or that we need to license the use of their patents to avoid infringement.
Such notices may, among other things, threaten litigation against us or our customers or demand significant license fees.
3 unchanged sentences
• Regulatory or government requirements have and could continue to require us to host and deliver certain products and services on-soil in certain markets, requiring us to alter our technology and delivery model, potentially resulting in additional expenses.
−Removed: • Various central banks are experimenting with digital currencies called Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs).
−Removed: CBDCs may be launched with their own networks to transfer money between participants.
+Added: • Various central banks are experimenting with CBDCs which may be launched with their own networks to transfer money between participants.
Policy and design considerations that governments adopt could impact the extent of our role in facilitating CBDC-based payment transactions, potentially impacting the transactions that we may process over our network.
5 unchanged sentences
For a discussion of the regulatory risks related to our real-time account-based payments platform and oversight by regulators, see our risk factor in “Risk Factors - Payments Industry Regulation” in this Part I, Item 1A.
−Removed: Furthermore, the complexity of this payment technology requires careful management to address security vulnerabilities that are different from those faced on our core payment network.
−Removed: Operational difficulties, such as the temporary unavailability of our services or products, or security breaches on our real-time account-based payments network could cause a loss of business for these products and services, result in potential liability for us and adversely affect our reputation.
−Removed: Working with new customers and end users as we expand our multi-rail solutions and integrated products and services can present operational and onboarding challenges, be costly and result in reputational damage if the new products or services do not perform as intended.
+Added: Furthermore, the complexity of this payment technology requires careful management to address information security vulnerabilities that are different from those faced on our core payment network.
+Added: Operational difficulties, such as the temporary unavailability of our services or products, or information security breaches on our real-time account-based payments network could cause a loss of business for these products and services, result in potential liability for us and adversely affect our reputation.
+Added: MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K 33
+Added: Working with new customers and end users as we expand our multi-rail solutions and products and services can present operational and onboarding challenges, be costly and result in reputational damage if the new products or services do not perform as intended.
The payments markets in which we compete are characterized by rapid technological change, new product introductions, evolving industry standards and changing customer and consumer needs.
−Removed: In order to remain competitive and meet the needs of the payments markets, we are continually involved in developing complex multi-rail solutions and diversifying our integrated products and services.
+Added: In order to remain competitive and meet the needs of the payments markets, we are continually involved in developing and implementing complex multi-rail solutions and diversifying our products and services.
These efforts carry the risks associated with any diversification initiative, including cost overruns, delays in delivery and performance problems.
−Removed: These projects also carry risks associated with working with different types of customers, for example organizations such as corporations that are not financial institutions and non-governmental organizations (“NGOs”), and end users other than those we have traditionally worked with.
−Removed: These differences may present new operational challenges in the development and implementation of our new products or services.
−Removed: These new customers are typically less regulated, and as a result, enhanced infrastructure and monitoring is required.
+Added: These projects also carry risks associated with working with different types of customers (such as corporations that are not financial institutions, non-governmental organizations (“NGOs”) and new end users).
+Added: These differences may present new operational challenges, such as enhanced infrastructure and monitoring for less regulated customers.
+Added: Our failure to effectively design and deliver these multi-rail solutions and products and services could make our other offerings less desirable to these customers, or put us at a competitive disadvantage.
+Added: In addition, if there is a delay in the implementation of our products or services (which could include compliance obligations, such as AML and CFT, and licensing requirements for our products and services that operate under regulatory licenses), if our products or services do not perform as anticipated, or we are unable to otherwise adequately anticipate risks related to new types of customers, we could face additional regulatory scrutiny, fines, sanctions or other penalties, which could materially and adversely affect our overall business and results of operations, as well as negatively impact our brand and reputation.
+Added: Information Security and Operational Resilience
+Added: Information security incidents or account data compromise events could disrupt our business, damage our reputation, increase our costs and cause losses.
+Added: Information security risks for payments and technology companies such as ours have significantly increased in recent years in part because of the proliferation of new technologies, the use of the Internet and telecommunications technologies to conduct financial transactions, and the increased sophistication and activities of organized crime, hackers, “hacktivists”, terrorists, nation-states, state-sponsored actors and other external parties.
+Added: These threats may derive from fraud or malice on the part of our employees or third parties, or may result from human error, software bugs, server malfunctions, software or hardware failure or other technological failure.
+Added: These threats include cyber-attacks such as computer viruses, denial-of-service attacks, malicious code (including ransomware), social-engineering attacks (including phishing attacks) or information security breaches and could lead to the misappropriation or loss of consumer account and other information and identity theft.
+Added: These types of threats have risen significantly due to a significant portion of our workforce working in a hybrid environment.
+Added: These threats also may be further enhanced in frequency or effectiveness through threat actors’ use of AI.
+Added: Our operations rely on the secure transmission, storage and other processing of confidential, proprietary, sensitive and personal information and technology in our computer systems and networks, as well as the systems of our third-party providers.
+Added: Our customers and other parties in the payments value chain, as well as account holders, rely on our digital technologies, computer systems, software and networks to conduct their operations.
+Added: In addition, to access our products and services, our customers and account holders increasingly use personal smartphones, tablet PCs and other mobile devices that may be beyond our control.
+Added: We, like other financial technology organizations, routinely are subject to cyber-threats and our technologies, systems and networks, as well as the systems of our third-party providers, have been subject to attempted cyber-attacks.
+Added: Because of our position in the payments value chain, we believe that we are likely to continue to be a target of such threats and attacks.
+Added: Geopolitical events and resulting government activity could also lead to information security threats and attacks by affected or sympathizing jurisdictions or other actors, which could put our information and assets at risk, as well as result in network disruption.
+Added: To date, we have not experienced any material impact relating to cyber-attacks or other information security breaches.
+Added: However, future attacks or breaches could lead to security breaches of the networks, systems (including third-party provider systems) or devices that our customers use to access our products and services, which in turn could result in the unauthorized disclosure, release, gathering, monitoring, misuse, loss or destruction of confidential, proprietary, sensitive and personal information (including account data information) or data security compromises.
+Added: Such attacks or breaches could also cause service interruptions, malfunctions or other failures in the physical infrastructure, networks or operations systems that support our business and customers (such as the lack of availability of our value-added services), as well as the operations of our customers or other third parties.
+Added: In addition, they could lead to damage to our reputation with our customers, other stakeholders and the broader payments ecosystem, additional costs to us (such as repairing systems, adding new personnel or protection technologies or compliance costs), regulatory penalties, financial losses to both us and our customers and partners and the loss of customers and business opportunities.
+Added: These consequences could be further pronounced in jurisdictions in which we are deemed critical national infrastructure.
+Added: If such attacks are not detected immediately, or disclosed as required by law, their effect could be compounded.
34 MASTERCARD 2023 FORM 10-K
Compared sentence by sentence after normalising whitespace, quotation marks, case and digits, so re-formatting and restated figures do not read as changed language. Wording changes appear as one removal and one addition. The current filing and the prior one are authoritative.